Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl yesterday promised a fast-track overhaul of the police procedures that allowed for promotion of men accused of domestic abuse, addressing concerns of women's groups but risking a run-in with the police union.

Photographer, Post-Gazette

Above: Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board: "Absent any kinds of guidelines or parameters ... there's no reason to disqualify anyone for a promotion."

Below: Marsha V. Hinton, chairwoman of the police review board: "Where are these policies Where is the movement? We need more of a follow-up."

Advertise with us

Click photos for larger image.

Reader Forum

What do you think about the controversy over promotions in the City of Pittsburgh Police Department? Send your comments to postscript@post-gazette.com. Please include your full name and hometown.

Read comments

Breaking his near-silence a week after news media reported that three of four officers upgraded in rank June 18 faced domestic allegations, he said existing procedures are "obsolete and unacceptable."

Advertise with us

He did not rule out reversing one or more promotions.

"It's something that will be considered over the next couple of days," he said.

Any reversal, or change in procedure, would prompt the Fraternal Order of Police to "file every kind of an action I could to stop him from tampering with state civil service law," said union President James Malloy.

The mayor is "getting pressure, probably from women's groups, and now he wants to crawfish and go back the other way," he said. "That's a sign of immaturity."

Mr. Ravenstahl said he knew of the well-publicized accusation that freshly minted Cmdr. George Trosky broke his then-wife's nose in 1997. An assault charge was dropped when the ex-wife did not show up in court.

Advertise with us

He said he did not know prior to the promotion ceremony that new Lt. Charles Rodriguez faced a pending criminal case in Ingram, where police charged him with simple assault for an April incident with his daughter. Nor was he aware, he said, that police responded to now-Sgt. Eugene F. Hlavac's home in relation to arguments with his girlfriend.

"I'm upset that I didn't know, and I let the chief know that he should have communicated that to me," the mayor said.

Pittsburgh Police Chief Nate Harper left the mayor's office after an hourlong meeting yesterday. He declined comment.

The mayor said his hands are tied on most promotions.

"Sergeants and lieutenants are promoted now without the ability for the mayor to say yes or no, either way," Mr. Ravenstahl said. He added that had the city not promoted Lt. Rodriguez and Sgt. Hlavac, who were next on the civil service lists for their respective posts, "the potential would have existed for legal ramification."

Advertise with us

That's not true, said Mr. Malloy.

"He had the power to pass over any one of those people who were promoted. That's an absolute right that's unappealable by the FOP or the police officer," he said.

Civil service rules require that promotions be made from a list of qualified candidates ranked by a mixture of test scores and experience. When one position is open, the chief can pick from the top four candidates on the list. When two positions are open, the chief can choose from the top five.

"You're on the list, and that's the way it goes," said Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board Executive Director Elizabeth Pittinger, who was in the meeting with the chief. "And absent any kinds of guidelines or parameters in which the chief can exercise discretion, there's no reason to disqualify anyone for a promotion."

If someone is passed over three times, they are bumped to the bottom of the list.

Advertise with us

"Our goal, as a city, and my administration, and the Police Bureau, is to have a zero tolerance policy on domestic abuse and violence," the mayor said. The question is whether that policy would be triggered by a complaint with the city's review board or Office of Municipal Investigations, a conviction, or some other event.

He intends to develop criteria for bypassing candidates following a meeting with members of the Allegheny County and City of Pittsburgh Women's Commission today, and a televised hearing before City Council tomorrow.

The women's commission chairwoman, Cynthia McCormick, is also a member of the city Civil Service Commission. In January, hers was the lone vote on the three-member civil service panel against a rule change allowing detectives to become commanders, clearing the way for Cmdr. Trosky's promotion.

Councilman William Peduto urged the mayor to lobby the commission to reverse its decision to allow detectives to jump to commander.

Deputy Police Chief Paul Donaldson said Thursday that he had information he could not release that undercut the domestic abuse charges.

Advertise with us

Yesterday Philip Dacey, a retired lieutenant at the East Liberty station who was acting commander earlier this year, detailed two police visits to Sgt. Hlavac's East Liberty apartment.

After the second incident, Sgt. Hlavac was transferred to the Hill District station. Mr. Dacey said he informed Assistant Chief William Bochter and Deputy Chief Donaldson about what he perceived as Sgt. Hlavac's "anger issue. ... I would get calls from people at the [Waterworks] mall that he would just lose his cool over little stuff, over a traffic ticket, people not moving fast enough."

Sgt. Hlavac has received disciplinary action reports over several incidents during the past several years. Last year, he was written up for being insubordinate to Sgt. Carol Ehlinger, Mr. Dacey said.

Sgt. Ehlinger, Sgt. Hlavac and Lt. Rodriguez declined comment. Cmdr. Trosky could not be reached.

Mr. Dacey also said Sgt. Hlavac was the subject of a complaint to the Office of Municipal Investigations for cursing at bicyclists during a mass outing of riders in East Liberty to assert equal rights on the road. Video of the incident is on YouTube.com.

Advertise with us

At a review board meeting last night, Ms. Pittinger said Chief Harper on two occasions, including their earlier meeting with the mayor, had expressed interest in formulating a "zero tolerance" policy in regard to police officers involved in domestic abuse incidents.

She said he is considering adopting a model touted by The International Association of Chiefs of Police as well as adding some of his own restrictions and procedures.

Ms. Pittinger also said the chief was interested in ensuring the policy had "checks and balances" in place to mete out appropriate punishment for offending officers as well as specific rules for promotions that would bar candidates with domestic violence histories from advancing.

Marsha V. Hinton, chairwoman of the police review board, echoed Ms. Pittinger's sentiments, but added they have requested policy revisions for other issues in the past that police have failed to deliver. She noted that there had been no revision of a high speed chase policy as promised after two people were killed in Homewood after a chase last year.

"Where are these policies?" she asked. "Where is the movement? We need more of a follow-up."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.