Three City Council veterans are engaged in spirited battles in next Tuesday's primary to retain their seats.

In District 6, Sala Udin is facing competition from two others, including a former staffer, and in Districts 4 and 8, incumbents James Motznik and William Peduto, respectively, each have one opponent for the Democratic nomination.

Only Motznik has the party endorsement.

District 6

Advertise with us

Challenging Udin in District 6 are Tonya Payne, the party's 1st Ward chairwoman who won the endorsement, and Mark Brentley Sr., a city school board member.

Udin, 62, of the Hill District, has been councilman for 10 years in District 6, which includes the Hill, Strip District, Downtown and parts of the North Side and Oakland.

He believes he has made a difference. In that time, he said, $298 million in housing and $327 million in neighborhood business development have been invested in the district, and 2,117 families have gotten new affordable housing.

Udin also believes police-community relations have improved, in part with creation of the Citizens Police Review Board, which he advocated.

"You've got to look at the results. If there were no results, I deserve to be criticized and kicked out of office. But if there have been results, you have to look at the results and make a judgment based on that," he said.

Advertise with us

Payne and Brentley argue that Udin hasn't done enough. Both want to bring a grocery store to the Hill and fault Udin for not doing so.

Payne, 41, president of Uptown Community Action Group, said there are too many abandoned properties in the district, and the development that has occurred was the result of work by community organizations, "not because Sala got behind them."

"Sala has not done what Sala needed to do. People feel betrayed. I feel betrayed. We all thought Sala had so much potential," she said.

Payne, of Uptown, said her priorities would be neighborhood improvements; public safety, including a return to community-oriented policing; and more inclusiveness in charting the agenda for the district.

Udin claims Payne is running against him in retaliation for his firing her in 1997. Payne said that's not true.

Advertise with us

"It had nothing to do with him firing me," she said. "I thought it was ludicrous that he fired me. No one could have worked harder."

Brentley, who ran against Udin a decade ago, does not believe the councilman has done enough to address youth violence in the district. He said curbing such violence would be a priority.

He believes he can use the council position as a bully pulpit to raise the problem of youth violence to the top of the city's agenda and direct resources to address it.

Brentley, 48, of the North Side, termed Udin's development numbers misleading, saying many of the initiatives were spearheaded by the mayor's office or others, not Udin.

"He was a minor player in a major issue," he said.

Advertise with us

Udin said his top priority over the next four years would be the grocery store and completing some of the housing redevelopment that has come to the Hill, including Oak Hill and Bedford Dwellings.

Alan Perry is running unopposed for the Republican nomination.

District 8

In District 8, Peduto is trying to hold on to his council seat while at the same time trying to win the seven-man race for the Democratic nomination for mayor.

Mounting an aggressive campaign to unseat him is Harlan Stone, a 50-year-old lawyer from Squirrel Hill perhaps best known for fighting the property assessment freeze ordered by former county commissioners Larry Dunn and Bob Cranmer in 1996.

Advertise with us

Stone, a 14th Ward committeeman, has been endorsed by the party, the 14th Ward Independent Democratic Club and many labor unions. He claims Peduto hasn't been responsive to constituents or elected officials.

"I don't think he's been very effective in solving the financial problems of the city while he's been in there and I don't think he's done an awful lot to improve the lives of constituents in the district," he said.

Peduto, who is running for his second term, said nothing could be further from the truth. He said his lack of endorsements and Stone's entry into the race were a direct result of his support of Act 47.

"I was told by the party bosses that if I supported Act 47, they would find someone to run against me and they have," he said.

Peduto, 40, of Point Breeze, said he has received the support of community-based organizations and lots of people who appreciated his leadership during the city fiscal crisis.

Advertise with us

The councilman's goals, if he is re-elected, include instituting outcome-based budgeting, earmarking money based on priorities rather than by department; implementing a community-based economic development strategy that involves residents more in planning improvements; and merging city and county services.

He said community-based economic development has worked effectively in the Centre-Baum corridor and could be used in other city neighborhoods.

Priorities for Stone, who's making his first run at elected office, include "right-sizing" the city to comply with the Act 47 plan; cutting the city's 50 percent parking tax; and consolidating services with the county.

District 8 encompasses Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, Point Breeze, Bloomfield, Friendship and North and West Oakland.

District 4

Advertise with us

Opposing Motznik for the Democratic nomination in District 4 is Anthony Coghill, a 38-year-old Beechview resident who runs a roofing business.

Coghill, who lost to Motznik in a special election four years ago to fill 10 months of former Councilman Michael Diven's term, has built his campaign around public safety -- he is against closing fire stations and wants to put more police on the street -- and reducing the size of council from nine members to five, which he believes can save $1 million a year.

Vice president of the Beechview Merchants Association, Coghill wants to develop a marketing plan to bring more business to neighborhoods. He claims that Motznik hasn't done enough on the economic development front, and that business districts are suffering as a result.

Motznik, 41, of Overbrook, said he has helped to bring new drugstores to Carrick and Brookline and assisted in the expansion of the Carrick Foodland. He said he also has worked with developer Bernardo Katz in remaking the Beechview business district.

"All three business districts are better off today than they were three years ago," he said.

Advertise with us

He said business districts would remain a priority. He also wants to increase the number of police officers from the 900 budgeted to 1,100.

While Motznik initially opposed Act 47, he said he now believes the city has turned the corner financially. He said he opposed Act 47 for a long time to try to get the best deal possible for the city.

Bob Hillen, 47, of Beechview, the city Republican Party chairman, is running unopposed for the GOP nomination.

District 4 includes Beechview, Bon Air, Brookline, Carrick and Overbrook.