Democrat Steve Larchuk was spared the indignity of running for Congress against his will when a judge granted his request to be removed from the April 26 ballot.

Mr. Larchuk, who almost succeeded in knocking opponent Erin McClelland off the primary ballot in the 12th Congressional District race, abruptly withdrew from the race on March 24.

Pedro A. Cortes, Pennsylvania’s secretary of the commonwealth, Wednesday asked a Commonwealth Court judge to deny Mr. Larchuk’s request to get his name taken off the ballot.

This morning Commonwealth Court Judge Senior Judge Dan Pellegrini granted Mr. Larchuk’s petition.

Advertise with us

The 12th District, including Beaver County and parts of Allegheny, Cambria, Lawrence, Somerset and Westmoreland counties, is represented by Rep. Keith Rothfus of Sewickley, who is unchallenged in the Republican primary. Mr. Larchuk of Franklin Park and Ms. McClelland of Harrison were the Democrats hoping to face him in November.

Mr. Larchuk, who had been endorsed by the Allegheny County Democratic Committee, initially had legally challenged some of the signatures on the nominating petitions submitted by Ms. McClelland. After a seven-hour hearing on March 17 and a 5½-hour hearing March 22, a judge invalidated 26 signatures, leaving Ms. McClelland only 13 signatures over the required minimum of 1,000.

Observers believed Mr. Larchuk was on the verge of succeeding when he suddenly quit, five days before a third hearing. “All that matters is defeating Keith Rothfus in November,” Mr. Larchuk said in an email announcing his decision. “This protracted court battle and primary contest have become counterproductive and so I am stepping aside.”

But to have his name removed from the ballot, Mr. Larchuk had to submit an appeal to the secretary of the commonwealth and Commonwealth Court. In his petition, he acknowledged that his request came “well after the March 2 deadline for withdrawing” and that he understood “I may only withdraw my candidacy by order of the court.”

Mr. Cortes, however, said the request was impractical and should be denied.

Advertise with us

“With only four weeks until the primary election, all six of the counties in the 12th Congressional District have printed official absentee ballots, provisional ballots and emergency paper ballots,” he wrote to the court. “At least three of the counties have programmed the ballots on their electronic voting systems for Election Day; and the six counties have sent out 644 absentee ballots to military and overseas citizens,” of which 29 already have been returned.

“It’s a bizarre thing,” said Chuck Pascal, an attorney for Ms. McClelland. “If the court removes a candidate as the basis of a challenge, no one questions it. But if a candidate wants to be removed, the state is saying, ‘You can’t be removed even if you want to be.’

“Say the challenge against Erin went forward. If she was removed, they would have reprinted absentee ballots or reprogrammed the voting machines. Or they would have posted a notice in every machine saying that, per a court order, this candidate has been removed from the ballot.”

Department of State press secretary Wanda Murren said, ”It is too late for Mr. Larchuk to have his name removed from the ballot.”

The latter is what the McClelland campaign is seeking in this case. “We’re not asking to reprogram anything, but to put up a notice,” Mr. Pascal said. If voters ignored that notice and voted for Mr. Larchuk anyway, Mr. Pascal said, those votes would be ignored. The same thing would happen with ballots that had already been cast. Basically, Ms. McClelland would be the nominee no matter what.

Advertise with us

In his order, Judge Pellegrini wrote that if the candidate’s name can’t be removed, county boards of elections can post notice about the withdrawal, and that similar notice could be sent for absentee ballots.

Ms. McClelland lost to Mr. Rothfus in 2014, and the University of Virginia Center for Politics has classified the 12th District as a “safe Republican” seat.

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1456. Christ Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.