Edward C. Gainey has been trying to oust his former boss, state Rep. Joe Preston, for years. This year the two are locked in one of the region's most competitive Democratic primary races, along with body shop owner and former drug dealer William D. Anderson.

Mr. Gainey, 36, a former aide to Mr. Preston and later to former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy, has the Democratic Committee endorsement.

Mr. Preston, 58, has 23 years of House experience and a two-to-one fund-raising advantage.

Mr. Anderson, 33, has political roots and a willingness to confront past errors.

Advertise with us

They're facing off in the May 16 primary in the 24th District that includes Aspinwall, East Hills, East Liberty, Highland Park, Homewood, Lincoln-Lemington-Belmar, Larimer and Wilkinsburg. There is no Republican candidate, so the winner will likely take the seat in January.

Mr. Preston, of East Liberty, touted his work on increasing transit funding, fighting identity theft and bringing state money to the district. In November, he helped get $8 million in state aid for a planned East Liberty hotel.

"It comes from working hard, dealing with leadership," he said of his ability to bring home the bacon. "I have earned respect."

He said his position as one of the region's senior legislators, and as minority chairman of the Consumer Affairs Committee, in part explains his vote last year for the since-repealed pay raises for judges, administrators and lawmakers. Leaders must sometimes make unpopular votes, he said.

Mr. Gainey offered this opinion about legislative pay raises: "If we're not producing new industries to put people to work, then I don't think we deserve a pay raise."

Advertise with us

The Highland Park resident challenged Mr. Preston in 2004 but was tossed off the ballot due to a paperwork error. This time he's on the ballot, and criticizing the incumbent for voting for annual water rate hikes as chairman of the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority and for supporting a bill that makes it easier for natural gas companies to shut off service to delinquent ratepayers.

Mr. Preston was among 163 House members who voted in 2004 for looser gas shutoff rules. He has since called for hearings on the resulting shutoffs and helped constituents get state help with heating bills.

The candidates differ on whether the state should help finance a new arena.

"I do believe that for us to stay at the class of city that we are, an arena goes along with having a great convention center," Mr. Preston said.

In January, he endorsed Isle of Capri Casinos' bid to build a new arena if it receives the city's lone slot machine license, and he didn't rule out backing a state-aided arena plan if another company receives the license.

Advertise with us

"There are better things the state can spend its money on," said Mr. Anderson, especially education and helping small businesses.

Mr. Gainey said he hadn't yet evaluated arena funding ideas.

In 1992, Mr. Anderson, of Homewood, pleaded guilty to drug possession charges. In 1998, he pleaded guilty to drug possession and delivery. Both times he was sentenced to probation.

He said drug dealing was a "sporadic thing" and a mistake.

"I have gone through this, and I can tell people not to go down this road," he said.

Advertise with us

He now owns Pittsburgh's Finest Auto Body and Detailing, and volunteers for many campaigns and Democratic groups. His grandmother, Evelyn D. Richardson, is a Democratic National Committee member.

Mr. Gainey faced years of litigation, ended in 2002, regarding support for his two children. He is unmarried.

Mr. Preston and his wife, Odelfa, have had liens filed against them for late taxes by the Internal Revenue Service in 2001 and 2004, by the city of Pittsburgh in 2004 and by Allegheny County in 2005. They then paid the taxes.

He said the $36,285 in IRS liens resulted from a disagreement on taxes due from a benefits distribution taken by his wife, a systems analyst. He said he was unaware of the city and county property tax liens, noting that his wife pays the bills.

Mr. Preston said the district's communities face social problems that have no easy answers. A legislator's effort "is never going to be enough to deal with the problems we have there," he said. "At the same time, the track record is there" to warrant his re-election.

Advertise with us

"It's time for leadership that has the vision to improve our communities," Mr. Gainey countered. With the party endorsement, he said, "we're in a position to win this race."

Joe Preston

Ed Gainey

William Anderson

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.