The jury on Monday reached a unanimous verdict on only two of the seven counts against Leon Ford.
But it was a victory for the 21-year-old East Liberty man, nonetheless.
The jurors found him not guilty of aggravated assault, which is a felony, the most serious charge against him.
There was little reaction in the courtroom, aside from Mr. Ford’s father, Leon Ford Sr., pumping his fist in the air, and attorney Thomas Malone happily slapping his client on the back.
The panel of seven women and five men told Judge Donald E. Machen of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court just after 4:30 p.m. Monday that it was “hopelessly deadlocked” on charges of recklessly endangering, resisting arrest and escape.
Assistant district attorney Robert Schupansky told the court that, as with every other hung jury, his office would review the case and make a determination whether it will be retried.
Read More
Because Mr. Ford is not in custody, the prosecution would have a year to take him to trial on the five remaining counts.
Mr. Ford was pulled over in Highland Park about 9 p.m. on Nov. 11, 2012, by officers from Pittsburgh’s Zone 5 station. The traffic stop — for speeding and going through a stop sign — went on for more than 16 minutes as the officers debated the driver’s identity. Although Mr. Ford provided three valid forms of ID, including his driver’s license, insurance card and pink slip for his car, the officers thought he might be another man named Lamont Ford, who was wanted on an outstanding arrest warrant.
The officers claimed that they saw a bulge in Mr. Ford’s sweatpants, and when they asked him to exit his vehicle, he refused. One officer, David Derbish, then climbed in the front passenger seat of the car, while two others, Andrew Miller and Michael Kosko, attempted to pull him from the driver’s side.
In a dashboard video recording taken from a patrol car, Mr. Ford’s car can be seen quickly pulling away from the curb. Officer Derbish, who was still inside, claimed he feared for his safety and fired five shots at Mr. Ford.
He was left paralyzed.
The jury, which requested to view the video several times, deliberated about 12 hours over Tuesday and Wednesday, before having to start over on Thursday when one member of the panel had to be replaced with an alternate.
The group then deliberated throughout the day Thursday, was off on Friday and returned Monday morning.
“It seems to me to send a pretty clear message that he should not be retried on the hung charges,” said John Burkoff, a criminal law professor at the University of Pittsburgh. “There is every likelihood that the next jury would hang or acquit him.”
Of course, Mr. Burkoff continued, if the district attorney’s office learns that there was only one holdout, and the rest of the panel had voted to convict Mr. Ford, that would be relevant to a decision to retry.
“But acquittal on the most serious charge means the jury was sending a clear message this wasn’t a winnable case,” he said.
Judge Machen, who heard summary traffic charges as part of the trial, found Mr. Ford guilty of one count of failing to yield at a stop sign and guilty of careless driving. He found him not guilty of a second stop sign count.
At the end of the day, Mr. Malone reargued a previous motion made to the court asking for a judgment of acquittal, saying that the prosecution failed to prove its case on the charges of reckless endangerment, resisting arrest and escape. The judge said he would allow both sides to file briefs and argue the issue on Oct. 7.
The jurors spent several minutes speaking with Judge Machen after rendering their verdict, but they were escorted out of the courthouse by sheriff’s deputies and did not speak to the media.
Defense attorney Fred Rabner and Mr. Ford spoke briefly with reporters only to thank the jury for the service it rendered. There is a gag order on the case, and Judge Machen said it would not be lifted because charges are still pending.
“We’re blessed,” Mr. Rabner said.
The verdict on the aggravated assault charge could help clear the way for Mr. Ford to pursue damages against the city in the civil suit he has filed in federal court.
The lawsuit includes claims for assault, excessive force, unlawful search and seizure, and due process violations. It makes claims against police administration, too, for failing to adequately train and supervise its officers.
Among the evidence Mr. Ford’s attorneys hope to use in the case is a report by the police department's Critical Incident Review Board, which found that the officers involved in the traffic stop violated a number of internal police policies and procedures in how they handled the traffic stop.
“We believe this situation could have been avoided had the officers followed training and protocol, and Mr. Leon Ford followed the lawful instructions of the officers,” the board wrote.
Mr. Burkoff said he believes the criminal verdict will have a “pretty significant” impact on the civil case.
“Cases like these usually settle,” Mr. Burkoff said. “It certainly puts more weight on the scale for Mr. Ford’s case than the city’s.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.