With 16 schools slated to be closed or moved in Pittsburgh because of a declining population, it might be difficult to understand why one city middle school is scheduled for a 30,000-square-foot addition.

But school officials are defending a decision to expand Sterrett Classical Academy in Point Breeze, a $4.9 million project that several parents criticized during a public hearing before the city planning commission yesterday.

"We're not doing this so much for capacity as we are doing for equity," said Rick Fellers, the school district's chief of operations.

The school doesn't have a workable gymnasium, for instance; it has pillars and 8-foot ceilings that make it impossible to play many sports safely. The cafeteria and library also are smaller and shabbier than those in some other city schools. The cafeteria was built when children walked home for lunch, which is no longer the case, Fellers noted.

Advertise with us

But some Point Breeze residents raised concerns that the project would eliminate about half of a large playing field now available to residents. There also were concerns that the size of the building would block views for some residents who live on Reynolds Street.

"There's absolutely no way to justify the size of this," said Stephen Magley, a Point Breeze resident.

With the district's proposal last week to close several schools, "it is impossible to see how an argument can be made for the need for more school space," said Point Breeze resident Steve Awodey.

Several residents, including Mary Beth Doheny, a board member of the South Point Breeze neighborhood organization, urged school officials to consider re-orienting the proposed addition to save more of the ball field and to address some of the other concerns.

"By preserving the ball field, the city will be preserving its tax base in the long run," Doheny said. "This ball field is where the children of Point Breeze play. There has to be a compromise."

Advertise with us

Fellers called the loss of the athletic field space "unfortunate. We are field-poor. We hate to lose a field."

But, he added, "We want to make sure that all schools that we are keeping open provide equity."

Phyllis Cohen, president of the Sterrett Parent Teacher Organization, urged residents to keep an open mind about the project. She said the expansion is critical to meeting the needs of the middle school children who attend the school.

The gym addition would be built off the back left side of the school, Fellers said, when viewed from the school's front on Reynolds Street.

The old gym would be converted to classrooms; in all, four classrooms would be added to allow space for 100 more students. A conference room also is planned.

Advertise with us

Sterrett, which was built in 1899, has an enrollment of about 370.

The planning commission is expected to decide in four weeks whether to recommend to City Council that a conditional use be granted to allow the school to expand. Council has the final say.

If the clearance is granted, Fellers said, the district will take bids immediately and hire contractors in August. The project would be completed by August 2005.