Candidates for Pittsburgh mayor offered their visions for a revitalized Fifth and Forbes retail corridor Downtown yesterday and agreed that the city's 50 percent parking tax had to be scaled back, though they clashed on exactly how.

Keith Srakocic, Associated Press

Joe Weinroth, right, Republican candidate for mayor, answers a question while sitting with the Democratic candidates at a debate in Pittsburgh yesterday. The Democrats, from left to right, are Mike Lamb, Bob O'Connor and Bill Peduto.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

Republican mayoral candidate Joe Weinroth joined Democrats Bob O'Connor, Michael Lamb, and William Peduto at the Omni William Penn Hotel for a forum sponsored by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. A fourth Democratic candidate, Les Ludwig, was not invited.

The candidates offered varying solutions for the troubles that plague the ragtag Downtown retail corridor, one that has lost two department stores in the last year. They did agree that more residential housing, for students and others, should be a key component of that effort.

O'Connor, the former City Council president who has won the party endorsement, said retail would follow housing, adding it is hard for businesses to survive solely on lunch hour office-worker traffic.

He also said the emphasis should be on small retailers and restaurants, as it is in many of the neighborhood business districts, and not on the kind of single-developer strategy employed by Mayor Tom Murphy.

O'Connor also said the city must do a better job keeping Downtown clean and cracking down on panhandlers, not only in the center core but in neighborhood business districts as well.

Advertise with us

"There are more panhandlers in Squirrel Hill than there are in Manhattan," he said.

Lamb said that rather than making Fifth and Forbes a single development area, it should be divided into segments to give local developers a chance.

He embraced the idea of transforming the old G.C. Murphy's store into a market house and said that Fifth Avenue should be turned into a showcase for local retailers.

With so many colleges and technical schools Downtown, student housing should be a priority, the county prothonotary added.

"If you want to make Downtown more vibrant, put 2,000 20-year-olds in it. It will become a lot more vibrant," he said.

Advertise with us

Peduto, a city councilman who called the Fifth and Forbes corridor an "embarrassment," said the city should employ incentive programs similar to those offered in neighborhood business districts to attract more retailers Downtown.

Weinroth also believes the city should offer incentives to developers or businesses to invest in or to stay Downtown and must deal with each property individually, not as part of some "grand scheme." He also said the city must create a friendlier tax environment for businesses.

All four of the candidates said they supported a rollback in the city's 50 percent parking tax. But their various plans drew some of the sharpest criticism of the session.

O'Connor said a rollback could dramatically increase the number of people parking in the city, enough perhaps to offset the revenue lost with the reduction in the tax, a position Lamb called "ridiculous." O'Connor also called for budget cuts to offset revenue losses.

But Lamb also came under fire for his proposal to generate new revenue by being more aggressive in getting abandoned properties back on the tax rolls. Peduto claimed the proposal reeked of the kind of one-time budget fixes that pushed the city close to bankruptcy.

Advertise with us

Peduto offered no specific means of replacing the money, other than saying it had to be a "continuing regional source of revenue."

Weinroth said the city needed to look to the state Legislature to find a way to replace the lost revenue and to continue to pursue avenues to reform its tax structure.

Regardless of the approach, Lamb said reducing the 50 percent rate should be the "No. 1 tax priority" of the next mayor.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.