After a year of turmoil, self-doubt and recrimination, the Pittsburgh Public Schools board might be able to find a few moments of peace, however incomplete, in choosing from its current slate of candidates.
Several board members say they can't go wrong with any of the four finalists for the Pittsburgh superintendency.
The finalists are Gerald Dawkins, 56, superintendent of Saginaw Public Schools in Michigan; William Harner, 49, principal of Gainesville Middle School in Georgia; Christine Johns, 39, deputy superintendent of curriculum and instruction in Baltimore County Public Schools in Maryland; and Mark Roosevelt, 49, former director of the Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education.
All four were trained in high-profile management programs for urban superintendents, three of the four by the Los Angeles-based Broad Center for the Management of School Systems, which emphasizes innovation and competition in school management. All have track records of reforming schools and improving student achievement, according to board member Patrick Dowd.
"We have an excellent pool of candidates from which to make this selection," Dowd said.
Two black board members, Mark Brentley and Alex Matthews, have been critical of a search process they say was tainted by conflicts of interest and by secretiveness. They plan to continue boycotting the board's interviews of candidates, and might boycott the final vote.
The board's third black member, Randall Taylor, says he will vote on the superintendent's selection but that he is frustrated that neither his brother, Bernard Taylor, a school superintendent in Kansas City, nor interim superintendent Andrew King made the cut.
"I still believe our two most qualified and experienced candidates were Andy King and Bernard Taylor," said Randall Taylor, who had to abstain from voting while his brother was still under consideration.
King, he said, told him he applied for the position. He was not, however, among the 10 candidates selected from among 36 applicants for an interview.
The board could announce a choice as early as this week, and hopes to vote on the selection at the end of July so the new superintendent can start by the first day of school, on Sept. 1, according to board members.
Neither salary nor term has been decided, however, and the board is still considering whether and how to create a so-called "accountability contract" that would spell out not only pay, but also expectations and methods of evaluation.
Members of the public will not be asked to comment, but can speak on any topic they choose, including the candidates for superintendent, at the board's regular monthly public meeting at 7 p.m. July 18.
Here's a summary of the candidates:
Gerald Dawkins
Dawkins, a native of Spartanburg, S.C., began a career in education as a teacher and counselor in Grand Rapids Public Schools in Michigan in 1973 and later became an administrator overseeing career education, student services, the Grand Rapids Jobs Corps, applied technology and community outreach. He later became assistant superintendent for educational services and then chief of staff before being hired as superintendent in Saginaw in July 2001.
"Our focus is to make every child important," Dawkins said of Saginaw. "We've looked at our testing strategies and data, student by student. We know who's not achieving and have implemented change to bring them up."
In addition to studying students' test scores, Dawkins and other Saginaw administrators watch for other red flags: several moves in one year, more than 10 absences, repeated grades or failure in more than one subject. In many cases, such students are offered tutoring after school or on the weekends.
Dawkins also created ninth-grade academies at two Saginaw high schools to help freshman adjust socially and academically to a new setting. He started a K-8 MicroSociety School in which all pupils participate in a business beginning in first grade.
Dawkins formed an international academy with a foreign language immersion program. And, to try to improve performance, he created single-sex classes at two elementary schools that had failed to meet state standards for several years.
While working in Grand Rapids, Dawkins showed a skill at building relationships with community leaders and other members of the public, earning their trust and smoothing negotiations over issues such as closing schools.
"That was one of the areas where his knowledge of the community helped so much," said Patricia Newby, a former Grand Rapids school superintendent who hired Dawkins to be her chief of staff in 1998. "Even though they were very angry, he was never hesitant to go to them. I trusted him to do everything that was right."
Dawkins, a Marine Corps veteran, is a graduate of Knoxville College, where he earned a bachelor of arts in social science. He holds a master of arts in counseling and personnel from Western Michigan University and earned a doctorate from Wayne State University. Dawkins and his wife, Gwen, have two daughters, Kanika and Kamaria.
William Harner
Like Dawkins, Harner, originally from a Philadelphia suburb, looked to ninth-grade academies as one way to improve student achievement.
After his first semester as principal of Hilton Head High School in South Carolina in 1998, Harner spent his Christmas break examining the records of all 400 students who had failed that semester, trying to identify trends.
Freshmen, he found, represented about 50 percent of all the fights and other violent incidents at the school, and 38 percent of freshmen were failing a class.
Harner, a retired Army lieutenant colonel, ultimately created more than a dozen ninth-grade academies, small centers kept separate within buildings and staffed by their own teachers to give students more individual attention, after he was hired as superintendent of Greenville County Public Schools in South Carolina in July 2000.
After all, a teacher's attention to him saved him from illiteracy when a test he took as a third-grader showed that he couldn't read, Harner said. His teacher called his mother, and after five years of remedial classes, tutoring and summer school, Harner began reading at grade level in eighth grade.
