The American Civil Liberties Union claimed a victory yesterday in its ongoing legal battle over the City of Pittsburgh's parade permit process.

After a lengthy hearing in U.S. District Court, Judge Joy Flowers Conti extended a preliminary injunction that allows groups to apply for parade permits if they give one week's notice and pay either $68 if their event would obstruct a street or $21 if their event would obstruct a sidewalk.

The judge also directed the city to amend its application forms by Wednesday to reflect those guidelines, said Witold Walczak, legal director of the ACLU's Pittsburgh chapter.

Witnesses testified yesterday they either received the same application they received two years earlier when applying for a parade permit or were met with confusing regulations when seeking permission to hold demonstrations.

Advertise with us

Joseph Parente, a Web site developer who organizes anti-abortion protests, said he tried for weeks to get a permit for a Jan. 31 rally. He said he was told he needed to apply for a permit 45 days in advance.

A proposed parade and protest ordinance would charge groups for police and public works services. The ACLU has argued that the costs essentially would eliminate protests, in violation of the First Amendment.

During the hearing, the city's attorney, Diego Correa, said a prior ordinance was repealed Tuesday. He unsuccessfully asked the judge to rule the case moot until City Council comes up with a new one.

Robert Kennedy, president of the Irish Society for Education & Charity, which organizes St. Patrick's Day festivities in Pittsburgh, said the ruling would benefit all cultural and ethnic groups.

He had said that under the proposed change, the society would have had to pay about $10,000 -- about half of its annual fund raising -- which would force the parade elsewhere.