Street trees, especially in Downtown, have a hard time growing up healthy. Vehicles emit pollution and the large ones clip their branches. Many trees are trying to grow without adequate tree pits, and the tree pits that exist are often compacted and plagued with litter.

The use of rock salt, or sodium chloride, to melt ice on sidewalks adds to the insult. It is harmful to tree roots and raises the pH level of soil.

A collaboration of organizations has negotiated a good deal — $6,200 for 21 tons of magnesium chloride, a safer alternative — and has begun applying the alternative ice-melting agent to Downtown sidewalks.

The Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust, PNC Bank and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership got a 69 percent reduction on the cost by ordering in bulk.

Advertise with us

No public money is involved.

The obstacle for the average consumer is cost. Magnesium chloride — and the even better alternative, calcium magnesium acetate — can cost two to four times more than rock salt.

But considering the cost of replacing trees and shrubbery, and their value when healthy, the benefit is worth it.

As is true with all decisions that affect the environment, the immediate cost of something isn’t the cost of something. Shortsighted decisions — think Flint, Mich., and its “cost-saving” water delivery system — can cost the public dearly and in ways greater than money.

Marah Vecenie, the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy’s community forestry coordinator, advises consumers shopping for de-icers to read the ingredients to see how much rock salt is in a product that claims to be eco-friendly.

Advertise with us

“A company could say this is safe for your pets and trees but a lot of these products have mostly rock salt,” she said. “The percentages should be listed. Some companies are trying to trick you and won’t list them, but they are required to tell you, so you might have to go on their websites. They don’t make it easy.”

Jeff Bergman, the conservancy’s director of community forestry and director of TreeVitalize Pittsburgh, said he bought a $12 canister, maybe a gallon, of magnesium chloride two years ago for use at his home and still has some.

“I use it the way the directions say to,” he said.

Many people don’t. I have seen crews dump rock salt on sidewalks and along curbs. If strewn widely, the amount in these piles could cover many square feet of walkway.

If overused, both rock salt and magnesium chloride damage concrete, but magnesium chloride is better for the groundwater, for the trees and shrubs and for pets. Rock salt not only burns their paw pads, especially when mixed with snow, but it can be lethal if ingested.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership held a workshop in Downtown last month to educate various stakeholders on de-icing practices. Representatives from the city-county Sports & Exhibition Authority, the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, Gateway Center and the David L. Lawrence Convention Center were among those present.

It’s reassuring to know more people are paying more attention to the quality of our soil, our groundwater and our urban canopy. This is a network of heavy hitters who have influence, and the more the merrier. It would be good to see the Pittsburgh Pirates get on board. The soaping of the sidewalks along PNC Park is hard on trees and unnecessary. Numerous trees on Federal and General Robinson streets on the North Shore have had to be replaced in part because of the runoff into tree pits.

Mr. Bergman said the partners bringing tons of eco-friendly de-icer to Downtown are all interested in green practices and see trees as “a major asset’ to the quality of life in Downtown.

“We’ve been partners with the Cultural Trust for years doing a lot of greening work, planters and baskets and trees,” he said. “The trust really values [its] trees. They’re all city trees, but they have funded a good amount of the green work.

“The Conservancy fronted the money to plant about 400 trees in the last five years [in] Downtown, so it was extremely important for us to protect that investment.”

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.