In the second of three rounds of televised debates last night, Luke Ravenstahl's two Democratic mayoral challengers took some of their hardest swings of the campaign at the 29-year-old incumbent -- on city contracting, budgets and even garbage cans -- but Mr. Ravenstahl deftly fought them off.

The Ravenstahl administration has been an "abomination" on the need for new city ethics rules and so-called pay-to-play contracting, City Councilman Patrick Dowd, 41, claimed. "This mayor is willing to sell off permits and sell off contracts to people who owe him favors, essentally," he claimed.

The KDKA-TV debate, which will be broadcast tomorrow at 7 p.m., was originally scheduled for April 15, but was called off after the fatal shootings of three police officers on April 4.

Carmen Robinson, 40, took the mayor to task for saying two weeks ago that he could not change his schedule to appear at last night's event. Although he eventually agreed to last night's taping.

Advertise with us

"Once public opinion said 'that's really bad,' he called here and said I only had one day [that he could appear]," said Ms. Robinson.

"We're here. Let's not waste our time talking about the past," Mr. Ravenstahl responded to the Hill District attorney.

Taking on Mr. Dowd's pay-to-play criticisms, Mr. Ravenstahl claimed the councilman took some campaign contributions from a vendor in early 2007, voted in favor of a contract for the contributor, then later took more money from the same vendor that summer.

"This is someobdy who talks out of one side of his mouth, then acts differently," Mr. Ravenstahl said.

"We're talking here about the future," Mr. Dowd responded. "You said let's not talk about the past."

Advertise with us

And so it went on a long night for three candidates with just 19 days before the Democratic primary. The evening began in Stanton Heights with a forum that was expected to be dominated by discussion of the April 4 shootings, but quickly turned into attacks on Mr. Ravenstahl, who was 45 minutes late.

Mr. Ravenstahl leapt into the fray when he got there. His foes, he said, "continuously talk about me and make this campaign about Luke Ravenstahl and my administration.

"I have chosen to make it about you," he told the few dozen people in the Sunnyside Elementary School auditorium.

Mr. Dowd said the mayor's administration "repeatedly accepted campaign contributions and then shortly thereafter provided permits ... contributions and contracts" to donors.

The mayor said Mr. Dowd only got interested in campaign finance reform after he joined the mayor's race.

Advertise with us

At the KDKA-TV debate, tough questions also came from moderator Ken Rice, who noted that Mr. Ravenstahl's campaign commercials say he faced the city's "fiscal situation head-on and made the tough decisions" to keep the budget sound. The new taxes and budget cuts that kept the city out of bankruptcy were really the work of state government, Mr. Rice noted.

Mr. Ravenstahl defended himself a bit but finally conceded the point. "It's not simply me. If that's somewhat misleading, I apologize," he said.

Mr. Dowd noted that Mr. Ravenstahl voted against the city's recovery plan twice as a North Side councilman in 2004. "Tough decisions were not made when the mayor was a city councilman. For him to sit here and tell you he has done [these] things is actually the most disingenuous thing you can imagine."

"He's full of half-truths," Ms. Robinson said. "You're right to point out he is not completely honest."

But Mr. Ravenstahl was poised throughout the attacks and gave as well as he took.

Advertise with us

When Mr. Dowd criticized the mayor for spending $250,000 on garbage cans instead of public safety, Mr. Ravenstahl's campaign manager -- sitting off camera -- pumped his right fist. The mayor was prepared -- with an e-mail Mr. Dowd's office had sent him, requesting help with garbage cans.

"When you suggestied garbage cans be purchased ... we responded," Mr. Ravenstahl said, before criticizing Mr. Dowd for politicizing the purchases.