In a fast-paced debate last night, the two Democratic primary challengers to Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl took repeated shots at his leadership and policies, but they found the incumbent prepared to defend his record.
The hour-long debate on WTAE-TV, the first of two planned televised face-offs, occasionally played out in the shadow of the April 4 killings of three police officers, with Mr. Ravenstahl, 29, touting the hiring of police and coming installation of security cameras, attorney Carmen Robinson, 40, highlighting her experience as a police sergeant, and Councilman Patrick Dowd, 41, talking about gun control.
In one exchange that epitomized the back-and-forth of the debate, Councilman Patrick Dowd said the mayor "did not provide any leadership" last year when he let legislation requiring that gun owners report the loss or theft of firearms become law without his signature.
Mr. Ravenstahl countered with a series of quotes from Mr. Dowd during council's debate on the measure, in which the councilman took what the mayor called "every possible position" before voting for it.
And Ms. Robinson argued that gun control was a feel-good measure. "Banning weapons will not make people feel safer, because we won't have guns, but the criminals will," she said.
WTAE anchor Wendy Bell led the question-and-answer session by raising the issue of violent crime. Last year saw the most city homicides in a decade.
"Today, we stand here with more police officers than we had in 2004," said Mr. Ravenstahl.
"We can't just keep throwing money at prisons and curfew centers and detention centers," said Ms. Robinson, arguing that the dollars should go to community centers.
"Let's get serious about truancy and dropout rates," said Mr. Dowd, a former school board member who said he'd be best positioned to work with the district. He said the city needs "many, many more" charter schools.
Mr. Ravenstahl noted that he was criticized in his 2007 campaign for proposing the Pittsburgh Promise for college tuition aid without showing how he'd pay for it, but the program is now on its way toward its funding goals, thanks largely to the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.
"The Pittsburgh Promise doesn't go far enough," said Ms. Robinson. "It has to target middle schools" with efforts to get kids on a college track earlier.
So it went, on issue after issue, with Ms. Robinson seated between the two men.
On the city's finances, Mr. Ravenstahl noted that in 2004 the city was "on the brink of bankruptcy." But now, even as other cities struggle with deficits, it's got around $100 million in the bank and is getting credit rating upgrades.
Mr. Dowd shot back that the surplus was accumulated on the backs of senior citizens that don't get the tax cuts they should, and residents who must deal with a crumbling infrastructure.
And Ms. Robinson said the city's "neighborhoods have been neglected, severely," while the administration uses "carnival tactics" to try to lure new residents.
Mr. Ravenstahl cited his cuts -- driven in part by state mandates -- in parking and business taxes. But in response to a question submitted by suburban resident, he said the $52-per-year levy on those who work in the city "should be higher" given the expenses of keeping the city safe for both its residents and commuters.
He touted his administration's work on keeping companies like Pittsburgh Brewing operating in the city, saying his development philosophy is to "protect those that are here" rather than "looking for the big fish elsewhere."
Mr. Dowd said there should be more "reaching out beyond the city and region" even as his administration would encourage promising local companies. "We need to make sure that we're building the next Pepsi here in Pittsburgh."
Ms. Robinson said her development efforts would target "the moms and pops in the city of Pittsburgh."
Mr. Dowd's sharpest attack came when asked whether there is a "pay to play" culture in city government, in which those who want contracts or city aid must make campaign contributions.
"The evidence is abounding, and it's most unfortunate," he said.
"We don't have to indict or convict Mayor Ravenstahl to show that Pittsburgh has an air of pay-to-play politics," said Ms. Robinson. Voters "do believe that the city is for sale, that that [mayor's] office is for sale to the highest bidder."
Mr. Ravenstahl said he has already banned most no-bid contracting and signed on to a package of contracting and campaign finance reforms announced by Councilman William Peduto yesterday. He noted that last year he put Mr. Dowd on a commission that's bringing the best contracting policies to the city, adding that it happened at a time when the councilman was "more interested in working with people than in playing politics."
"He's chosen to make his campaign about me," said Mr. Ravenstahl, after the debate, when asked about Mr. Dowd's criticisms. "I've instead chosen to make this campaign about the issues and about what the future of this city holds, and I believe and would ask him in the upcoming days to focus on what's important for the people of the city."
"If you don't have a negative record, then you don't get hit with shots," said Mr. Dowd, post-debate. "He's got a very negative record."
Ms. Robinson said she didn't mind being "caught in the crossfire" in a race that has, until last night, consisted mostly of the mayor and councilman "talking to each other" while ignoring her.
The second and final broadcast debate will be on WPXI-TV on May 4. The primary is May 19.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.