VWH Campbell, Post-Gazette photos
The feeding area at the Pymatuning Reservoir spillway is solid with carp as they fight for food.
By Caitlin Cleary
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
LINESVILLE -- The carp are feeding again at the Spillway, and it is an awesome, fearsome sight.
Giant swells rock the thick soup of carp as they jockey for position, their yellow lips opening and closing at the surface -- thousands of O's waiting for the chunks of soggy white bread, buns and bagels to rain down on them from the outstretched hands of delighted crowds.
Every year, more than 300,000 visitors flock to the Pymatuning State Park's Spillway, a freakish kink in the aquatic food chain where humans toss copious amounts of bread products to carp, an ugly bottom-feeder that, under normal conditions, would be sucking up zooplankton and larvae along the lake floor.
The carp are arguably the biggest tourist attraction at the Crawford County park. Fascinated family members lean over the crumbling concrete overlook, heaving week-old spheres of crusty Italian in an effort to stump the carp and aiming their video cameras at the ensuing feeding frenzy.
As far as the carp of Pymatuning Reservoir are concerned, every day is a feast day, and today is the greatest day of gluttony ever.
It is also the last. Starting tomorrow, construction crews will close off the Spillway until next year, part of a long-awaited $2.7 million state renovation project that will stabilize the shoreline, replace pit latrines with modern toilet facilities, upgrade the areas for food and souvenir sales and build shaded seating for wildlife viewing.
"I can't believe we get the people we do," said park manager Pete Houghton, who described the current facilities as "just terrible."
Mr. Houghton hopes to have the Spillway reopened for Memorial Day 2007.
So the gravy train is over; the carp are going on a low-carb diet. Tomorrow, when the crowds disappear and take their bounteous loads of white bread with them, will the fish remember the good old days? No longer able to get by on their good looks and the kindness of strangers, the carp will no doubt swim into deeper waters and forage for their natural diet.
On a cool and windy day last week, the Spillway was clogged with carp and tourists, just as it has been for more than half a century.
"It's like the eighth wonder of the world," said John Valentic, of Perrysville, Ohio, as his teenage sons emptied trash bags full of stale bread into the water below. Mr. Valentic's aunt, 91-year old Carmelita, of Ashtabula, Ohio, leaned up out of her wheelchair and lobbed a loaf over the wall of the overlook, laughing with glee at the fin-slapping fracas she had created.
Every year, the Valentic family takes a vacation during the week of July 4 and makes the drive to Pymatuning, clearing out bakeries along the way. For 15-year-old Christopher Valentic, there are big ideas at work in the Spillway: the dramas of nature, of hunger, of desire and the feeling of human omnipotence.
"There's one piece of bread, and a million fish," he explained as he squished scraps of bread together into "breadballs."
"And one fish is going to get the bread. There's a million open mouths all pointing at you, expecting something."
The Spillway, on a causeway two miles south of Linesville, has been a tourist destination since the 1930s. Before the Spillway's construction was even complete, carp gathered in the area's shallow, rushing waters to feed, and the people followed.
At times, the carp have been so thick in the water that ducks are able to walk across the fishes' backs to grab their share of bread. Local businesses capitalized on this spectacle, and it was adopted as the community's promotional slogan -- "Where the Ducks Walk on the Fish."
As a rule, Pennsylvania state parks forbid the feeding of wildlife, said Mr. Houghton. The Spillway is the one exception.
"Why are we feeding fish? A lot of local people have jobs associated with it," he said. "It's something that we at state parks don't condone; we don't want people to artificially feed the wildlife -- that's where the fine line comes in. We're certainly not going to shut down something that important to the community."
Carp don't get much respect from local fishermen.
"They're big, ugly and don't taste good," said Nathaniel Poff, 14, who works at Poff's Place, his family's bait shop just up the road in Linesville. Some people use carp as turtle bait, he said, but not many fishermen bother, "unless they're a little kid and they want to catch a big fish."
Nathaniel allowed that a few people might enjoy carp meat.
"It could taste good because it's got all the bread in it," he said.
On Thursday, the Spillway was littered with empty plastic bags and twist ties. The loud sucking sound of thousands of carp mouthing at the surface competed with the honks of geese.
Water lapped at the sloping sides of the reinforced rock shoreline, which was dotted with scraps of hot dog buns that never quite reached their targets. Carp swam up to the edge of the rocks, trying in vain to flop out of the water and grab the bread.
For Ken Segner of Aliquippa, there is a right and a wrong technique to feeding the Spillway carp. He scoffed at the novices who tear up one slice of white bread into little bits for the fish. Carp enjoy a challenge, and onlookers enjoy a show.
"You ought to see the bread they're going to get," said Mr. Segner as his 16-year old nephew, Brad Vitale, went out to the parking lot to retrieve more bread from his SUV, which was filled to the roof with it. "Hard, crusty Italian bread. It's too big, and it floats too much, like a beach ball. It'll take 'em at least two to three minutes of playing volleyball with it. It makes the kids have more fun, I think."
Mr. Segner, who works for a bread company and gets day-old bread for free, typically brings 300 to 400 loaves with him for each trip to Pymatuning. He has been coming here every year for 20 years.
After Brad returned with the heavy artillery, he proceeded to stack up a high wall of bread on the overlook's concrete railing, and, at the count of three, pushed it all over at once.
The carp didn't know what hit them; they thrashed around in ecstasy, splashing water high into the air. The crowd went bananas.
"That was awesome," said Brad.
One of the carp at the Spillway surfaces for a mouthful of bread.
Click photo for larger image.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.