Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette
Pittsburgh Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle is escorted to District Judge Charles A. McLaughlin's office in Brookline where she was arraigned on charges of theft by deception, criminal conspiracy and ethics law violations. Behind Ms. Carlisle is her mother, Constance Parker.By By Rich Lord, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
The trail toward Pittsburgh Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle's arraignment yesterday on 17 corruption counts started with a city check for $1,610 issued on Sept. 12, 2003.
That check was written to Darlene Durham, a consultant and political supporter of Ms. Carlisle, according to the Allegheny County Investigating Grand Jury's report. It was taken to the bank that same day, and $1,010 was transferred to cash. On the same day, Ms. Carlisle deposited $800 in cash in her personal account.
Listen in
Comments from Connie Parker, Ms. Carlisle's mother.
Related coverage
Negative press worries Carlisle's district
See the criminal complaint and affidavit in the case against Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle, in pdf format.
That was the first of 63 similar transactions, involving three "consultants" over two years, allegedly resulting in the transfer of $38,310 from the city to Ms. Carlisle's personal account, and $4,850 to her campaign account, in what the grand jury called a kickback scheme.
Yesterday, as she arrived at the Brookline courtroom of District Judge Charles A. McLaughlin, she was asked whether she stole from the city. "No, I did not," was all she said.
The seven-page criminal complaint against her lists three charges of theft by deception, three charges of criminal conspiracy, three violations of the state Ethics Act, five Election Code violations, and three charges of failing to file financial disclosures.
It outlines a scheme that, officials said, would be hard to detect even under council's improved spending oversight rules. It throws a career, and a council election, into turmoil.
Attorney Patrick Thomassey, representing Ms. Carlisle, stressed that much was unknown regarding the transactions alleged by the grand jury.
Public officials are "ultimately responsible for where the money goes, but it's not always their doings," said Mr. Thomassey. "Who's responsible for their deposits? Who's responsible for writing checks? Those are things we're going to find out down the road."
Ms. Carlisle was released without bond, ordered to be fingerprinted and scheduled for a preliminary hearing in a week.
Investigators yesterday were rounding up three alleged co-conspirators, Ms. Durham of McKeesport, Lee Otto Johnson of Penn Hills and Sheryl Pinson-Smith of Lawrenceville. Mr. Johnson was in police custody. Investigators arrived at council's offices with an arrest warrant for Ms. Pinson-Smith, but she was not at her job as a staffer in Ms. Carlisle's office.
Each faces charges of theft by deception and conspiracy. The three received $101,480 in city funds for consulting work, but the grand jury focused on a fraction of that spending.
According to the grand jury's report, Ms. Durham received 18 city checks totalling $33,745 through March 2004. The dates on those checks coincide closely with $17,210 in deposits into Ms. Carlisle's personal bank account, and $2,270 in deposits into her campaign account.
An affidavit filed by Detective William Miller of the Allegheny County district attorney's office indicates that Ms. Carlisle sent Ms. Durham blank professional services invoices when the consultant lived in Houston. The councilwoman told the detective that sometimes she typed Ms. Durham's name on blank invoices and checked boxes describing the work done, and twice she signed Ms. Durham's name to invoices.
Checks were mailed to Texas or picked up by Ms. Carlisle or her staff at the city controller's office.
Ms. Durham, according to the affidavit, "did not complete any studies or submit anything tangible" -- even invoices -- for the payments she received.
Within a month of the last check to Ms. Durham, a similar arrangement developed with Mr. Johnson, according to the grand jury. It lasted six months, involving 16 checks for $20,820. The checks correspond to $9,975 in deposits into Ms. Carlisle's personal account, and $500 to the campaign account.
Mr. Johnson, who owns a home jointly with Ms. Carlisle's mother, was found guilty of theft of services and criminal conspiracy in 1976. Details of that case were not available yesterday.
