Theresa Colaizzi said she's been the vocal representative District 5 voters wanted when they elected her to the city school board four years ago.

But challenger Tom Baker said Ms. Colaizzi has been too divisive. He pledged to be a calming force as the board wrestles with a financial crisis, the racial achievement gap and other contentious issues.

Ms. Colaizzi and Mr. Baker are squaring off in the only contested city school board race on the Nov. 8 ballot. Contests in other city districts were decided in the May 17 primary.

Ms. Colaizzi, 45, a Democrat, said a school board known for heated disputes over the years has become "pretty unified" under new Superintendent Mark Roosevelt and is poised to tackle the achievement gap and move the district forward in other areas.

Advertise with us

"I've never been more confident," said Ms. Colaizzi, who lives in Greenfield and is co-owner of a hair salon in the Crafton-Ingram Shopping Center.

Ms. Colaizzi said District 5 -- taking in Greenfield, Hazelwood, Hays, Lincoln Place and parts of Oakland, Squirrel Hill and the South Side -- didn't have an aggressive representative before she joined the board.

When board members clashed publicly, Ms. Colaizzi often has been in the thick of it. She said disagreements enabled members to better understand each others' viewpoints.

"In a way, it's healthy," Ms. Colaizzi said.

Mr. Baker, 25, said Ms. Colaizzi hasn't been a good leader or role model. Mr. Baker, a Republican, said he decided to enter the race after seeing Ms. Colaizzi and other board members yelling at meetings.

Advertise with us

"It just wasn't what I expected out of a school board member," Mr. Baker said. The Greenfield resident works as a recruitment and retention specialist for Three Rivers Adoption Council and is on the boards of the Greenfield Organization and the Pittsburgh Singles Volunteer Network.

Mr. Baker said cool heads are needed to address key problems, including the $6 million budget shortfall Mr. Roosevelt has predicted for next year; a coming round of school closings to help the district's finances; and the perennial achievement gap. In reading and math at every grade level, performance of black students lags that of white students.

Echoing comments Mr. Roosevelt has made, the candidates said an expectation of achievement should be inculcated in teachers, parents and students. Mr. Baker said he'd hold community meetings to hear parents' input and better involve them in the educational process.

Ms. Colaizzi said principals and teachers should analyze test scores and other data to design individual education plans for students. Mr. Baker said the district should maximize use of pre-school, after-school and tutoring programs for under-performing students, making principals stronger leaders while holding them accountable for performance.

As leader of the board committee on contract negotiations, Ms. Colaizzi said, she helped deliver contracts that avoided work stoppages while lengthening the school day and increasing health-care contributions from teachers and other workers.

Advertise with us

Ms. Colaizzi graduated from the former St. Paul Cathedral High School in Oakland. She has an associate degree in business management from Community College of Allegheny County and developed what she described as a grass-roots expertise in the city schools.

She said she was active in parent groups when her daughter, Lucia, 22, and son, Franco, 16, a student at Allderdice High School, were elementary students. She said she became an activist while trying to find a middle school for her daughter. Ms. Colaizzi wasn't able to get her daughter into a magnet school and didn't want to send her to now-closed Gladstone Middle School in Hazelwood. That led Ms. Colaizzi to play a prominent role in pressuring the board to convert Greenfield Elementary into a school for students through the eighth grade.

By the time she joined the board four years ago, Ms. Colaizzi said, she had a familiarity with the school system that Mr. Baker lacks. She called Mr. Baker too young to be an effective board member and suggested he'd use the post as a stepping stone to higher office.

Mr. Baker said he's well-versed on educational issues and considers an unpaid board slot the "truest form of public service."

The son of a one-time city school teacher, he graduated from Allderdice in 1997, then received a bachelor's degree in elementary education from Millersville University of Pennsylvania. He is certified to teach elementary students.

Advertise with us

Mr. Baker said he worked for a year as director of Learning Ladder Child Development Center in Lancaster, an experience that reinforced for him the importance of early education. For his master's degree from Indiana University of Pennsylvania, he studied the role of student affairs in higher education. While in graduate school, he worked as a career counselor to Carnegie Mellon University students. Mr. Baker, who's also been a youth baseball coach and counselor to middle school students, said he entered the race to help the district tap what he believes is great potential.

"I'm kind of a true believer," he said.