Even before the March 13 fire at Ebenezer Baptist Church became fatal, it was fearsome.

Close-up 2004: Ebenezer Baptist fire

The news that defined the year

Steve Mellon, Post-Gazette

Advertise with us

The Rev. J. Van Alfred Winsett stands on the Hill District lot where the 131-year-old Ebenezer Baptist Church stood before it was destroyed by fire in March 2004. Two firefighters died when the church's bell tower collapsed.

Click photo for larger image.

Tomorrow: Prisoner abuse scandal in Iraq hits home

It spread so quickly there was no time for the Rev. J. Van Alfred Winsett to retrieve anything from his Hill District church after he called 911 at 8:45 a.m. -- baptismal records, hymnals, Bibles all had to be left inside.

Just before 9:30 a.m., firefighters in the basement saw the fire suddenly retreat; the room went black. The captain realized what was happening and ordered his crew out, but the backdraft blew over their heads before they could retreat, blasting their faces and the hands raised to try to protect themselves. A firefighter upstairs was blown across the street by the force of the exploding gases. Five firefighters were hospitalized by the backdraft, which was fueled by gases that collected in a space between the basement ceiling and underside of the first floor.

Advertise with us

"I knew it was bad when they started knocking out my stained-glass windows," said Winsett. "When they knocked out the windows, I could see the fire fire just dancing in the pulpit. I knew: This is not a common fire. This is a bad fire."

After the backdraft, the fire went to four alarms and Fire Chief Peter J. Micheli Jr. was called to the scene. Firefighters pulled back, fighting defensively from Wylie Avenue and Devilliers Street. Within two hours, the flames were mostly knocked down. Winsett had set up quarters in a Salvation Army wagon and was in the midst of making arrangements for temporary worship and office space.

The chiefs and company commanders met and after checking the interior, Deputy Chief David Manfredo, the incident commander, sent crews in to douse hot spots, hoping to keep the building from being a total loss.

About 20 minutes later, Micheli decided to go to the hospital to check on the firefighters injured in the backdraft. He was walking toward his car, his back to the fire, when the 115-foot-tall bell tower crashed to the ground at 12:13 p.m. The pastor and the chief could do little more than witness the disaster that killed the church building and two of the firefighters trying to save it.

"It seems like that tower collapsed in slow motion," said Winsett. "You could go home and eat dinner and come back and it would still be collapsing."

Advertise with us

Micheli rushed back up to the church. "When I got back up there and saw how many firefighters were lying on the ground, the first thing that came to my mind was fatals. Was anybody missing?" said Micheli.

A head count indicated two were -- Battalion Chief Charles Brace and Master Firefighter Richard Stefanakis. Arriving crews pulled comrades from the rubble, began first aid, and started searching for the missing men.

"I saw [injured] men like cordwood, stacked up in the street," said Winsett. "My heart just went out to them." Paramedics worked to assess injuries and get the injured to hospitals.

This is an artist's rendering of the planned new Ebenezer Baptist Church.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

The search and recovery continued all afternoon; the bodies of Brace and Stefanakis were removed around 5 p.m.

For both Micheli and Winsett, the months since the fire have been difficult and busy.

Thirty firefighters were hurt in the backdraft and tower collapse, the injuries ranging from burns, broken bones and contusions to a serious eye injury and a crushed foot that resulted in amputation of toes. Twenty-one firefighters have returned to work, seven are still out, Micheli said. Of those, he expects three will definitely come back to work, two might and two will not be able to.

Two others have retired: Manfredo, the incident commander who was badly injured in the collapse, and Assistant Chief Arthur George, who took over command after Manfredo was hurt.

A seven-member board of inquiry established to investigate the fire came back with its report in May. It assessed no blame in the deaths but did call for upgrades in equipment and training. The fire's cause remains undetermined, but investigators suspect it was electrical.

Advertise with us

No policy changes were recommended, but a de facto one has occurred.

"The main thing coming out of this is that we are going to be more conservative in vacant buildings, be they occupied or not occupied," said Micheli. "We're addressing it in a class" that all firefighters will take, he said.

When lives are not at stake, the bureau will err on the side of protecting firefighters. This goes against the natural desire of firefighters to do what they're trained to do, Micheli said.

"They always say firefighters go in when everything else is coming out," he said. "Our duty is to save lives and property."

But Ebenezer made it clear that the desire to defeat the fire has to be tempered against the risk. Micheli has been chief since 1999, and was acting chief for 1 1/2 years before that. He said it's the worst fire of his 41 years of service.

Advertise with us

"Nobody wants this on their turn. Nobody. You want to protect them as the best you can. It's devastating when you lose them."

A federal investigation is still ongoing. A team from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health that specializes in firefighting investigates every fire in which a firefighter dies. Its report is expected in two or three months.

For the members of Ebenezer, the fire was a terrible blow. The congregation was formed 130 years ago and bought the former Presbyterian church on Wylie in 1914.

"The church is very dear, very dear to its members," said Winsett. Seventy-three percent live outside the Hill District but drive back on Sundays to attend church at Ebenezer.

After the fire, the church -- an original brick building covered with a gray stone facade -- as well as the adjoining 9-year-old annex were demolished. Ebenezer decided to rebuild on the same site, and plans to break ground late next month or in February on a church expected to cost $6 million to $7 million. The congregation has been worshipping down Wylie Avenue at the Hillcrest Seventh-day Adventists. A half hour into the fire, the pastor of that church, Jeff Baskin, offered his building for Ebenezer's Sunday services (Adventists worship on Saturdays), said Winsett. The church's many ministries have been farmed to sites around the neighborhood and Winsett's office space is in the basement of the Hill House across the street. He has been fund-raising to close the gap between the cost of the new church and the $4 million in insurance from the old.

Advertise with us

He said he can't pretend to understand why the beloved church had to be destroyed, but that he knows he was prepared for the aftermath. Every church he has served has required some building or rebuilding, so he has long experience in raising money and dealing with the logistics of working with contractors.

The ability to handle that task doesn't make the loss easier to take, though.

There is a replica of Ebenezer Baptist Church in the Carnegie Science Center's Miniature Railroad and Village. "When I looked at it I could see myself in that church," said Winsett. "When I left and came back, I saw a vacant lot."

Micheli has a bigger model in a room near his Ross Street office, created by the city Department of Engineering and Construction for the investigation. He can take it apart, pulling off the roof to expose the vestibule where Brace and Stefanakis were, peer inside the bell tower to a thin strip of wood that represents the exposed steel beam that investigators believe failed and set off the collapse, raise the whole church to point to the corner of the sanctuary floor where another group of firefighters was injured by falling beams, bricks and stones.

"It always comes back," said Micheli. "I think about it. It always sticks in your mind."

Advertise with us

Winsett said he still looks for the church as he drives in from his Point Breeze home or walks out of his office. "I'll never be able to divorce myself from what I saw. Sometimes people give me photos [of the fire] and say, 'Reverend, look, a picture.' I almost wish they wouldn't. I appreciate it. I don't want to be ungrateful. But I have to relive it every time," he said.

Now, though, a fence has gone up on the vacant lot in preparation for the construction next year. When people ask him, 'Reverend, when are we going home?' he can tell them he hopes this time next year they'll be close.

Inside the new church, he said, there will be a memorial to the two fallen firefighters.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.