Mayor Tom Murphy, a former seminarian and community activist, essentially became the head of a 1,245-member police force when he took office in 1994, a year after the city endured a record 83 homicides.

CITY ISSUES 2005

One in an occasional series during the campaign for mayor of Pittsburgh.THE SERIES

How mayor hopefuls would fix city finances

Advertise with us

Today: Next mayor will face safety issues

Pittsburgh's next mayor -- none of the candidates has a background in law enforcement -- will face the same kind of challenge next year. Due to the city's budget cuts, however, he will have, as of last week, 791 officers at his disposal.

Crime dipped the last decade -- among the nation's top 50 cities, Pittsburgh was the 10th safest in 2003 -- but gun violence remains a major fear in the city, with the fatal shooting of a teenager near Carrick High School on March 16 only the latest grim example.

The mayor of Pittsburgh names the city's police chief and sets policy for all branches of the Public Safety Department, including its fire, paramedic and building inspection bureaus. A look at the public safety policies of the three major candidates in the May 17 Democratic primary for mayor follows.

William Peduto

Advertise with us

William Peduto

The city councilman from Point Breeze has released a four-point crime and policing plan. He supports reinstating the Community Oriented Policing program, which was disbanded in 2003, partially by turning over desk jobs occupied by uniformed police to civilians, as called for in the Act 47 economic recovery plan.

Peduto calls for a "parole patrol" program, in which parole agents would ride along with police to identify parole violators and repeat offenders. He wants a renewed effort to prosecute nuisance crimes such as graffiti and littering, and would place large red placards on buildings cited with numerous code violations to embarrass their owners into compliance.

Peduto supported the Murphy administration's latest five-year contract with the city firefighters union, which led to the closing of six fire stations, including one in his council district.

Peduto's plans are available on his Web site, www.billpeduto.com.

Advertise with us

Analysis

People liked the Community Oriented Police program, which often led to officers walking beats in neighborhood business districts. Police Chief Robert W. McNeilly Jr. dissolved the 70-officer division, replacing it with a more tightly supervised program of uniformed and bike police.

Most everyone would like more police on the streets, but the problem, as with every public service in Pittsburgh, is paying for it. Placing civilians in desk jobs would free up about 38 officers, by Peduto's numbers.

The parole program could work, though parole officers are not overseen by city government, so Peduto would need cooperation from Allegheny County.

Peduto made a large stink about the firefighter contract when it was unveiled in February, saying he would not support it unless it was based on computer studies of response times and for a term shorter than five years. Within 10 days, he changed his position and supported the pact.

Advertise with us

Michael Lamb

Michael Lamb

The county prothonotary, who oversees civil court records, has issued a six-page description of his public safety priorities, with a major focus on gun- and drug-related crime. Lamb would ask the Legislature for tighter gun restrictions within the city limits and work with the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency on drug prevention programs.

He has called for crackdowns on graffiti and litter and agrees that placing civilians in administrative Police Bureau jobs can get more uniforms on the streets. Breaking with the Murphy administration's current policy, Lamb says he would encourage participation with the Citizens Police Review Board, which has been largely ineffective without city government's support.

Lamb says he strongly supports the contract with the firefighters union and says the 2007 contract reopener with the union for further cuts would be "aggressively pursued" by his office.

Advertise with us

The Mount Washington man supports plans to restructure the medic bureau, perhaps by mergers with the Fire Bureau or local hospitals, and says technology has to be improved at the Bureau of Building Inspection.

His plan is available at www.lambformayor.com.

Analysis

Lamb and Peduto agree on many of these priorities and, also similarly, Lamb would need outside help from the state to get his major initiatives on drugs and crime completed.

Complying with review board investigations will not sit well with the Fraternal Order of Police and could force a legal showdown with the union. But others, such as the 35,202 city residents who voted to create the board in 1997, may be pleased somebody is taking it seriously.

Advertise with us

Bob O'Connor

Bob O'Connor

O'Connor has not issued policy papers on public safety matters, but in an interview last week, he said he would push for police to be better equipped and trained. He said he would try to hire more officers, largely by seeking state and federal policing grants and by cutting other police-related costs, partially by merging some operations, such as the police training academy, with county government.

The Fraternal Order of Police has endorsed O'Connor and given his campaign $10,000. Unlike the union -- and like the other candidates -- O'Connor says he supports the Civilian Police Review Board.

O'Connor said the city "had no choice" but to accept the firefighter contract and close stations in order to cut Fire Bureau costs. He said the Murphy administration should have explained the closings better and he supports efforts to place medic trucks or other city functions in the six closed station houses.

Advertise with us

Analysis

O'Connor is close to the police union and ,during his losing 2001 mayoral run, promised to replace McNeilly as chief, to the union's delight. O'Connor said last week that he had not promised any jobs to people in any city department should he become mayor, but Assistant Chief Nate Harper is seen as the frontrunner to replace McNeilly next year. He would be the first black police chief since Earl Buford stepped down in December 1995.

Correction/Clarification: (Published April 13, 2005) Pittsburgh mayoral candidate Bob O'Connor said he misspoke in remarks that appeared in the original April 10, 2005 version of this story on issues facing the mayoral candidates, when he said he favored eliminating the city's Citizens Police Review Board. O'Connor says he supports the board but favored the dissolution of federal oversight of the Police Bureau, which occurred last week.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.