Never underestimate the curse of Tom Murphy.

Sala Udin

That lesson put Bob O'Connor in the Democratic driver's seat for the Pittsburgh mayor's job, of course, and it put Murphy ally Sala Udin on the way out after a 10-year City Council career.

Udin, 62, had impeccable government credentials. A former civil rights activist and aide to the late councilman, Jake Milliones, he joined council in 1995, became its finance chairman, led the fight for the city's Citizens Police Review Board and holds a seat on the powerful Urban Redevelopment Authority board.

Advertise with us

But he was also Murphy's most vocal supporter on City Council, which was almost all Tonya Payne, his main challenger for the Democratic nomination to his District 6 council seat, needed to beat him.

"She very much tied the two individuals together, going so far as to say [Udin] was 'Murphy's boy,' " said Khari Mosley, Democratic chairman of the North Side's 22nd Ward and an Udin supporter.

"It was a case where voters looked at it as not only a referendum on Sala, [but] as much a quasi-referendum on Tom Murphy."

Payne, an Uptown activist and chair of the 1st Ward Democrats, repeatedly blamed both Udin and Murphy for any problem facing the Hill District and North Side neighborhoods Udin represented. That included uncollected trash, closed pools and fire houses, and even construction delays at the Hill's Freedom Corner memorial.

"Hey Tom and Sala ... The Party's Over," said printed material Payne's campaign issued recently. "Murphy and Udin: It's Time For Them To Go."

Advertise with us

Unofficial results released by the county Elections Division showed Payne won every Hill District/Downtown/Oakland voting ward (Wards 1-5) and Udin the North Side wards (21, 22, 25 and 26) where Murphy has long had his political power base.

Payne received 44.9 percent of the total Democratic vote, Udin 40.5 percent and school board member Mark Brentley 14.7 percent.

Udin partisans yesterday said voters reprimanded him in Tuesday's primary for making "tough decisions" on city budget matters, rather than his ties to Murphy. Udin was a longtime proponent of the spending cuts in the Act 47 recovery plan and voted for a contract with the firefighters union in March that closed a Hill District fire station, even though he knew it would be unpopular.

"Sala made some difficult decisions but the right decisions for Pittsburgh," Murphy said yesterday. "This is a choice of telling people what they want to hear or what they ought to hear, and Sala was not afraid to tell people what they ought to hear. I admire that in him and [his defeat] will be a loss for the city."

In other races Tuesday, Murphy's allies either lost or his foes won.

Advertise with us

The clearest example is O'Connor, the longtime Murphy rival who won the Democratic mayoral primary, in his third try, largely by telling voters that he warned them of the city's fiscal ills four years ago.

Another is City Councilman William Peduto. Peduto came in second to O'Connor in the mayor's race -- two percentage points ahead of Allegheny County Prothonotary Michael Lamb -- but easily won the Democratic nod for his District 8 City Council seat.

Murphy supporters tried to punish Peduto for entering the mayoral race -- and possibly siphoning votes from Lamb, their preferred alternative to O'Connor -- by actively campaigning for Peduto's council opponent, attorney Harlan Stone.

Peduto not only rebuffed them but had the biggest winning margin in any of the four Pittsburgh City Council races, a date when other council incumbents (Udin and Jim Motznik) were facing heavy weather.

Another Murphy ally, Paul Renne, the former H.J. Heinz executive running for the open District 2 council seat, also lost. Murphy had gone so far as to veto a zoning application early this year, at Renne's request, for a Mount Washington apartment project while Renne was running for council. A judge overturned Murphy's decision last month.

Advertise with us

In beating Udin for the District 6 nomination, Payne also used another trait Udin shares with Murphy -- a perceived top-down management style -- against him.

Payne claimed Udin was out of touch with regular folks in the Hill District and the North Side, despite all the large-scale economic development he championed in the Hill, most noticeably at its crumbling public housing developments.

Udin tried to counteract that strategy by showing off his support among the district's leaders. A large Udin campaign ad in the May 11 edition of the New Pittsburgh Courier listed 58 well-known supporters -- including respected activists Thelma Lovette and the Rev. Johnnie Monroe -- calling for his re-election. At the top it read, "Sometimes families fight. But in our community, family is still family."

That seemed to feed into Payne's strategy, as it displayed Udin as an elitist.

Even Udin's supporters said he was hurt by that image. Former city councilwoman Barbara Burns -- another Murphy ally who lost her seat in 2003 to a then-unknown Murphy foe, Luke Ravenstahl -- said Udin's leadership on major city issues such as the budget may have hurt him with voters.

Advertise with us

"Sometimes as people play a leadership role that goes beyond their district, it is consuming of their time. Sala wasn't as visible" as some voters wanted, Burns said yesterday.

Murphy agreed.

"I think you get caught up in the issues and sometimes you lose touch with your constituents. I think that's probably what happened to Sala," he said.

Udin could not be reached for comment.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.