"It has helped create the passion I have for moving student achievement forward for as many children as I can," he said.
In Greenville, Harner doubled enrollment in Advanced Placement classes and tests. He eliminated all below-grade-level classes and required students to take any remedial classes during elective periods. He created the district's first center for highly gifted students, pushed middle-school pupils to take advanced math classes and added full-day preschool.
The fast pace of those reforms, along with a few controversial moves such as Harner's sale of some district-owned timber, which some school board members thought they should have been asked to approve, gradually began to frustrate some members of the community. In April 2004, board members asked Harner to leave his job more than a year before the end of his contract.
Board member Crystal Ball O'Conner, however, said ousting Harner was a mistake.
She said she believed "the tremendous success we had and still have relates to many of the initiatives he began and implemented so effectively during his time here."
Harner earned his bachelor of science in engineering from the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, N.Y., holds three master's degrees and earned his doctorate in educational leadership from the University of South Carolina. He and his wife, Lindsley, have a son, Billy, 18, and a daughter, Jessica, 14.
Christine Johns
Personal hardship inspired Johns' education career as well.
The pain of seeing her father and other steel and factory workers get laid off from job after job led Johns to become an educator.
"That taught me a critical lesson about the value of education," she said.
In the two decades since she received her bachelor of science degree from the University of Pittsburgh, Johns has advanced to the highest levels of school administration and earned a reputation for championing the underdog along the way.
The only female finalist and the youngest of the four, Johns has a shorter track record than the others, but she's hard-driving and eager to hold the top job in a major urban school district.
"I understand Pennsylvania," said Johns, a native of the Johnstown area. "I understand the culture of Pittsburgh."
While her resume includes a doctorate from Harvard University's Graduate School of Education, she says her proudest achievement is helping to improve student achievement scores for kids in special education, English language learners and children from poor families.
Johns, who has never been married and has no children, started her career as an elementary school teacher in Maryland. She moved to administration and soon became the youngest of 200 elementary school principals in Prince George's County, Md. Johns also served as an assistant superintendent in Pasadena, Calif., before taking her current job in Baltimore in 2000.
She wants to bring her skills here to work on closing the achievement gap for all students, an area in which she claims to have a proven track record.
"I established performance goals and indicators by aligning to the state's accountability measures," she said. Beyond the classroom, she said, she "partnered with parents and families by opening lines of communication to build their confidence and trust."
People who know Johns describe her as ambitious, trailblazing and passionately focused on the children she serves.
"One of her biggest attributes is being a champion for the under-served student,'' said Joe Hairston, superintendent of Baltimore County Public Schools and Johns' boss.
Mark Roosevelt
A former Massachusetts representative, Mark Roosevelt, a great-grandson of President Theodore Roosevelt, was led to the education world by pure idealism.
A native of Washington, D.C., he became involved in education through his political activism in the 1970s. Roosevelt had come to Boston to attend Harvard University, and was recruited by a friend, a city councilor, to run the campaign of John O'Bryant, the first black person elected to the Boston School Committee.
After O'Bryant won his school board race, Roosevelt stood with 1,000 other triumphant O'Bryant supporters, most of whom were black, on election night and realized that many of the people around him had never experienced a political victory party before. It was a watershed moment that helped inspire his commitment to improving education.
The educational system, he said, is one of the most basic and yet most powerful levers of social change, for helping people escape poverty and powerlessness.
"It is up to all of us to make equality of opportunity less of a joke in this country," he said.
After working for President Jimmy Carter's domestic policy staff and becoming executive director of the John F. Kennedy Library Foundation in Boston, Roosevelt served for eight years in the Massachusetts Legislature. He chaired the House Committee on Education, where he co-wrote legislation passed in 2003 to help ensure that schools in rich and poor communities were funded at approximately the same levels, and to create a set of academic standards against which student performance could be measured.
In 1994, Roosevelt won the Democratic nomination for governor of Massachusetts but lost the gubernatorial election. He became president and CEO of Massachusetts Biomedical Initiatives, a nonprofit economic development corporation, and then director of the Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education. He ran the education reform group from May 2003 until January, when he remarried.
During his time with the group, Roosevelt showed great skill in inspiring other people to support his causes, according to Karen Vigue, who worked as his assistant director.
"One of Mark's greatest strengths is his ability to have a great vision and carry people along with that," Vigue said. "He has the ability to be a fabulous speaker and get people who wouldn't necessarily be in his camp to say, 'There's something in what he's saying. Let's jump on board.' "
Roosevelt received his bachelor of arts degree in American history from Harvard University and his juris doctor degree from Harvard Law School. He and his wife, Dorothy, live in Santa Fe, N.M. Roosevelt has a son, Matthew Choi Roosevelt, 19, from a previous marriage.
Gerald Dawkins
William Harner
Christine Johns
Mark Roosevelt
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.