A 2 1/2-year court battle against Google Inc. that ended in a $1 consent judgment against the computer giant wasn't about the money.
So said Gregg R. Zegarelli, the attorney who represented two Franklin Park residents in their federal lawsuit spurred by a Google photography vehicle going down their private road. The formal legal proceedings ended Thursday when U.S. Magistrate Judge Cathy Bissoon accepted a consent judgment reached between Google and Aaron and Christine Boring, confirming that the company trespassed and the couple is due a dollar.
"Google is an intentional trespasser. There is a judgment against Google forevermore," Mr. Zegarelli said.
Whether that will affect the Googling of Earth is as yet unclear. The California-based firm said it has no intention of halting its practice of photographing streetscapes everywhere for its searchable Street View feature and emphasized the nominal amount of the judgment.
Mr. Zegarelli noted that the circumstances of the Borings' case are unusual: Google's vehicle was driven a thousand feet on a private road marked with no trespassing signs, where it took a picture, which was put online with millions of others, the vast majority of which were taken from public streets.
"If they do it again, arguably, they're a habitual trespasser," said Mr. Zegarelli, of the Downtown-based Technology & Entrepreneurial Ventures Law Group. "If they do it a third time, then they're arguably disregarding rights" and could be subjected to a significant penalty.
The big issue for the Borings -- Mr. Boring is a computer professional and Mrs. Boring is a schoolteacher, both in their 30s -- was the implication that Google can assemble unlimited data on people, Mr. Zegarelli said.
"Google is a private database being filled with data. Sooner or later, there will be releases of data from that or leaks of that data," he said of the company that began with search-engine technology and now touches many parts of the Internet browsing experience. "Does everybody want to live in a world where Google has that sort of a power over all of that information?"
Google's Street View cameras, he said, sometimes capture the insides of peoples' homes through open doors or the actions of people on the street.
Mr. Zegarelli said his clients considered early this year the possibility that they might lose and be subject to a bill for costs Google incurred defending their lawsuit. They opted to soldier on, submitting a vast information request before negotiating the consent judgment.
Mr. Zegarelli would not say whether the Borings had spent significant money on legal representation, but he said he is not asking Google to pay his costs or bills.
The Borings could not be reached for comment.
The Borings' lawsuit was dismissed in February 2009 by U.S. Magistrate Judge Amy Reynolds Hay, but one count -- accusing Google of trespassing -- was revived in January by the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The Borings then tried to get the U.S. Supreme Court to hear an appeal on the other counts, but the justices declined.
The trespassing count then went to Judge Bissoon.
"The Borings stuck it out against Google," Mr. Zegarelli said, "and they should really be commended for that."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.