Municipal primaries are always fights in the trenches, and nothing underscores that more than the old-time political battle in the city's South Hills, where City Councilman Jim Motznik beat his former friend and boss Michael Diven for an open district judge seat.

The two men were fighting over political turf that covers Brookline, where they both live, to Beechview, Duquesne Heights and Mount Washington. They also conjured old 19th Ward Democratic party battlegrounds going back decades, with court battles, political high jinks and personal animosity.

Mr. Motznik, 45, was formerly Mr. Diven's chief of staff on Pittsburgh City Council. He won the council seat when Mr. Diven went on to the state House, and stood by his former boss when he switched his registration to Republican after a battle with Democratic House leadership. The pair broke ties when Mr. Motznik supported Democrat Chelsa Wagner over Mr. Diven for the House seat in 2006.

Mr. Motznik raised five times as much money as Mr. Diven, and drew him into an embarrassing court battle over forged signatures inked on a petition a Diven aide left inside a Mount Washington bar. The aide was arrested for forgery, just as two Diven aides were caught up in a forgery probe in 2006.

Advertise with us

The pair was vying for the seat currently held by District Judge Charles McLaughlin, who retires at the end of the year. Mr. Motznik will also give up his District 4 council seat at the end of the year.

In this race, Mr. Diven, 39, attempted to use his fights against former House Speaker Bill DeWeese, House whip Mike Veon and other embattled Democratic leaders to make the case that he is a reformer who would serve well on the bench.

Mr. Motznik -- a former public works laborer before running for council -- said his council experience and ties to community leaders will help him judge the quality-of-life issues that commonly go before district judges.

Mr. Motznik was unopposed on the Republican side, meaning the race is all but wrapped up for him.