The determination of how much power Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner has is headed for Common Pleas Court.

Ms. Wagner said Monday her attorneys will file a petition this week to enforce subpoenas against three county administrators who did not attend a meeting Monday to discuss a proposed audit she wants to conduct. County Executive Rich Fitzgerald filed a motion last week to quash the subpoenas, arguing the controller’s office isn’t empowered — or qualified — for such an audit.

Earlier this month, Ms. Wagner subpoenaed county manager William McKain, Mr. Fitzgerald’s chief of staff Jennifer Liptak and county police Superintendent Charles Moffatt so her office could begin a review of county police department operations.

County solicitor Andrew Szefi notified the controller in a letter Friday that the officials would not take part in the meeting, pending a judge’s ruling on his motion to quash the subpoenas.

Advertise with us

“The controller cannot issue subpoenas in pursuit of an audit that she is not legally permitted to conduct,” Mr. Szefi wrote in the court documents, adding that using subpoenas to force attendance at a meeting to discuss an audit is “outside the scope of the controller’s subpoena power, or any recognized use of a subpoena.”

At issue is whether Ms. Wagner can conduct a performance audit, which she termed the “gold standard” of auditing.

“Those are the kind of audits that really show how you can achieve efficiency and cut the waste and so forth, and not just looking at whether two plus two equals four,” she said.

Ms. Wagner also has met resistance in efforts to audit authorities where Mr. Fitzgerald appoints some or all of the members.

In a statement, county spokeswoman Amie Downs and Ms. Liptak maintained that the law is not on Ms. Wagner’s side.

Advertise with us

“Like the rest of the elected office holders in this county, she has duties and functions that she is responsible for performing. Those do not include performance audits,” Ms. Liptak said. She also said the administration “is not making any attempt to keep government activities confidential.”

A hearing has not been scheduled. Mr. Szefi filed his motion with county Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, who couldn’t provide a timeline Monday. He said the matter “would obviously be something that would be decided in the not-too-distant future.”

The two issues — quashing the subpoenas or enforcing them — likely will be addressed at the same time.