Judy Neelan of Shaler said she might have "stayed for an hour" if she'd had to pay to park Downtown yesterday.
But with free parking all day at Pittsburgh Parking Authority garages, she decided to take her time, do some shopping and see the holiday sights with her daughter Jennifer Neelan, and grandchildren, Bridget Sweeney, 7, and Calley and Madelyn Neelan,7 and 5 respectively.
"It was very much a draw," Ms. Neelan said.
That sentiment is music to the ears of parking officials and Downtown merchants who support the free Saturday parking program in the run-up to Christmas. But nobody knows for sure how successful the program has been in hooking shoppers.
Revelers at the ice rink at PPG Place and those lined up for free carriage rides nearby had no shopping bags in hand.
Some of those Downtown yesterday said they would have come with or without free parking. Others didn't know about the program or said it was still more convenient to travel by bus or to be dropped off.
"It takes away an excuse that people can use for not coming Downtown and it encourages them to come Downtown," said David Onorato, executive director of the Parking Authority. "I do feel it is perceived as a good thing."
The authority decided to offer free parking on Valentine's Day and the Saturdays during the holiday shopping season in lieu of reducing rates year-round to reflect a small cut in the parking tax, from 50 percent to 45 percent.
On the Friday after Thanksgiving, the first day free parking was offered, the number of tickets dispensed at the garages increased by 1,600 over the same day on the previous year. The next day, also a free parking day, the number jumped by 1,400 over the same Saturday last year. On Dec. 1, there was an increase of 364.
But Mr. Onorato said it's almost impossible to tell how much of the increase is due to free parking and how much is the result of other events Downtown.
Clayton Grabb of Butler and his daughter, Emily 8, capitalized on the free parking yesterday but didn't really have shopping on their itinerary.
Instead, their annual father-daughter holiday outing included visits to the ice rink at PPG Place, the creche at U.S. Steel Plaza and an incline ride to Mount Washington. Mr. Grabb said breakfast, lunch and dinner also were planned.
"The free parking helps a lot," he said.
Some Macy's shoppers said they'd park in the department store garage and use the covered walkway to get to the store. They said they planned to spend enough money -- $50 -- to have the parking validated.
"We've already spent a lot of money," Amy Medvid of Moon said around noon. She was shopping with her children, Jackie, 9, and Parker, 5, and their grandmother, Debbie Medvid of Cecil.
The eight city garages that are part of the free-parking program contain a total of 5,800 spaces. On the first three free-parking days, those garages issued between 5,200 and 5,900 tickets, compared to 3,500 to 5,500 tickets on the three same days last year. The busiest garages were Fort Duquesne and Sixth; Mellon Square; 9th and Penn; and Smithfield and Liberty. All are close to shopping and the Cultural District.
But Mr. Onorato pointed out that Black Friday -- the Friday after Thanksgiving -- also was the day the WPIAL football championship games were played at Heinz Field. That Saturday, the University of Pittsburgh played South Florida on the same field. The games could have had an impact.
The weather can be a factor on turnout, too. "Part of the attraction here today is it's really not cold," Ms. Neelan said.
Supportive merchants
With vehicle traffic at the city garages only an indirect measure of the impact of free parking on shopping, officials and retailers point to anecdotal evidence of the program's success.
"Do I have a statistically valid number for you? No," said Tom Michael, president of Larrimor's, the upscale clothing store on Grant Street.
But he's confident that free parking is fueling sales, saying, "People are talking about it."
Mr. Michael also sees a snowball effect in which various amenities are boosting retailers' seasonal business. He said restaurants and other attractions help make Downtown the "biggest mall" in the area.
"They're ice skating, and they're shopping, and they're having coffee, and they're having dinner and going to the Cultural Trust," he said of people on Downtown streets yesterday.
Take the Medvids, whose fun began at Macy's breakfast and "Santa Show." Then Jackie and Parker took part in a children-only shopping experience, aided by mom's credit cards and Macy's elves. The family also admired Macy's window displays, which tell the tale of Cinderella this season.
Amy Medvid said she wanted her children to have the holiday season "Downtown experience" that she did while growing up. She said the family would have made the traditional excursion regardless of the parking situation.
Jack Cohen, owner of S.W. Randall Toyes & Giftes, said his Downtown store was busier on the first two Saturdays free parking was available than it was on the same Saturdays a year ago. Last weekend, the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust sponsored the Kids Holiday Crawl Downtown, and the Saturday before, the annual holiday parade took place.
While Mr. Cohen can't say for sure whether the free parking or the events or some combination are the reason for the increase, he said he has heard from customers who appreciate what the city is doing. He even has signs in his window advertising the free parking.
"It's such a good incentive. I'm glad for that. It never occurred to me they would ever do that. This has been very good, though," he said.
Hollie Plevyak, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership's vice president of marketing and communications, said that not counting this weekend, 4,420 people had ridden the Holly Trolley that circulates Downtown on Saturdays and Sundays during the holiday season, 42 more than during the same period last year.
More than 3,000 of those rode on the Saturdays that free parking was offered, compared to 834 people on Saturday, Nov. 17, when it wasn't. She also said there has been a big demand from merchants for signs the partnership provides that advertise the free parking and that some businesses have called to say they have experienced increases in traffic.
Carriage rides offered from Oxford Centre also have been in great demand. One couple got engaged on a carriage ride last weekend and another proposal was expected this weekend, Ms. Plevyak said.
"There seems to be a little bit more of a buzz, so we feel good about it. We don't have a lot of stats or figures, but overall people seem to be enjoying it."
Partnership President and CEO Mike Edwards experienced that buzz for himself last weekend, when he and his family went Downtown. He said the Mellon Square parking garage was packed on Saturday and there were lots of people shopping.
The free parking and new development "have given people a sense there's something maybe they should check out Downtown," he said.
The final two free parking Saturdays will be Dec. 15 and Dec. 22.
Larrimor's Mr. Michael will be sorry to see it go. He'd like to see the program expanded, perhaps with free parking once a month after the holiday season.
"As a retailer, we support it," he said. "We think it's a great initiative."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.