Four candidates for Pittsburgh mayor met together yesterday at a breakfast forum, but the engagement proved to be the eggs equivalent of over easy rather than hard-boiled.
John Beale, Post-Gazette
Candidates for mayor of Pittsburgh, left to right, Les Ludwig, Bill Peduto, Michael Lamb and Bob O'Connor, participate in their first debate yesterday at the Rivers Club, Downtown.
Click photo for larger image.
The hour-long session, sponsored by Leadership Pittsburgh Inc., sparked no fireworks or sharp differences, as Democratic candidates Bob O'Connor, Michael Lamb, William Peduto and Les Ludwig spent most of the time detailing their qualifications and positions rather than debating differences.
Republican candidate Joe Weinroth also was invited to the Rivers Club event but could not attend.
Three of the Democratic candidates were unanimous on one point: The job they want is still important, despite the current oversight by the state Act 47 team and a separate state-appointed board.
While Lamb, O'Connor, and Peduto said they supported greater cooperation with the county or other governments where appropriate, they weren't in a rush to sacrifice the mayor's office on the altar of consolidation.
"While we have some oversight and the Act 47 recommendations holding the purse strings to some degree, the operation of this government is going to depend on a strong mayor," said Lamb, the county prothonotary who has supported row office consolidation.
Where the city and the county are doing similar work, there should be consolidation, Lamb said, adding that the mayor should be encouraging such cooperation at all levels of government where possible.
O'Connor said the city first must get its fiscal act together and work toward greater cooperation with the county in areas like development and shared services before going any further.
"When we start doing those things, maybe we could start looking at a bigger picture. I'm not closing the door on anything. Everything should be on the table. I'm open to whatever's the right thing to do for the city and Allegheny County. Right now, though, I think that's a tough call to be doing right away," he said.
Peduto, a city councilman, said one of the reasons a merger occurred between Louisville, Ky., and Jefferson County government in 2003 is that many areas within the county were unincorporated at the time. That is not true in Allegheny County, with its 130 municipalities.
"Mt. Lebanon would still exist. Wilmerding would still exist. Wall would still exist," he said. "The only place that wouldn't exist is Pittsburgh."
At this point, Peduto said, governments in the region should be looking for "areas of commonality," perhaps through the councils of government, rather than mergers.
Ludwig came the closest to supporting a full consolidation, saying it could help the region to increase its political clout in Harrisburg, a la Philadelphia.
"I don't see anything wrong with a merger," he said.
As for what distinguishes the candidates from one another, Lamb highlighted his background as prothonotary and his leadership in the effort to switch to a county executive form of government and to reduce row offices.
He said he was the only candidate who has managed a large public office amid budget constraints. In terms of consolidation, he said he was the only one to have "actually walked the walk, going so far as to recommend the elimination of my own position."
O'Connor, the former three-term city councilman who has the Democratic Committee's endorsement and is the presumed frontrunner, stressed his business background, his experience on council, which included a stint as president, and an ability to bring labor, business, and government together to resolve problems.
"I saw this coming," the two-time mayoral candidate said of the city's financial problems. "I have the experience and the dedication. I can bring people together to fix this. This is very fixable."
Peduto cited leadership, saying he has helped to navigate council "through battle-tested times." He said he was the first to call for the city to enter Act 47 distressed status, at great political cost.
"It cost me the Democratic Committee endorsement. It cost me labor's endorsement for the rest of my political career. And you know what? If I had to do it again, I would because it was right. It was what was needed for Pittsburgh. That is leadership," he said.
Ludwig cited his creativity, saying he had proposed private investment accounts for Social Security more than 20 years ago, as well as his business experience as a dairy products owner and personal care home operator.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.