HARRISBURG -- Gov. Ed Rendell insisted yesterday he has no plans to seek a commuter tax for Pittsburgh, despite comments to the contrary made during a phone conversation with Pittsburgh officials on Monday.

AP file photo

Gov. Ed Rendell

He said Pittsburgh's financial bailout legislation -- a $52 occupation tax and a 0.55 percent business payroll tax approved by the state Legislature early Sunday -- will raise enough new revenue to balance the city's budget, although just barely.

Advertise with us

At a Capitol news conference yesterday, Rendell claimed his remarks Monday about possibly seeking a commuter tax for Pittsburgh some time in the future were misunderstood and misconstrued by a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter who the governor said was "eavesdropping" on the phone conversation in a City Council member's office.

"The reporter probably violated most journalistic standards I've heard of," Rendell claimed. "He only listened to a portion of the call. If he was going to unethically eavesdrop, he should have eavesdropped on the whole conversation. There was no plan to use a commuter tax, nor did I say we need to use a commuter tax."

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette quoted Rendell yesterday as telling Pittsburgh officials that "we are not without the ability to go back and ask for a commuter tax."

That statement brought groans from Senate Republicans, who had said often during heated talks over the weekend that Rendell couldn't be trusted to keep his political promises and that he kept changing his legislative priorities.

Sen. Jane Orie, R-McCandless, who helped craft the Pittsburgh bailout bill, said she was in a "state of shock" when reading Rendell's comments in the Post-Gazette yesterday. "We had dealt with him in good faith."

Advertise with us

Rendell had given Orie and Sen. John Pippy, R-Moon, a letter on Saturday pledging not to seek a commuter tax if the Legislature approved the Pittsburgh bailout bill.

Orie and the Senate's top two Republicans, President Pro Tem Robert Jubelirer, of Altoona, and Majority Leader David Brightbill, of Lebanon, fired off a letter to Rendell yesterday saying it was "extremely disheartening to read that ... you are still searching for a way to impose a stiff commuter tax. A commuter tax is unfair, economically counterproductive and a huge breach of faith."

They said they didn't appreciate "getting blind-sided in this fashion on this issue."

Orie said the ban on the use of the commuter tax was also inserted into the Pittsburgh bailout legislation.

"When some House Republicans said that clause should be contained in the legislation, I thought they were being a little paranoid, but I guess they weren't," she added.

Advertise with us

Rendell insisted yesterday: "There was no plan to use a commuter tax." He said he would stick to the no-commuter-tax promise he made to Pippy and Orie.

Rendell said state Budget Secretary Michael Masch "has convinced me the [Pittsburgh bailout] plan will work. He says this plan will balance the budget, though there isn't much margin for error," meaning the new taxes and spending cuts won't produce a huge budget surplus.

Rendell said the main purpose of Monday's phone call to Pittsburgh City Council members was to urge them to go ahead with city spending cuts demanded by a state fiscal oversight board. Without such cuts, the city won't be able to use the new occupation tax and payroll tax revenues.

Rendell said the bailout legislation "isn't the best of plans, but you don't always get what you want here. I give Sens. Orie and Pippy a little bit of credit for banging a plan together. There were a lot of people who never thought we'd get to this point."

Rendell said he wouldn't join City Council President Gene Ricciardi in calling for an investigation into which council member let the Post-Gazette listen in on what Rendell called a "private" phone conversation.

Advertise with us

"I was the person most abused by what I consider a major journalistic lapse, but I will let it drop," he said. "It is what it is. We can't put the genie back in the bottle. City Council members may feel abused, because the conversation was private."

Meanwhile, Mayor Tom Murphy, at the request of Ricciardi and other council members, has asked city Solicitor Jacqueline Morrow to conduct a "full investigation" to determine if "any ethical violation and/or any federal, state or local criminal violations might have occurred" in allowing a reporter to listen in on Monday's conversation.

Morrow will have the discretion to use the city's Office of Municipal Investigations in the inquiry. Ricciardi said the office has the power to subpoena employees and put them under oath, but he added it cannot do so to council members. He is asking them to comply voluntarily.

Ricciardi said he's willing to let the matter drop if the council member who allowed the Post-Gazette to listen in on the conversation comes forward and apologizes.

Until that happens, those council members who were part of the conference call -- Ricciardi said there were four that he knew of -- are under suspicion.

Advertise with us

"This is not to muzzle journalists. This is not to squelch journalism or the free press. This has everything to do with a council member who betrayed this City Council," Ricciardi said.

While Ricciardi suggested that there could be violations of wiretapping or eavesdropping laws involved, U.S. Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan said in a statement she saw no federal violations.

"This is an unusual circumstance which may warrant inquiry by city of Pittsburgh officials. However, it does not appear that any federal violations are present," she said.

Mike Manko, a spokesman for District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., said his office won't become involved unless Morrow requests it.

While city officials were demanding an investigation to determine how a reporter got access to the conference call, a lawyer for the Pennsylvania Newspaper Publishers Association questioned whether the call violated the state's open meeting law.

Advertise with us

If a quorum of five or more council members participated in the call, and those members engaged in discussions or deliberations, there may have been open meeting issues involved, said Teri Henning, media law counsel for the association.

After announcing Morrow's investigation, Murphy repeated that neither he nor Rendell wants a commuter tax for the city in the short term. Rather, he said in comments to reporters, Rendell was speaking about a possibility of winning the taxes in the future.

Asked if the Post-Gazette's reporting was in error, Murphy said, "I'm not going to suggest that. I'd just simply suggest in the context of my understanding of the conversation, that conversation was not about the remote possibility of imposing a commuter tax sometime in December."

Asked if the matter was hurting the city's ability to fix its struggling budget, Murphy said: "It creates an awkward situation for everyone concerned."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.