In 2004, he was paid $27,195 for an 85-page "health study" that consisted of reports written by other entities and an essay on race and religion. The affidavit indicates that Ms. Carlisle "was not actively requesting" a report from Mr. Johnson until the news media started raising questions about the payment in the spring of 2006. Then he submitted notes from which her staff typed the essay.
Two weeks after the last transaction involving Mr. Johnson, the first of 26 checks went to Ms. Pinson-Smith, according to the grand jury's report. The $26,400 in payments correspond to $11,125 in deposits into Ms. Carlisle's personal account, and $2,080 in deposits into her campaign account.
The affidavit says Ms. Pinson-Smith did not submit any supporting documentation for the database work the councilwoman has said she performed.
Mr. Thomassey acknowledged that the charges are serious. "I've had a number of meetings with the prosecutor's office along the road, so we'll see what happens," he said.
The perjury and Election Code charges can each bring terms of five years' imprisonment and a $10,000 fine, according to the complaint. The penalties associated with the other charges are not specified in the complaint.
The Election Code charges indicate that in 2003, 2004 and 2005, Ms. Carlisle failed to report campaign contributions and expenses as required by law.
The three financial disclosure charges relate to the deposits made into her personal account that were either gifts or indirect sources of income, according to the complaint, and should have been reported to the state.
"Naturally [filling out campaign and financial disclosures is] the duty of the candidate, but a lot of times that's not the person who actually does it," Mr. Thomassey said.
Detective Miller's affidavit indicates that Ms. Carlisle told him that she personally prepared her campaign finance reports.
Ms. Carlisle faces seven rivals in the May 15 Democratic primary.
The councilwoman is "doing very well, and she's still going forth with her campaign," said her mother, Constance Parker. "The people will make the call on that."
She suggested that bias against women may be at work, citing radio personality Don Imus' recent comments about the Rutgers University women's basketball team.
"And also, you know, if you look at our society, any time you have a person come out and say, 'rough, tough, nappy-headed hos,' this is what our society thinks of women," Ms. Parker said. "It's difficult, but we'll make it through, because we've got greater powers."
After news reporters requested Mr. Johnson's report, then-Council President Luke Ravenstahl referred the matter to the city Law Department. The solicitor then sent records of some $178,000 in spending by Ms. Carlisle's office to District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.
The grand jury spent six months on the case, Mr. Thomassey said.
Mr. Ravenstahl, now the mayor, said he would move to reactivate the city's long-dormant Ethics Hearing Board. It tried to meet in February, but could not muster a quorum of its five members.
"I've instructed my staff this morning to ensure that the ethics board meets as early as next week to deal with this issue and any others that come up in city government," he said.
Mr. Ravenstahl declined to state flatly that he would press to have money returned to the city should Ms. Carlisle be convicted. "We'll deal with that in the future. Let's let this process take its course and then we'll decide as a city how to move forward."
Council President Doug Shields said that Ms. Carlisle has "a presumption of innocence."
He said that he has tightened oversight of spending since last year, but nothing is corruption-proof. "If there is a consultant that fraudulently enters into an arrangement with an individual, it would be very difficult to stop someone from breaking the law or the [council] rules."
The judiciary has struck down council's power to impeach its members, but a provision in the city charter bars members convicted of first- or second-degree felonies. "If they're convicted of a felony, they just have to quit," Mr. Shields said.
The theft and conspiracy charges do not meet the threshold because they are third-degree felonies. Three of the ethics charges against Ms. Carlisle are ungraded felonies, so it was not known yesterday whether they would trigger an automatic loss of office if she were convicted.
But the charter also says officials "shall forfeit their office" if they falsify required financial and campaign disclosures, as Ms. Carlisle is accused of doing.
Ms. Carlisle, 48 and of East Hills, has been a city employee since 1994. She was an aide to her predecessor, current county Recorder of Deeds Valerie McDonald-Roberts, before winning the seat in a 2002 special election. She won a full term in 2003.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.