Pittsburgh police Chief Cameron McLay has asked two agencies to investigate his appearance in uniform last week at the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia after his prime-time speech there raised the ire of the police union and drew allegations that he violated municipal code.
An investigator — who could be a civilian or a police officer — has yet to be assigned from the city’s Office of Municipal Investigations, which is under the Law Department, according to Timothy McNulty, spokesman for Mayor Bill Peduto.
But the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board, an advisory body, had already launched an inquiry into Chief McLay’s appearance. The board will look at whether the chief violated the city code, ethics regulations, professional standards and rules governing the conduct of public employees.
Fraternal Order of Police Lodge No. 1 president Robert Swartzwelder was not impressed by the chief’s request in light of statements by Mr. Peduto and his chief of staff, Kevin Acklin, that the convention speech did not run afoul of the city code. The code says officers are not permitted to “campaign for a candidate for any office or for a ballot issue while on duty, while wearing a uniform or while on City property” or while identifying as police bureau employee.
“I would say you’re wasting a lot of money and time and effort ...” Officer Swartzwelder said Monday. “First of all, he went there with permission of the mayor, obviously ... He’s the only one that can discipline the chief. So why are you wasting a bunch of OMI investigators’ time and effort and money when the mayor’s already come out publicly saying there’s no wrongdoing?”
Elizabeth Pittinger, the review board’s executive director, said the chief’s appearance onstage one week ago to discuss recent shootings of and by police, community relations and criminal justice reform demands a thorough analysis. Of critical importance, she said, is ensuring that there is not a double standard in how rank-and-file officers are treated compared with the chief.
“The public deserves a full vetting of the controversy,” said Ms. Pittinger, who called it a “messy, messy thing.”
She said that the chief “probably technically violated the code, but that the greater good was served,” a remark that set off Officer Swartzwelder. “I didn’t know that’s how we evaluate police conduct,” he said.
While the board’s review is underway, Ms. Pittinger seemed to be leaning toward the view — endorsed by Officer Swartzwelder — that the convention was inherently a political activity.
“It’s perception. That’s what we’re dealing with, and whether or not there was improper political activity when Chief McLay appeared at a partisan venue in full uniform,” Ms. Pittinger said. “He did not overtly endorse any candidate. He did not overtly endorse any plank of any platform endorsed by the Democratic National Convention. But it was a partisan venue, and it’s hard to interpret that in any way other than engaging in political activity.”
Mr. McNulty said the convention organizers reached out to the city the day before the chief’s speech, “and the mayor told the chief that it was up to the chief if he wanted to do it or not and embraced the opportunity to talk about community policing in front of millions of people. And the mayor’s only stipulation was that it not be political in any way, and it wasn’t.”
The chief of staff checked “the relevant code language,” Mr. McNulty said, adding, though, that he did not believe the city solicitor was consulted. He defended the independence of OMI’s investigation.
“OMI is an independent office under the Law Department and the solicitor, and they will produce a fact-based report without any influence whatsoever from this administration,” Mr. McNulty said. “The FOP president doesn’t know what he’s talking about.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.