At first glance, it seems like an odd trio for a legislative race: a former Ross commissioner, a retired Army paratrooper and an insurance specialist who, at a recent fund-raising event, sang Patsy Montana's "I Want To Be a Cowboy's Sweetheart."

Yet the three -- Mark Purcell, Chuck Geiger and Susan Banahasky -- share an intense anger over the state Legislature's 2 a.m. vote last year for hefty pay raises. And all are challenging state Rep. Don Walko for the Democratic nomination in the 20th District, covering parts of the city of Pittsburgh and the North Hills, in the May 16 primary.

Mr. Walko, a 53-year-old attorney and North Side Democrat who is hoping for a seventh term in the House, voted for the pay raises, which boosted his salary from $72,000 to $85,000. He then joined colleagues in voting to repeal them after months of public pressure, although he decided to keep the first portion of his raise.

"I have to live with my vote. I realize that," he said. "I'm not trying to duck away."

Advertise with us

Instead, Mr. Walko highlights his achievements as a lawmaker, from pushing for expansion of the state's drug assistance programs, PACE and PACENET, to seeking funding for a range of local projects under Growing Greener II, an initiative that will provide $625 million for environmental cleanup and conservation projects throughout Pennsylvania over the next six years.

He also has helped secure state funding for renovation of the North Side's Hazlett Theater, new police equipment in West View and several housing developments in the city, including Cowley Hilltop in Troy Hill.

Mr. Walko says his desire to support such projects is the main reason he's running for re-election.

But the pay raise issue looms over the race.

Mr. Purcell, a Ross commissioner for 20 years, last year narrowly lost a race for Allegheny County Council. While going door to door in his campaign, he heard a common refrain: "Are you running for the Legislature? Because if you are, I'll vote for you."

Advertise with us

Mr. Purcell, who now owns a jewelry business, said those questions sparked his interest in researching how the Legislature works, or doesn't work. He then joined Operation Clean Sweep, which has recruited candidates statewide to take on incumbents.

He said members of the local Democratic establishment who support Mr. Walko asked him not to run. But he's decided to move away from the party structure.

"My first goal, when I get to Harrisburg, is to vote myself out of a job," he said.

Mr. Purcell would call for a constitutional convention, the first since 1968, to overhaul the Legislature. He wants to cut the size of the 253-member body and end overly generous pension plans, something he called for at the local level as a commissioner. Ordinary citizens, he said, would be delegates at the convention.

Mr. Purcell's two fellow challengers don't have his experience in elected office, but they rival his enthusiasm.

Advertise with us

Ms. Banahasky, 50, of Lawrenceville, is a recovery specialist at Zurich, an insurance company. She touts her involvement as an organizer for Lawrenceville Votes, a group formed in 2002 to boost voter turnout, and Art All Night, a hugely popular annual cultural event in the neighborhood.

Ms. Banahasky, a member of Run Baby Run, an organization that recruits female candidates, is taking her love of art and music on the campaign trail. At a fund-raising event last week, she sang a collection of her favorite country music standards.

She said the "arrogance" of the pay raises pushed her to make her first run for public office.

Her main goal is to reduce the size of government, and she said her years of experience in management positions would help her navigate the intricacies of state budgets. She also thinks legislators should be limited to two four-year terms, which would enable them to focus on governing.

Mr. Geiger, 62, of Brighton Heights, may be the most outspoken in his criticism of the state Legislature.

Advertise with us

"They're no better than criminals," said the former Army staff sergeant. He is now the owner of a cleaning business, GI Dirtbusters II.

He also is making his first run for public office, and he says he has no interest in being a career politician. He wants to cut the Legislature's size in half and prevent members from collecting their sizeable medical benefits when they retire.

Mr. Geiger also said he'd spend at least 10 hours a month visiting constituents in their homes, "whether they voted for me or not."

Mr. Walko argues that his critics miss the broader context of last July's vote on the pay raises.

In 1995, his first year in Harrisburg, Mr. Walko voted against a similar raise. A decade later he switched sides, he said, because the "yes" vote was part of an overall state budget compromise put forward by House Republican leaders. That compromise restored some Medicaid cuts and spending in the Growing Greener II program.

Advertise with us

Mr. Walko also thought his position, which includes a seat on the influential Appropriations Committee, was demanding enough to warrant a greater salary.

But after four months of public backlash and negative news media coverage, he and his colleagues voted in November to rescind the pay raises. The issue had become too much of a distraction for legislators.

"The timing was bad," he said. "I freely admit that it was the wrong thing."

All four candidates, including Mr. Walko, support some kind of property tax reduction, possibly using a mixture of sales tax increases and gambling revenue. Mr. Purcell also would like to see elected assessors and more state oversight of how property value is set.

Mr. Walko supports the idea of a citizens' constitutional convention to make changes to the size and structure of the Legislature. He'd also like to see such a convention introduce a graduated income tax in Pennsylvania, with a higher rate on those with bigger salaries.

Bill Stalter, of Reserve, is running unopposed for the Republican nomination in the 20th District.