Pittsburgh's police union intends to file a lawsuit this morning in Commonwealth Court in Harrisburg challenging the legality of the Act 47 economic recovery plan.
The four-count suit contends that the plan violates the statute governing the "distressed city" act by mandating changes such as wage freezes and employee contributions to health insurance instead of merely recommending them.
"We say that's beyond the power given them in their statute," Fraternal Order of Police attorney Bryan Campbell said yesterday.
Campbell would not provide a copy of the lawsuit, but he outlined its main arguments in an interview.
The FOP also contends that one of the plan's architects, Philadelphia's Public Financial Management, should not have been able to act in both as a consultant to state Department of Community and Economic Development Secretary Dennis Yablonsky to determine whether Pittsburgh qualified as a distressed city, and as a creator of the recovery plan.
"There was nothing wrong with them being a consultant, but then ultimately the contract to work it out should have gone to some other entity," Campbell said.
Another legal challenge raised by the FOP concerns whether the recovery plan should have jurisdiction over non-economic issues affecting police.
Campbell cited provisions under the plan to mandate drug and alcohol testing for officers after on-the-job accidents or injuries and to eliminate the ability of officers to pick their duty locations based on seniority.
"What's that have to do with economics?" Campbell said. "Act 47 doesn't give them the authority to completely dismantle a collective bargaining agreement and say, 'We're also going to take away non-economic items for you, and we're going to tell you [that] you can't bargain for any non-economic items.'"
The final part of the suit alleges violations of the U.S. and state constitutions relating to impairment of a contract.
The suit, to be filed by Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge 1 and its president, Michael Havens Jr., lists as defendants Mayor Tom Murphy, the city of Pittsburgh, Yablonsky and the Department of Community and Economic Development.
Also named are Public Financial Management and its partner in crafting the recovery plan, Downtown law firm Eckert Seamans.
The recovery plan, signed into law Wednesday, requires the city to make $33 million in spending cuts next year, most of them to the city work force, and imposes $41 million in new taxes, which require legislative approval. Together they would fill a projected $72 million deficit next year.
The cuts will affect the future contracts of all 3,657 city employees after their current contracts expire.
Since the police force is both the biggest single employee group -- with 902 members as of March -- and its contract expires at the end of this year, it is feeling pressure already.
Police would be subject to all the cuts other workers are facing -- a two-year wage freeze, controls on overtime and holidays, 15 percent contributions to health care, among others -- as well as cuts unique to police.
They include fitness standards, the "civilianization" of 38 administrative jobs and the elimination of the "master police officer" position. The police union also asked the Act 47 coordinators to amend language requiring drug-testing after all on-the-job injuries, saying the tests "may" be mandated by management instead.
Section 241 of the 1987 Municipalities Financial Recovery Act says the recovery team shall issue "recommendations" on "possible changes in collective bargaining agreements" and staffing levels.
As Campbell pointed out, that does not rise to a mandate, but, according to Department of Community and Economic Development administrator Fred Reddig, another part of the state law does give distressed cities power to affect future contracts. That includes arbitrated contracts, like those granted to police and firefighters.
Section 252 says: "A collective bargaining agreement or arbitration settlement executed after the adoption of a plan shall not in any manner violate, expand or diminish its provisions."
After a city adopts an Act 47 ordinance that includes recommendations, as the city did Wednesday, they have the force of state law, Reddig said yesterday.
Since Pittsburgh is the largest of the 20 municipalities to be designated distressed since 1987 -- and has the biggest work force -- lawsuits were virtually guaranteed. The firefighters union has also pledged to fight the recovery plan.
In a suit filed over an Act 47 plan, in Wilkinsburg, the state Supreme Court ruled in 1994 that distressed cities can enforce work force controls required under recovery plans.
Suits have also been filed since Act 47 took effect in 1987 challenging the commuter taxes allowed under the plans, and the ability of the economic development secretary to rule on distressed status.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.