The new arena should not significantly increase traffic congestion or create major parking problems for Hill District residents or others, two studies have concluded.
By 2020, the studies say, there still should be a surplus of spaces available at garages and lots Downtown and near the new arena even during sold-out events in the building, which will have 1,300 more seats than the 16,900-seat Mellon Arena.
And while traffic congestion may increase on Forbes and Fifth avenues and Bedford Avenue and Washington Place near the new arena, there won't be a need for major street improvements, other than a new traffic light on Centre Avenue near a proposed parking garage and the tweaking of the timing and phasing of traffic signals in the Hill and Uptown.
The results of the studies, paid for by the Penguins and done by Walker Parking Consultants and Trans Associates, with city oversight, were detailed yesterday during the first two focus group meetings involving the new arena, both of which generated considerable discussion.
Walker estimated that, even with the elimination of 2,400 spaces at Mellon Arena, once the site is redeveloped, there still should be a surplus of 1,938 spaces in the vicinity of the new building during a sold-out weeknight event.
And while residents in the Hill may see an increase in parking in their neighborhood during arena events, the impact should be "negligible" and "mitigated quite easily," city transportation planner Sidney Kaikai said.
Toward that end, the Walker study recommended that the city beef up enforcement of residential parking permit programs in the Hill adjacent to the arena and shorten or eliminate the grace period extended to nonresidents who park in the neighborhood.
The study not only took into account a new 500-car garage planned by the Penguins at the arena site between Centre and Fifth avenues, but also counted nearby garages, including those at the Marriott Hotel, U.S. Steel Tower and Manor Building.
It estimated there are 11,256 spaces near Mellon Arena and "fringe" garages and lots. That will drop to 11,033 after the new building is completed and the Mellon Arena site is developed.
Don Carter, president of Urban Design Associates, the architectural firm spearheading the focus group sessions, said one advantage to the new arena site is that it is about a block and a half closer to Downtown.
As a result, planners are expecting more Penguins fans and others attending events to park at garages Downtown because of the relatively short walk to the venue, making up for many of the spaces lost at Mellon Arena.
"We're expecting that more people will park in Downtown than park now. So that will take the pressure off the Hill District and account for some of the spaces you lose on the existing arena lot," Mr. Carter said.
Some people were skeptical.
Jet Lafean of the Schenley Farms Neighborhood Watch said illegal parking has increased in the Schenley Farms area and other parts of Oakland after the construction of Schenley Plaza eliminated a parking lot between the Hillman and Carnegie libraries. He fears the same will happen in the Hill.
Bette Lloyd, a Hill resident, said that the city's residential permit parking program needed to be extended deeper into her neighborhood to prevent illegal parking during events.
Bomani Howze, vice chairman of the One Hill CBA Coalition, also urged planners and consultants to expand the traffic study to include all of the Hill, not just the area around the arena, and to consider the impact on Fifth up to the Birmingham Bridge.
Others raised concerns about current congestion -- and the potential for more -- on Bedford Avenue near Mellon Arena and other parts of the Hill. George Moses, a member of the Hill District Consensus Group, said an independent traffic study should be done.
The Trans Associates study said "no significant increases in congestion" were expected from the new arena, adding that the new traffic light, tweaking the timing and phasing of existing lights, and other minor improvements should be enough to mitigate problems.
Nonetheless, Marimba Milliones, a Hill resident representing community interests in the planning process, suggested that another study be done after the arena opens "so we can measure results against what was projected."
Yesterday's two focus meetings drew almost 100 people, with nearly 60 of those attending an evening session at Duquesne University. There will be five more focus group meetings, followed by a public meeting Aug. 28 to discuss results of the seven sessions.
Besides traffic, other issues discussed yesterday ranged from pedestrian and disabled access, to possible retail space on Fifth and Centre avenues, to minority employment and potential community benefits.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.