H omemade cookies are beloved any time of day, week or year. But they are especially treasured during the holiday season — and even more so when they emerge from the oven victorious in holiday competition.

Shared at office parties, neighborhood open houses and family celebrations, cookies are a tasty token of love.

The act of setting out sweet treats for loved ones has been a tradition at least since the Middle Ages, when biscuit-like cookies and other nibbles were shared at European winter solstice festivals. As for cookies themselves? Celebrity chef Nick DiGiovanni told National Geographic they can be traced back to seventh-century Persia (the historical name for modern-day Iran), with the cultivation and trade of sugarcane.

With so many cookies being shared by so many people in November and December, we just knew there had to be some awesome bakers in our region that deserved the limelight. So in 2021, the Post-Gazette relaunched its annual holiday cookie contest after it had been dormant for several years.

Advertise with us

It was a different kind of contest than many, in that the PG Food Team baked the cookies instead of the contestants. We also did the judging in private, first at the PG’s offices on the North Shore and then at food editor Gretchen McKay’s house. But in 2023, we found both our first-ever community sponsor and a new location to do the judging — Cafe Momentum, a nationally recognized nonprofit restaurant and professional training facility that gives teens who’ve been involved with the justice system a second chance with hands-on restaurant experience.

But alas, PG staffers still made the cookies — perhaps (sadly!) not as expertly as the bakers who submitted the recipes.

A man plays with a child as audience members, many of them finalists in the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, listen and watch the judges on Dec. 1. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Our 2025 contest, which was held on Dec. 1 at Robinson Market District at Settlers Ridge with sponsor Giant Eagle, rights that baking wrong.

For the first time in five years, finalists made their own cookies. (Whew!) And the public was invited to watch on the grocery’s second-floor seating area as judges tasted, conferred and tallied their scores.

A new year calls for fresh ideas, so we revamped the 2025 contest to include three new cookie categories: Iced, Chocolate and Filled. But we kept the category that has proven the most popular with readers and very often also comes with the best backstory: Family Favorite. The contest drew more than 60 entries over four categories, a new record.

Advertise with us

We also were thrilled to welcome a new partner into the fold, Community Kitchen Pittsburgh, a nonprofit that helps people facing barriers to employment such as homelessness, drug addiction recovery or former incarceration by offering training programs, transitional employment and job placement services.

Finalists in the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Dec. 1. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Retired school teacher Cheryl Mascia of Connellsville ended up winning the overall competition (along with the Chocolate category) with an ooey-gooey, absolutely scrumptious chocolate, caramel and peanut butter cookie that originally had  a “naughty” name. It’s so good that when she attempted to take a picture to submit with her entry, “the entire batch was eaten before I could!” she said.

Teresa Kauffman of McMurray took top honors in the Iced category for her delicate show-stopping Russian Torte Cookies. A perfect balance of sweet and crunchy, the dessert features layers of rich, flaky pastry, apricot preserves and ground nuts. She cuts the cookies into diamonds for extra flair.

We also raise our toques to Joanne Ezibe of East Liberty, who walked away (smiling!) with a win in the Filled category with a recipe for Snickerdoodle Coquito Cookie Cups. Nestled in a soft and chewy snickerdoodle cookie layer, its cheesecake-like filling is made (and was served) with coquito, a traditional coconut-based Christmas drink that originated in Puerto Rico. It was a welcome taste of the tropics on a chilly December evening.

And finally (drum roll, please!), Julie Goetz of Highland Park finished first in the very popular, very competitive Family Favorite category. She started making her recipe for Burnt Butter Cookies a year after she first enjoyed them at a Christmas dinner on an Air Force base in Panama as a newlywed. They are now a family favorite “and likely to be yours as well,” she wrote in her submission.

Advertise with us

Rules and prizes

Contestants, who had to be at least 18, were permitted to enter only one category online through Nov. 23. The selected finalists made the cookies at home and brought them to Market District, where they were judged — in real time, before the audience —  on a 1-5 point scale for texture, taste and overall appeal.

In addition to food editor Gretchen McKay, who also emceed, judges included longtime WQED producer and Pittsburgh historian Rick Sebak; Community Kitchen Pittsburgh chef instructor Missy Terrell; Giant Eagle executive chef Benjamin D’Amico; and PG staffers Hal B. Klein and Polly Higgins.

