Pittsburgh Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle, now the subject of a 17-count criminal complaint, continued to make maximum use of her city discretionary account last year, even as a prosecutor and grand jury probed her use of consultants from 2003 through 2005.
She also tapped her campaign account, which is the focus of some allegations against her, as personal financial problems mounted.
The allegations leveled by Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.'s office and a county grand jury, include counts of theft by deception, conspiracy, and violations of state ethics and campaign codes.
All relate to some 63 transactions in which, according to the grand jury's report, Ms. Carlisle paid city funds to Sheryl Pinson-Smith, Darlene Durham and Lee Otto Johnson as consultants, and then shortly thereafter deposited smaller amounts into her personal or campaign bank accounts. The grand jury's report called it a "kickback" arrangement.
Ms. Carlisle could not be reached for comment yesterday, and her attorney, Patrick Thomassey, described her mood as "subdued."
"She's very worried about it," he said. "These are serious allegations."
City spending records show that Ms. Carlisle continued to pay sums to consultants throughout last year, including $3,565 to Ms. Pinson-Smith, 48, of Lawrenceville, who later became an employee of the councilwoman's office.
Ms. Carlisle spent $17,784 in council discretionary funds last year, more than double the $8,010 limit in the city budget, making up for it by spending less than budgeted on staff salaries.
Of that spending, some went to neighborhood groups like Garfield Youth Sports and some went to office equipment companies. But she also spent $2,938 in city funds on draperies, and reimbursed herself $407.82 for expenses reportedly related to a district office.
Ms. Carlisle took $1,805 -- the maximum allowable under City Council rules -- as reimbursement for business miles driven in a personal car last year.
Her campaign fund, meanwhile, made $1,060 in payments to her last year, according to disclosures filed with the Allegheny County Elections Division, including $250 described as "misc/loan."
It is normal for public officials to make loans to their campaign accounts, but unusual for them to borrow from the funds that are only for use in running for office.
The campaign fund also made two payments totaling $375 for out-of-pocket costs associated with an unnamed attorney in August.
Her council salary was $53,687. Nonetheless, Ms. Carlisle faced financial problems last year, culminating in a November lawsuit by a credit card company seeking $4,325. A judgment was filed against her, but court records do not indicate whether she paid it.
Two of the other alleged conspirators also faced money woes.
In 2005, Deutsche Bank filed foreclosure against Ms. Durham for debts on an East Liberty property. In 2004, the Internal Revenue Service filed liens for unpaid taxes totaling $68,454 against Mr. Johnson, who owns a home jointly with Ms. Carlisle's mother, Constance Parker.
Despite the accusations against the councilwoman, other city officials declined to call for her resignation yesterday.
"That's a decision for the councilwoman to make," said Mayor Luke Ravenstahl. "We are going to do what we can to ensure that this activity doesn't take place," starting with a meeting, maybe next week, of the city's long-dormant Ethics Hearing Board.
"Whether or not Councilwoman Carlisle resigns is wholly up to her," said council President Doug Shields.
She has missed several recent council meetings, but Mr. Shields said her northeast Pittsburgh district won't be ignored.
"We will be tending to the needs of District 9 as a body," he said.
The last of the councilwoman's three alleged co-conspirators was arraigned yesterday at the Brookline courtroom of District Judge Charles A. McLaughlin. Ms. Pinson-Smith was released without bail, as were Ms. Carlisle, Ms. Durham and Mr. Johnson on Wednesday. All are scheduled for preliminary hearings on Thursday.
The East Hills councilwoman was fingerprinted and photographed Wednesday night, and the prints were sent to state police and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, as with any criminal case.
With a warrant out for her arrest since early Wednesday, Ms. Pinson-Smith turned herself in yesterday morning and was escorted, in handcuffs, by two detectives from the district attorney's office to appear for her arraignment. Her hands were free as she left Judge McLaughlin's office 10 minutes later with the detectives.
City records show that Ms. Pinson-Smith, Ms. Durham and Mr. Johnson got $101,480 in city funds for consulting work.
The grand jury's report says there is very little documentation that the consultants did any work, and that the arrangement siphoned $38,310 from the city to Ms. Carlisle's personal account, and $4,850 to her campaign account.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.