One approaches the campaign trail like a classroom. The other treats Pittsburgh government like an engine in need of a tune-up.

That makes for an odd pairing in what may be the marquee City Council race this year, pitting school board member Patrick Dowd against incumbent Councilman Len Bodack, both Democrats. The challenger talks about the root causes of crime and measuring government's performance, while the incumbent touts a record of careful tinkering with public safety and blight.

If voters are having a hard time making a side-by-side comparison, it's not likely to get easier. Mr. Dowd has challenged Mr. Bodack to debates, but the councilman has so far declined.

Adding to the confusion is a court case that could end the race before the May 15 primary.

Advertise with us

Stanton Heights resident Anthony F. Lisowski sought to knock Mr. Dowd from the ballot, saying he failed to list any gifts he'd received in a required filing with the city clerk. Mr. Dowd said the list must have been lost by the clerk, and prevailed in Common Pleas Court, but Mr. Lisowski has appealed to Commonwealth Court.

When Mr. Dowd recently asked and answered questions at Lawrenceville's Stephen Foster Center, nearly all of the seniors there cited crime as their main concern.

Mr. Dowd, a 39-year-old private school teacher from Highland Park, told some that the city should "find a way to start solving the problems, the root causes of these crimes, rather than dealing with the symptoms." He said the city should do more to give young people things to do.

Crime is a sensitive issue for Mr. Bodack, a 50-year-old whose career includes stints as a Democratic Committee official and a repair shop owner. He has been council's public safety chairman for most of his four-year career.

"In Lawrenceville, crime and drug-related activity are down," he said. "However, public perception and public awareness of crime has increased" because of crime-fighting efforts.

Advertise with us

Since 2002, crime has dipped in most of the district. In the neighborhoods stretching from Highland Park to the Strip District, reports of two dozen types of crimes, from homicide to disorderly conduct, have declined from 5,468 in 2002 to 4,694 last year.

Mr. Bodack said the crime drop is due to block watches, nuisance bar shutdowns, and the development of a Lawrenceville Weed and Seed program that may bring in federal funds to cover police overtime and community services.

Mr. Dowd said he believes most crime is based in vacant housing, but he disagrees with some politicians' focus on tearing down homes. He has a plan to encourage the purchase and redevelopment of vacant homes that might otherwise wait years for the wrecking ball.

Mr. Bodack is a sponsor of a pending bill that would force owners of vacant buildings to file plans to rehabilitate, board up, or tear down their holdings. It's one of several anti-blight bills introduced early this year but now stalled.

Another is a 2-month-old proposal by Mr. Bodack and Councilman Dan Deasy to force landlords to pay a $25-per-unit registration fee, and $5 to $30 per unit for periodic inspections.

Advertise with us

Why has there been no action on it? "That's a very important piece of legislation that I, personally, do not want to rush," said Mr. Bodack, adding that he's been meeting with representatives of landlords and neighborhood groups to "strike that accord."

He said he's "proud to be part" of turning what state overseers in 2004 said could become a $90 million deficit into what's expected to be a small surplus in this year's $419 million budget.

Mr. Bodack was one of a quartet of council members who opposed the state-backed recovery plan during much of 2004, then voted for it at year's end.

"I agree with probably 95 percent, or 98 percent" of the plan, he said. He only disagreed "whenever it came down to labor contracts and came down to people."

Mr. Bodack portrayed the city's process -- in which jobs were cut, benefits trimmed and some facilities mothballed -- as less unpopular than the plan Mr. Dowd supported that closed 22 elementary and middle schools.

Advertise with us

The closings were "unpleasant" but necessary, said Mr. Dowd, to hold the line on the district's $531 million budget. "I would challenge [Mr. Bodack] to tell me that the school district should go back to the way it was before."

The city's surpluses are expected to dry up in the next few years. Neither candidate wants to increase taxes or cut services.

"You can find efficiencies all over the place," said Mr. Dowd.

Mr. Bodack would ask large nonprofit organizations to give the city a percentage of what they would pay in taxes if they were for-profit businesses.

How about merging the city and Allegheny County?

Advertise with us

"I think it's inevitable at some point that we're going to see the city and county join up," Mr. Dowd said. But he said county or suburban municipal functions "could be sucked into the city" rather than vice versa.

A full city-county merger isn't "on the near horizon," said Mr. Bodack. "They're basically two different animals."

Patrick Dowd

Len Bodack

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.