Christopher Katchur, whom police say was fatally shot Wednesday night by his estranged wife, died with the restraining order he had gotten against her mere hours earlier still on him.
Mr. Katchur, 52, had left the Pittsburgh Municipal Courts Building, Downtown around 5 p.m. after successfully getting the 24-hour emergency Protection-From-Abuse order against Patricia L. Katchur, 55, who is now in jail and charged with criminal homicide. He wrote in his petition that he was fearful, that Mrs. Katchur had torn up their McKeesport home and burned their marriage license in the kitchen sink.
He also explained that his wife had two guns and permits to carry them.
District Judge James J. Hanley Jr. on Thursday said he told Mr. Katchur to go right to the McKeesport police so an officer could serve a copy of the order on his wife. The paperwork temporarily evicted her from the couple’s home on Orchard Street and ordered her not to abuse or contact him.
County police Superintendent Charles Moffatt said Mr. Katchur had gone right home from the courthouse. He said the victim did not contact or stop by the McKeesport Police Department to handle the PFA.
“He was just getting home when it occurred. He didn’t have time. He was just coming back from getting it. He still had it on him,” Superintendent Moffatt said. “Traditionally what you do is take it to the department. But I wouldn’t put it on him.”
But one thing Judge Hanley could not do was take Mrs. Katchur’s guns away. Despite what he called a “red flag” that she had firearms, his hands were tied; under state law that power rests only Common Pleas Court judges, who can order weapons relinquished as part of granting a temporary restraining order.
“There’s still a lot that can be tightened up in this [PFA] law to make it more protective. Obviously being able to get the weapons at that level would have been helpful. But weapons are complicated, and the Legislature has left that to the Common Pleas judges,” said Lorraine Bittner, legal director for the Women’s Center and Shelter of Greater Pittsburgh.
Judge Hanley said Mr. Katchur did not seem worried about the guns. But it was a concern to him.
Mr. Katchur said he had changed the locks and did not think his wife was at home.
“That's when I reiterated, 'Look, you've got to have the police serve this on her,' " Judge Hanley said. “I said, 'Take it to the McKeesport police. At least they'll have a copy to do the service.' ”
Little did Mr. Katchur know that on Wednesday his wife of almost five years -- armed with two handguns and finding herself locked out -- yanked an air conditioning unit from a window and climbed in, according to an affidavit. She told police that she went upstairs and fell sleep after taking an Ambien.
About two hours later, the affidavit said, Mr. Katchur returned home, yelling and screaming and telling his wife to get out. He told her he had a PFA, she recounted to an Allegheny County Police homicide detective, and said she was going to jail.
Mrs. Katchur said she got her .38-caliber revolver from upstairs, found her husband sitting on the porch steps “ranting and raving” and shot him at close range, the affidavit said. She told police “it was not an accident,” according to the affidavit.
Tiffany Fichera, 24, of McKeesport, who is friends with Mr. Katchur’s family, said his two sons from a previous marriage are having a hard time coping.
Melissa Ernst, Mr. Katchur’s niece, knew that the couple was having problems but insisted that her uncle was never the aggressor.
“She would overreact,” she said. “He was always the voice of reason, always calm. She’d be in the middle of the street screaming at the top of her lungs.”
Andrew Goldstein and Liz Navratil contributed. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.