MEYERSDALE, Pa. — Out behind Meyersdale Area High School and its football field, the Casselman River flows through the Shaw Mines complex, a moonscape of coal mines where more than a century of mine drainage has stained the waterway yellow and all but killed it.

Ongoing efforts have sought to restore aquatic life to that part of the Casselman and protect the Youghiogheny River, which receives the Casselman’s flow in the town of Confluence and is a centerpiece of outdoor recreation in the Laurel Highlands.

But several environmental organizations and individuals say those efforts face a potentially serious setback from a plan to locate a 131-acre mine waste disposal site along the Casselman and within view of bicyclists on the Great Allegheny Passage.

The state Department of Environmental Protection is considering permits to allow Heritage Coal & Natural Resources LLC to build and operate the Shaw Mine coal refuse site in Summit and Elk Lick townships, and discharge wastewater into an unnamed and polluted Casselman tributary.

Advertise with us

A technical review of the project’s Coal Refuse Disposal Area permit is underway by the DEP, which has scheduled a virtual public hearing on whether it should approve a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit.

That hearing is scheduled for 1 to 3 p.m. Wednesday. The DEP also is taking public comment on the proposed permits.

The Mountain Watershed Association, an environmental organization, as well as a number of those submitting comments so far say the DEP should be taking steps to reduce mine drainage, not permitting new sources of it.

“Adding more toxic coal waste to our hillsides and valleys is not needed,” the association says on its website. The coal refuse project would sit atop an abandoned deep mine that has “a history of environmental degradation,” the group says, and overlap an operating surface mine known as Summit 2.

It is both the region’s mining history and the refuse project’s potential future impact on water quality that concerns Stacey Magda, a community organizer with the Mountain Watershed Association, one of the regional environmental organizations that requested the hearing.

Advertise with us

In addition to ongoing discharges of acid mine drainage into the Casselman from a honeycomb of deep and strip mines in the Shaw Mines complex, Ms. Magda said the specter of the May 1993 blowout of acidic water from the mines continues to loom large over the Casselman. The event caused a massive fish kill in the lower 42 miles of the river all the way to Confluence.

“The coal refuse proposal would add additional pollution discharges to an historically impaired river,” Ms. Magda said. “It’s the wrong direction to go at a time when outdoor recreation has been amplified. Instead we need to be looking at a bigger picture of the river’s future beyond industrialization.”

She said the continuing existence of a yellow-orange plume of pollution coming out of the Shaw Mines and into the Casselman raises questions about the level of degradation acceptable to the DEP and to Heritage.

Eric Harder, who heads the Youghiogheny Riverkeeper organization, said the DEP has multiple mining bureau vacancies, creating “permitting and enforcement gaps.”

“My worry is that they’re trying to add more gob (coal waste) piles in this watershed,” Mr. Harder said. “And that stretches the ability to treat those discharges.”

Advertise with us

The draft permit for the refuse site includes effluent limits for two coal site wastewater drains or “outfalls” from settling and treatment ponds into an unnamed tributary of the Casselman. That tributary consists almost wholly of acid mine drainage from the abandoned deep mine beneath the footprint of the proposed refuse pile on Heritage’s Summit 2 strip mine.

The discharges, according to a notice in the Pennsylvania Bulletin, would include iron, manganese, aluminum, suspended solids and sulfates. The notice says the tributary and the Casselman already are “impaired” due to mining discharges, and, “This facility proposes a new mining related discharge to the impaired stream/watershed.”

The DEP, in email responses to questions, said the draft permit’s effluent limitations are within the Total Maximum Daily Load limits for the Casselman, and added the department does not anticipate the discharge would contribute to the impairment of the receiving waterways.

“DEP cannot approve permits that have the potential to degrade water quality,” the department said. The department’s permitting authority “requires that permits issued will not cause or contribute to impairments and must be protective of human health and aquatic life.”

Any permit the DEP issues also must pass U.S. Environmental Protection Agency review.

Advertise with us

Dan Parise, Heritage Coal’s head engineer, said in an email response to questions that the waste storage area would receive material from the company’s four surface mines. It would be sandwiched between plastic liners and layers of highly alkaline limestone to minimize runoff and neutralize any acidity in the rock. Runoff from the site would funnel through a treatment system.

He said the effluent limits for the treated discharges would be “extremely low and are much more restrictive than the current limits” in the receiving stream, which flows untreated into the Casselman River.

Mr. Parise said most of the water quality improvements to the Casselman River in the last 25 years were due to an ongoing remining initiative that began in the 1990s. That work has reduced levels of iron, aluminum and acidity in the river and aided the re-establishment of a warm water fishery.

“Having an approved refuse disposal permit,” Mr. Parise said, “will help the remining initiative to continue by providing a safety factor for mine refuse when planning for a future with more restrictive environmental and market factors.”

Roger Latuch, a dairy farmer and Casselman River Watershed Association board member, said the group is keeping a close eye on the proposal.

Advertise with us

”We’re not going to oppose it, but we are going to make every effort to make sure it’s done right,” Mr. Latuch said. “We realize the value of this watershed because we live in it. It’s a sub-watershed of the Youghiogheny and the Monongahela rivers where more than 2 million people get their drinking water. So there’s a lot of very vested partners here.”

He said Heritage was a helpful partner in efforts a year ago to design a treatment system for the legacy discharges from the abandoned Shaw Mines complex. The project fell through, however, because federal and state mine reclamation funding can’t be used in areas where active mining is taking place.

A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette review of the DEP’s online inspection reports on Heritage-owned mines shows the vast majority found no permit violations; most mining violations were minor and marked “abated.”

But many that were cited by state inspectors involved polluted water discharges.

At Heritage’s Craighead Mine, which began operations in Stonycreek Township in 2018, DEP records show seven notices of violation or compliance orders were issued by the DEP and the company was assessed penalties totaling $34,290. Those enforcement actions included alleged failures to employ proper erosion controls, discharges of water that did not meet permit standards, failure to report noncompliance with the mine’s National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit. NPDES permit, and two violations for “failure to conduct mining activities in a way to protect fish and wildlife.”

Advertise with us

Records for the Fisher Mine, opened in Elk Lick Township by Rosebud Mining in 2013 and owned by Heritage since 2017, show Heritage has received three notices of violation or compliance orders and fined a total of $2,400. The alleged violations include two for failure to design, construct and maintain erosion and sedimentation controls.

At the Summit 2 Mine in Elk Lick Township, previously owned by Rosebud Mining and Action Mining, and the "largest and oldest surface mine permit" in the state, according to Heritage, inspectors have issued five compliance orders or notices of violation since December 2017. Two of those violations were for discharging water that didn’t meet permit limits, for which Heritage paid penalties totaling $2,035.

Those wishing to either present testimony at or watch the hearing Wednesday must contact Lauren Fraley at lfraley@pa.gov (421-442-4203) at least 24 hours before the hearing. Testimony is limited to three minutes.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com