Pittsburgh city Councilwoman Darlene Harris, and three other Pittsburgh office seekers, may still be arguing over the May primary by the time everyone else has cast their ballots in November.
Ms. Harris mounted an unsuccessful bid to challenge Mayor Bill Peduto’s re-election during the Democratic primary. During that run, she flouted a 2015 ordinance requiring candidates to file monthly disclosures of financial activity. The city’s Ethics Hearing Board was slated to decide whether to fine her for not complying, but on Wednesday Mr. Harris’ attorney argued that the ordinance itself was illegal.
Invoking a concept called “pre-emption,” Jim Burn told the six board members on hand that “campaign-finance [law] is reserved to the state.” If local officials could make up their own rules, he warned, “The next thing you know, we have campaign finance run amok,” with each municipality devising its own policies.
Calling that objection “an important issue that needs to be resolved,” hearing office Bill Ward gave Mr. Burn until Oct. 11 to file a motion objecting to the procedure. Attorneys for the board would have until Oct. 25 to respond, moving any proceeding into late October at the earliest.
A similar discussion took place earlier in the afternoon, when City Council District 4 candidate Mark Johnson also said state law barred the city’s penalties.
In any case, he noted, he was removed from contention due to defective petitions well before the primary. “This is very, very silly,” said Mr. Johnson. “I haven’t done anything that matters.”
In 2007, the state Supreme Court upheld Philadelphia’s ability to impose contribution limits on local candidates. But while state law is silent on contribution limits — silence the court interpreted as permitting local limits — the state already sets a schedule for reporting financial activity.
This is the first time Pittsburgh’s ordinance has been tested, and the outcome could also affect two other city council candidates. On Monday, Gary McBurney and Cletus Cibrone Abate had hearings for failing to file reports. Both pled ignorance of the city rules.
Mr. Johnson, a lawyer with a background in government, said that if the board upheld his fine, he would appeal to the state’s Commonwealth Court. “People deserve to be protected from the city’s overreaching,” he said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.