On flood-struck Washington Boulevard Monday, crews from the agencies responsible for the overtaxed sewers there began the job of cleaning and reinforcing the system, while the region's leadership started talking about potential solutions to Friday's calamity that caused four deaths.

Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority and Allegheny County Sanitary Authority officials met and identified potential short- and long-term fixes that ranged from emergency road closures during storms to raising Washington Boulevard above flood level.

Pittsburgh Councilman Patrick Dowd, a PWSA board member whose district includes part of the area that flooded Friday, said the only real solution was to rebuild the intersection of Washington and Allegheny River Boulevard, which currently forms "a dam" at one end of a vast topographic bowl.

"No matter how large the pipe is that you build, you're always going to have a storm at some point that is too big for it," he said.

Advertise with us

In this case, the large storm sewers running down Washington Boulevard -- 108 inches and 102 inches in diameter, respectively -- received too much water for the pipes near the Allegheny River to convey.

He said a 48-inch pipe carries water toward Alcosan's treatment plant beside the Ohio River and a 132-inch pipe carries overflow to the Allegheny River -- but that's not enough.

"The dam has to be broken and let the water naturally get to the rivers."

The flash flood that hit Friday afternoon occurred as more than 2 inches of rain fell in one hour in the watershed around Washington Boulevard, leaving motorists stranded in trapped vehicles.

Emergency workers rescued more than a dozen people from trees and the roofs of their vehicles. But a mother and her two children from Plum drowned inside their vehicle, and an Oakmont woman died when officials believe she was washed into a sewer and ended up on the bank of the Allegheny River, where her body was found Saturday.

Advertise with us

On Monday, vacuum trucks from PWSA and contractors prowled Washington Boulevard and Highland Drive, sucking dirt and debris out of clogged catch basins and culverts.

The basin at the intersection of Highland and Washington had gunk around 7 feet deep that workers said probably ran down a hillside from the site of Shuman Center and the federal Job Corps. Workers said the material likely accumulated over time when an inadequate silt fence allowed it to flow into the roadway.

The silt fence was replaced yesterday morning by Job Corps workers. The Job Corps local office referred a request for interviews to Department of Labor spokeswoman Joanna Hawkins, who said the agency would have no comment.

Job Corps doesn't have a permit for work at the site, and an inspector for an agency that administers erosion and sediment permits for the state Department of Environmental Protection visited the site Monday to see if it needs one.

PWSA spokeswoman Melissa Rubin said it's too early to point fingers.

Advertise with us

"We can't say why it occurred at this point," she said. "We are looking into that along with Alcosan, and that's something we're going to be studying over the next several weeks and months -- looking for short-term and long-term solutions."

Mr. Dowd said he reviewed video tapes of PWSA's lines taken on July 22, and they "were pristine" at that time.

Alcosan controls an underground diversion tank near the intersection of Washington and Allegheny River Boulevard. Workers yesterday began raising manhole covers that were below the grade of the surrounding ground, potentially allowing water to flow in through them.

The workers used concrete risers to boost the manhole covers by one foot, and they planned to encase them in concrete. They were delayed for hours when the risers originally provided proved to be too narrow by two inches.

"This was a 100-year storm, which our system is simply not designed to handle," Ms. Rubin said. "There is no system designed to handle a 100-year storm."

Advertise with us

Rain gauges monitored by 3 Rivers Wet Weather, which oversees efforts to address the region's sewer issues, show the watershed received 2.29 inches of rain in one hour beginning at 4 p.m., more than 3 inches for the day when a morning storm is included.

John Schombert, the agency's executive director, said that is considered a one-hour, 100-year event, something not statistically expected more than once in 100 years.

"There are over 3,000 acres of land that [drain into] that valley," he said. "This was a very localized, high-intensity storm. That's a phenomenal amount of rain."

He pointed out that at his office, a few miles away in Lawrenceville, the gauges measured just over 1 inch of rain during the afternoon storm and a gauge a couple of miles away at Sandy Creek Road in Penn Hills measured about a half-inch.

Some areas hit by Friday's storm also were devastated two years ago by another storm characterized in the same terms. Homes on Maryland Avenue, in nearby Shadyside, were flooded by a June 17, 2009, storm, and again on Friday.

Advertise with us

Their experience illustrates that there are no quick fixes.

The home of Jon Koteski saw $50,000 in damage two years ago when heavy rains overwhelmed sewers and caused a backup into their basement.

On Friday, said Mr. Koteski, "The pool of water in front of our house was 5 to 8 feet deep" and his basement filled with 2 feet of sewer water.

He said that in May, after another backup, City Councilman Bill Peduto's office helped arrange a meeting for him with PWSA officials, who pledged to address the problem.

Mayor Luke Ravenstahl's office did not respond to requests for an interview. Mr. Ravenstahl appoints the PWSA board and some members of the Alcosan board, and his Public Works Department is responsible for city road maintenance.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dowd said sewer lines from Wilkinsburg and Penn Hills, plus runoff from the hillsides on either side of Washington, turn the boulevard into a natural waterway.

He pointed out that the site where a woman and her two children were killed is around 15 feet lower than the intersection of Washington and Allegheny River Boulevard. He acknowledged that lowering the intersection or raising the boulevard would be expensive.

But he said that federal, state, county and local expertise and money could be brought to bear.

"We have to find a solution to this," he said.

The city authority and regional sewer agency met privately Monday to begin that process.

Advertise with us

In a news release, PWSA Chairman Dan Deasy said the meeting was an opportunity "to have an open discussion and share ideas."

The short-term possibilities include establishing a procedure for closing the road during an emergency, inspecting submerged pipes using robots, installing street signs warning of possible flooding and making sure manhole covers are identified by agency and location.

For the long term, ideas under consideration include installing a high-tech advance warning system with flashing lights and signs, building detention ponds, installing more catch basins and rebuilding Washington Boulevard.

Mr. Deasy called the flood deaths "a terrible tragedy" and vowed the agency will do "everything in our power to ensure this type of tragedy never happens again."

Arletta Scott Williams, executive director of Alcosan, said her agency will work cooperatively to determine a course of action.

"The grief, anger and demand for accountability is understandable. I am personally sickened by this tragedy," she said. "However, this is not the time to point fingers. Cooperatively determining if anything can be done in the future to mitigate problems is our focus."