With graphics, videos and celebrities, the three bidders for the Pittsburgh casino pitched competing $1 billion plans to the state Gaming Control Board yesterday, promising hundreds of millions of dollars in tax relief, thousands of jobs, and much-needed city economic redevelopment in exchange for the coveted slot machine license.

Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette

Tim Hinkley, of Isle of Capri, presents his firm's proposal for a Hill District development to the gaming board.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

Related article

Penguins loyalists rally for casino-arena plan

But in the end, it was funding for a new arena that dominated the first day of the hearings at the Omni William Penn Hotel, Downtown.

In his testimony yesterday afternoon, Penguins Chief Executive Officer Ken Sawyer told gaming board members that "you may be deciding the fate" of the team in choosing a casino winner.

The Penguins are backing the bid of Isle of Capri Casinos Inc., which has pledged $290 million in funding for an arena if it gets the license.

Advertise with us

A second bidder, Don Barden, who heads PITG Gaming LLC, has committed $7.5 million a year toward an arena as part of Gov. Ed Rendell's Plan B to keep the team in Pittsburgh if Isle of Capri doesn't get the license.

But the third bidder, Forest City Enterprises, while calling Plan B the "best approach" to funding an arena, refused to commit to the $7.5 million a year yesterday, saying officials first wanted the Penguins to commit to the plan and to staying in Pittsburgh. Only then would Forest City "finalize the details" with city and county officials.

Still, Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato took the comments as a commitment, telling the gaming board he was "declaring victory" in his effort to build a new arena for the city and the Penguins.

But Mr. Sawyer told the board the team's future in Pittsburgh is not guaranteed by Plan B.

"I can assure you that is not the case," he said. "There is no other plan [besides Isle of Capri's] that guarantees the Penguins will stay here."

Advertise with us

Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette

With the group supporting the Station Square proposal, from left: Franco Harris, Jesse Fife Jr. of the Manchester Bidwell Center and Brian Ratner of Forest City Enterprises.

Click photo for larger image.

Outside the hearings, Mr. Sawyer described Mr. Onorato's declaration of victory as a "gross overstatement," saying the Penguins still have lots of questions about Plan B and that one bidder, Forest City, has yet to formally commit to it.

"So I don't know how you can declare victory at this point," he said.

Advertise with us

Nonetheless, both Mr. Onorato and Mayor Bob O'Connor said they believe funding for an arena is a certainty, no matter which bidder wins the license.

As a result, Mr. Onorato told the gaming board it could turn its focus to determining which of the three proposals offers the best for the city in property tax reduction, jobs and economic development.

Mr. O'Connor urged the board to scrutinize the proposals carefully, paying particular attention to revenue and jobs estimates being tossed about by the bidders.

"We have to separate fact from fiction. We have to know what we're buying in the end," he said. "Otherwise gaming could become another cost our city does not want at this time."

Neither the mayor nor Mr. Onorato endorsed a specific plan.

Advertise with us

Mr. Barden called the comments of the mayor and chief executive "all good for us," as a result of his commitment to Plan B funding.

Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette

Don Barden, center, who would develop a casino complex on the North Side, listens with entertainer Smokey Robinson, right.

Click photo for larger image.

"The battle is won with respect to the Penguins," he said, in terms of removing the Isle of Capri's advantage on the arena issue.

Advertise with us

While Hill District community leaders and elected representatives generally backed the Isle of Capri-Penguins plan, Mr. Barden said that didn't bother him, because they had not yet had a chance to review his own pledge to assist the Hill District.

Steve Tello, vice president and general manager of Fox Sports Net, was among afternoon speakers who supported the Penguins and Isle of Capri proposal. He said the work of 100 individuals connected to Penguins broadcasts could be affected if the team feels compelled to leave town, and local broadcast of the games ends.

"The Penguins must stay here, and the Isle of Capri proposal will ensure they do," Mr. Tello said.

Both state Sen. Jim Ferlo, D-Highland Park, and city Councilman Bill Peduto, D-Point Breeze, also endorsed the Isle of Capri plan.

Sanford Stevenson, representing a West End community group, backed the Forest City proposal, however.

Advertise with us

"We believe their plan is the strongest financially," he said.

County Councilwoman Brenda Frazier, D-Stanton Heights, whose district includes all three sites, declined to endorse any one applicant. She said her constituents are primarily interested in tax relief. They want a casino "where it would do the least amount of harm," she said, and each proposal has both benefits and drawbacks.

Bidders pulled out all the stops in their 40-minute presentations before the board. Singer Smokey Robinson, an investor in PITG Gaming, opened for Mr. Barden, but he did not sing. Steelers Hall of Famer Franco Harris was among those who talked for Forest City. The Penguins held a rally in Mellon Square for supporters.

Most of the discussion inside covered familiar ground.

In addition to its arena pledge, Isle of Capri highlighted a proposed $350 million residential, retail and office development designed to reconnect the Hill District and Downtown. James Simms, a former County Council president working with the bidder, said the development would "redo a wrong" committed when Mellon Arena was built, segregating the Hill District.

Advertise with us

In his presentation, Mr. Barden emphasized location, saying it is the "critical factor" in the success of a casino. He believes he has the "absolutely best location" between the West End Bridge and Carnegie Science Center, with close proximity to Route 51 and Interstate 279. He also presented plans for a $350 million Hill District development.

Harrah's Entertainment, casino operator for Forest City, touted itself as the largest gambling company in the United States and Forest City's development expertise. The Pittsburgh casino would generate $347 million a year in tax revenue, the highest of the three, it said.

Forest City also pushed its plan to build 1,200 condos on the east side of Station Square as part of the casino development. It downplayed concerns about possible access problems. One consultant has said that Harrah's had "woefully underestimated" possible traffic congestion.

"We're confident with what we have. We're the ones that are hurt most if traffic doesn't work," said Brian Ratner, a Forest City director. "We think what we have makes sense."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.