The 14-month-old push to merge the City of Pittsburgh's government into Allegheny County won't get far without political unity, according to speakers at today's morning session of a day-long forum on consolidation that organizers hope will jump start a public education push.
"Consolidation is politically difficult," said Suzanne Leland, a professor of political science at the University of North Carolina-Charlotte who has been studying government mergers for years. "If Pittsburgh wants to go down this road, it is something that is going to have to go up against long odds, and it's going to be a political struggle."
That struggle was on display as city, county and suburban leaders followed the presentations by experts with a panel discussion before about 200 people at the Heinz History Center.
County Council President Rich Fitzgerald said he's for a city-county merger "conceptually, but if the details come out the wrong way, I won't be for it."
All nine city council members are "affirmatively for" consolidation, said City Council President Doug Shields. "However, it's not the consolidation that was put forward." They instead want "a city-county consolidation involving 130 municipalities and the government of Allegheny County. Other than that, you're not hitting the mark."
But suburban leaders seem to feel they're better off staying independent.
Stanley Louis Gorski, executive director of the South Hills Area Council of Governments, said COGs like his have already consolidated some services and much purchasing in the suburbs. "We are saving valuable resources, we are avoiding costs, and we are doing this without challenging the autonomy of the individual municipal governments," he said.
In April 2008, County Executive Dan Onorato and Mayor Luke Ravenstahl swung behind a report by a committee led by University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Mark Nordenberg that recommended a city-county merger that would leave out the suburbs. There has been no movement toward the state legislation that would be needed to allow a voter referendum on consolidation.
The Pittsburgh Foundation and the University of Pittsburgh Institute of Politics set up today's forum to revive the issue.
"This report came out a year ago," said Terry Miller, director of the Institute of Politics. "Then it went away. . . . We hope this is the beginning of a discussion."
Louisville, Ky., and Jefferson County made repeated stabs at consolidation before the "Vote yes for unity" campaign succeeded at the ballot box in 2000.
"Government consolidations represent the most complex conversation you are ever going to have with the electorate," said Joe Reagan, president and CEO of Louisville Metro Inc. So they simplified the message, got all major current and former elected leaders behind it, raised $1.6 million, created an organization and polled until they knew what every voter thought about the issue.
The creation of a Louisville Metro government, which didn't affect the suburbs, drove an attitudinal change. "The biggest benefit of merger is we just believe we can get anything done," said Charles Denny, chairman of the Louisville Chamber of Commerce. Big wins have included securing a United Parcel Service expansion and getting an auto plant retooled instead of closed.
Several speakers outlined a less dramatic path toward improving government: the steady melding of city, county and sometimes suburban functions.
Kim McMillan, communications director for Charlotte, said that North Carolina city made the latest of three runs at full merger with Mecklenburg County in 1996. The county council went along, but the city council did not, because of concerns about how city residents would be represented in the unified government.
So that city and county continued a 50-year effort to unite services, including policing and parks, and a trend toward privatizing or competitively bidding roles like waste collection, vehicle maintenance, street maintenance and water treatment. Ms. McMillan said that since 1994, the governments have saved $10 million by merging and contracting out services.
Miami-Dade County includes 35 cities and a large amount of unincorporated territory. In areas like trash collection, libraries and emergency services, the county contracts with some -- but not all -- of the cities to provide the service, said George M. Burgess, manager of that Florida city-county merged in 1957. In other areas, full consolidation has simplified matters for residents. For instance, a single 311 help line has replaced some 1,600 different customer service phone numbers for different functions in different Dade County cities.
Ms. Leland said that her research suggested there's no guarantee that any given type of merger will save taxpayer money or improve the economy, though the latter result happens more often than not.
Pittsburgh and Allegheny County are at the very beginning of what is often a decades-long discussion of the best means of improving government, she said.
"Structural consolidations are so difficult," she said. "Start with some small areas. . . . Where is there overlap? Where is there duplication?"
The forum's afternoon session, which is free and open to walk-up visitors, features the mayor, county executive and state legislators.
More details in tomorrow's Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.