It looks like the Pittsburgh City League won't be joining the Western Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic League anytime soon, mainly because of budget issues in the Pittsburgh Public Schools.
An athletics overhaul committee presented a plan to the district's education committee Tuesday night that would enhance athletics in the City League. Among recommendations the overhaul committee would like to see implemented quickly are:
• A change in how coaches are hired.
• A new academic policy for student eligibility in athletics and extracurricular activities.
• Initiatives to encourage more female participation in sports. An audit a year ago found the City League was lacking in some Title IX areas.
One of the other recommendations from the athletics committee was for the City League to disband and join the WPIAL. The original idea was for that to happen in the 2012-13 school year. But the athletics committee put the WPIAL idea under a category of "explore when financially/operationally feasible."
The committee has also suggested major upgrades in City League facilities and hiring an athletic/activities director for all nine high schools in the City League. But those plans also seem to be on hold because of financial constraints in the district.
"We're just in a different time and place [financially] than we were a year ago when this committee was formed," said Jake House, head of the athletics overhaul committee.
Superintendent Linda Lane said the next step is for the board to examine the recommendations and possibly vote on a few of them in June.
"Money is not the biggest issue with all of it," Ms. Lane said. "Any kind of facility renovations or adding athletic/activities director -- those are big-ticket items. But there are other low-cost things that potentially we could do soon."
The athletics overhaul committee, which included coaches, school athletic managers, school board members and school administrators, was formed in August to examine eight areas of City League athletics: coaching, facilities and equipment, participation (female and overall), transportation, scheduling, sportsmanship, connection to academics and wellness.
One of the recommendations from the committee is for the school board to modify hiring guidelines for coaches. Currently, coaching jobs must be given to district employees first. But the athletics committee recommended the best candidates should be hired. That would mean changing the district's collective bargaining agreement with the teachers union.
Also, the athletic committee recommends that students who have a grade-point average between 1.5 and 1.99 have a chance to play sports if they meet certain guidelines. The City League currently requires a 2.0 grade-point average to be eligible for athletics, which is much higher than minimum requirements established by the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association. Under PIAA guidelines, a student needs to be passing only four core courses to be eligible for athletics.
The proposed change in the academic eligibility policy was met with many questions from the district's education committee, which included school board members.
Board member Mark Brentley said lowering academic requirements for athletes was "racist." He suggested raising the minimum requirement to 2.5.
"The board policy committee will discuss [the 2.0 idea], and they'll have to make a recommendation to the board," Ms. Lane said. "In regards to the other recommendations, the next step is going to be to give the board more information. My feeling is there is going to be more discussion until any full recommendations come forward to the board."
Mr. House said: "My whole goal from the beginning was to give this process a voice, and I think we gave it a voice. There are still a lot of discussions to be done. As we learned during the process, there are strong opinions on both sides of every recommendation.
"We have to make changes because of the audit that was done on Title IX. It's the scope and sequence of changes that will be determined at a later date."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.