Without knowing the back story, a viewer might have missed the significance behind a musical pivot at Pope Francis’ most recent Christmas Mass at St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome.
But Manfred Honeck knew.
Knowing the context, and when it’s been subverted, is key for the music director of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, who accepted a conducting role at the Mass at the invitation of Pope Francis himself.
And he also knew personally, as a Catholic whose deep religious commitment is central to both his life and his work.
Traditionally at the papal Christmas Masses, Mr. Honeck said, a choir uses a Gregorian chant for the Credo, or core statement of Catholic beliefs. But midway through this year’s piece, it paused. As the pope walked forward and knelt on a prie-dieu, Mr. Honeck conducted a small ensemble, beginning with a quiet string introduction, drawing in woodwinds and leading to a soprano solo.
The eight-minute piece revolved around a single Latin sentence repeated with dulcet conviction: Et incarnátus est de Spíritu Sancto ex María Vírgine, et homo factus est (“And by the Holy Spirit was incarnate of the Virgin Mary and became man”).
Read More
The text, referring to Jesus’ human birth, is central to the Christmas message. In a precedent-shattering way that has become typical of his papacy, Francis asked that Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s musical setting of the text, in his Mass in C minor, be inserted within the traditional chant.
In a brief meeting with the pontiff before the Mass, “he told me that Mozart is his favorite composer,” Mr. Honeck recalled in an interview. “It’s wonderful how he thinks, how he is not afraid to change tradition. The words are the same, it’s just the music is different.”
It’s no surprise that the Austrian Honeck, 56, who has been music director of the Pittsburgh Symphony since 2008, was attuned to the spiritual significance of the event.
Or that he is often drawn to religious classics such as Mozart’s “Requiem” — which he has adapted by interweaving literary readings with the music, in an echo of the funeral liturgy’s alternation of spoken and sung words — or Johann Sebastian Bach’s “St. John Passion,” which is scheduled for next season.
Mr. Honeck attends Mass daily, often at St. Mary of Mercy Catholic Church, a few blocks from Heinz Hall and his Downtown apartment. His permanent home in his native Austria comes complete with a chapel.
“It means a lot to me to go to Mass,” he said. “Like cleaning the teeth, you are cleaning your soul and reflecting on your life.”
Yet asked if “devout” accurately described him, Mr. Honeck demurred.
“I would never call me a devout Catholic in [the sense of being] extreme in the faith. I would say I take the faith very seriously. I think I’m not alone with that,” he said, citing friends from other religions with the same commitment.
But “when you call yourself Catholic, then stay to that belief and practice it. It makes no sense to call me Catholic if I don’t practice it.”
The orchestra under Mr. Honeck’s baton will feature music in a spiritual key this Friday through next Sunday, April 17-19, if not entirely in an orthodox religious sense.
Mr. Honeck will be joined by his brother, Rainer Honeck, concertmaster of the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra, for a performance of Benjamin Britten’s Violin Concerto, an anguished response to the catastrophic Spanish Civil War. Other pieces will include a suite from Antonin Dvorak’s mythic opera “Rusalka” and Pyotr Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 6 (“Pathetique”) which Tchaikovsky saw as a requiem, the conductor said.
But, Mr. Honeck insisted, his priority is producing great music, religious or not.
“There are a lot of other requiems which are not so good, which I don’t perform,” he said. “We do other pieces which have nothing to do with Christianity at all.”
And he said he works to be inclusive of other faiths. For example, the PSO’s performances of the Mozart Requiem included the Jewish poet Nelly Sachs’ piercing meditations on the Holocaust.
Before performances, Mr. Honeck often holds prayer gatherings with those musicians who choose to attend.
Such workplace prayer meetings, whether in a factory or office, have stirred controversy at times because it can provide workers a chance to bond with the boss if they share his beliefs, or pretend to, while excluding those who don’t.
But Mr. Honeck says he doesn’t see that happening. Elsewhere, he said, he has joined in prayer with Jews, Muslims and others. At one of the orchestra’s Music for the Spirit concerts — faith-themed programs often held at area houses of worship — “there was also prayer with Buddhists,” he said.
“This is truly my biggest wish, that all religious groups are coming together and making music together and understanding each other,” he said. “I think every faith can contribute something to human beings. We have to work on that, that everybody’s understanding that, without also losing their identity.”
(He can find an example in high places for that. The pope’s invitees for the Christmas Mass also included a Jewish Israeli soprano, Chen Reiss, who sang the solo for “Et Incarnatus Est.” “It is true that it was Christian music and I am Jewish, but it didn’t matter,” she told the Times of Israel. “I was totally in the moment, and I felt its holiness.”)
Mildred Myers, a member of the symphony board who has helped Mr. Honeck prepare his public talks, said she respects him and his deep beliefs even though she doesn’t share them.
“I’m Jewish by background, I practice nothing, but somehow we’ve formed a very close relationship,” she said. “His faith is so much a part of who he is, it imbues everything he does, his art and everything else. ... If you’re going to have a relationship with him, you’re going to have to say that the way it is.”
Mr. Honeck is also “pragmatically faithful,” added Ms. Myers, a teaching professor of business management communication at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business.
“He knows how to work a room, he knows how to work an organization, he knows how to pull organizational strings to make things happen,” she said. That’s the pragmatic part. As for the faithful part: “He would tell you he’s inspired by God to do those things.”
The Rev. Ronald Lengwin, a priest with the Diocese of Pittsburgh, said he sensed Mr. Honeck as a “kindred spirit” from his arrival in Pittsburgh and his support for continuing the religiously themed Music for the Spirit programs, which had started years before Mr. Honeck’s arrival.
Father Lengwin said organizers hoped for “a champion” of the program in which “people could come together with some different beliefs and still have this great love for God, and then Manfred Honeck appears. From my own particular belief, this is God’s providence at work.”
Mr. Honeck said such programming is well-suited to the community.
“I see Pittsburgh as a religious city,” he said. “I have met so many people of different faiths who very honestly live, who take care about that.”
Anne Martindale Williams, principal cellist for the orchestra and a member since 1976, said Mr. Honeck “lives his faith through his work, whether that’s his work ethic or how he treats people, colleagues or strangers. .. It’s very evident when he’s on the podium. I’ve never heard him speak unkindly to a member of the orchestra. There’s no temperamental maestro on the podium.”
She said he invites people of various faiths to the pre-concert prayer sessions. There may have been “some strained feelings” from some who didn’t feel comfortable with them when the sessions began, “but it’s very low-key,” she said.
Typically, participants pray by name for those who are ill or struggling. “And we pray for the audience who’s coming to listen to the concert, that something that is played will resonate with them,” she said.
Mr. Honeck added of the prayers: “Most of all, there is a big part of it just to thank ... that we can do our concerts, that we can make music.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1416, Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.