Pennsylvania’s centuries-old blue laws prohibited hunting on Sundays, “the Lord’s Day, except out of necessity.” Since the 1700s, state law initially restricted hunting and working on Sundays to encourage church attendance.

That all will change if Gov. Josh Shapiro signs legislation that has easily passed the state House (142-61) and Senate (34-16) to fully repeal the Sunday hunting ban.

Inroads have been made in recent years, notably the approval of three Sundays a year for hunting in 2020.

Hunting coyotes, foxes and crows on Sundays has been legal for more than two decades; the new law, if signed, will add large game animals such as deer and bear.

Advertise with us

Previously proposed legislation to overturn the hunting ban for large game had been defeated for at least the past 50 years. But as some outdoors organizations oppose repealing the Sunday hunting ban, citing safety concerns, many others point to the need to solve a growing problem across the commonwealth: deer.

“The deer herd is too big,” said state Rep. Mandy Steele, D-Allegheny, who introduced the latest Sunday hunting legislation in the House.

“The Game Commission uses science-based wildlife management practices. This is about science in the end,” she said.

Pennsylvania's growing deer population poses a danger to motorists, with some of the highest deer-vehicle accident rates in the nation.

Farmers, too, have been impacted, with damage from deer browsing costing them millions of dollars in crop losses. The large herds also have taken a toll on the state’s native greenery.

Advertise with us

Sunday hunting will help remedy those problems, according to the Pennsylvania Game Commission.

Hunters help to manage wildlife populations as well as the conservation of all wildlife on a larger scale, said Steve Smith, executive director of the Game Commission, in a recent statement.

“One of the biggest reasons hunters stop hunting is a lack of time. While no one can add hours to the day or days to the week, removing the prohibition on Sunday hunting holds the potential to add significantly more time to the hunting calendar and keep hunters hunting,” he said.

Supporters of the legislation include the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau, which didn’t support earlier efforts to allow Sunday hunting.

Farmers have faced significant crop damage and financial burdens from an overpopulation of deer, William Whisler, a spokesman for the Farm Bureau, said in a June 26 press release.

Advertise with us

Because of deer browsing, Pennsylvania farmers sustained more than $20 million in losses on corn in 2017 — the highest reported number in the nation — and more than $15 million in soybean crop loss, said the Farm Bureau, citing estimates from the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Not everybody wants to lift the ban. Hiking groups such as the Sierra Club and the Keystone Trails Association that promote, protect and maintain trails across the commonwealth, worry about the safety of outdoor recreationists.

Hikers have greater and safer enjoyment of trails when they are reliably free from encountering hunting activity, said Brook Lenker, executive director of the Keystone Trails Association.

“The conflicts between these recreationalists and hunters may not prove substantial, but the heightened risk of accidents is real, and perceived or actual threats to safety or heightened noise from gunshots will keep people away from outdoor spaces they wish to explore,” Mr. Lenker said in an email.

Ms. Steele countered that hunting is a safe activity, backed by data from Pennsylvania and other states. Incidents are “so rare,” she said. “It’s more dangerous to go horseback riding. Hunters and hikers share the woods.” Ms. Steele added that she is a hunter and her family is filled with outdoor enthusiasts who enjoy hiking, biking, kayaking and other activities.

Advertise with us

She stressed the legislation is also about freedom for hunters, some of whom work six days a week.

The Trails Association has been advocating, as it has done before, to not repeal the Sunday ban. More recently it presented arguments before the House Game and Fisheries Committee after an invitation from Ms. Steele, Mr. Lenker added.

Additionally, lifting the Sunday ban is “counterproductive” for the state’s emphasis — especially under the Shapiro administration — to grow non-motorized, trail-based recreation, he said.

Awaiting Mr. Shapiro’s signature on the bill, the Game Commission plans to release information about specific Sundays soon. Depending on the timing, some of those changes could take effect for the 2025-2026 hunting season.