Post-Gazette food editor Gretchen McKay introduces a judging category of cookies during the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Dec. 1. At right: Giant Eagle executive chef Benjamin D’Amico, television producer Rick Sebak and Community Kitchen Pittsburgh chef instructor Missy Terrell. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As the overall Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion, Mascia won a $150 gift certificate from Giant Eagle and four fish-fry meal certificates to use during Community Kitchen Pittsburgh's Lenten Fish Fry in 2026. The other three category winners were each awarded $100 Giant Eagle gift cards plus one CKP fish-fry meal certificate and a CKP beanie. Eight second-place finishers received a certificate for one fish sandwich or “fish on a dish.”

And all participants — including the judges — walked away with a Holiday Cookie Challenge apron.

This being the giving season, the challenge once again featured a charitable component as well. Leftover cookies were shared by Community Kitchen Pittsburgh with Hello Baby, an Allegheny County program for new moms, and First Step Recovery Homes, a McKeesport nonprofit that provides transitional housing for men in recovery.

Advertise with us

From our kitchen to yours, we wish you happy holidays and a very peaceful and prosperous New Year!

Holiday Cookie Challenge Champion

Chocolate chip/peanut butter bars sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Chocolate Chip/Caramel/Peanut Butter Bars

Cheryl Mascia’s family loves chocolate, caramel and peanut butter, so when she found a recipe that combined all three ingredients, she tweaked it, and it was a hit.

It was so delicious, in fact, that when she took it into work to share for birthdays, her co-workers begged for the recipe. Only problem was, the cookie had a naughty name.

At the time, both she and her husband, Vince, were working at Southmoreland Middle School in Scottdale — he as the principal and she as a long-term sub in math. To share something called “Knock-You-Naked Bars” seemed inappropriate.

Advertise with us

The alternative name she came up with — Chocolate Chip/Caramel/Peanut Butter Bars — seemed more universally acceptable, she says. “Especially in work emails!”

Since the cookie was adapted from several other recipes she found online, the Fayette County resident says it took her several months to create a treat that she felt could be easily replicated. The caramel-peanut butter layer that’s sandwiched between the top and bottom cookie layers, gluing them together into one gooey bite, is but one example.

Mascia says she’s been known to burn herself on occasion in the kitchen, so she was hesitant to use a double boiler to melt caramels. Plus, it was a hassle to unwrap all the tiny squares “and then the kids would be eating them,” she says. One day, quite by accident, her son came home from Walmart with a bag of caramel bits. “And that changed things up.”

It also took a minute to figure out that if she placed a piece of waxed paper on the bottom of a turned-over pan and cut it to size,  she could use it to easily flip a layer of cookie dough with it face down onto the caramel-peanut butter layer — a move she credits to her early work as a math teacher.

During the holidays, Mascia serves these with other cookies, so she cuts them smaller and places them in mini cheesecake or small cupcake liners decorated for the season.

Advertise with us

For cookie layers

2¼ cups flour

1 teaspoon baking soda

1 teaspoon salt

1 cup (2 sticks) butter, softened

Advertise with us

¾ cup sugar

¾ cup brown sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

2 large eggs

2 cups (12-ounce package) semisweet chocolate chips

Advertise with us

For caramel-peanut butter layer

½ cup evaporated milk

60 whole unwrapped caramels or 1½ bags caramel bits (I found them at Walmart in the baking aisle.)

½ cup peanut butter

½ cup semisweet chocolate chips

Advertise with us

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Turn a 9-by-13-inch pan over, place either waxed paper or parchment paper on the bottom and cut out a rectangle for later use. Spray pan with nonstick spray.

Combine flour, baking soda and salt in a small bowl. Beat butter, sugar, brown sugar and vanilla extract in large mixer bowl until creamy.

Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Gradually beat in flour mixture. Stir in chocolate chips.

Spread half of the cookie dough into prepared pan (you may need to use some flour to help spread it) and bake for 8-10 minutes. Remove from oven and set aside.

Meanwhile, melt caramels and evaporated milk in a nonstick saucepan on low heat, stirring frequently. Next add peanut butter and stir until melted. (Sauce will thicken after removing from heat.)

Advertise with us

Pour peanut butter-caramel mixture over the baked cookie base.

Sprinkle ½ cup chocolate chips over peanut butter-caramel layer.

Turn out the remaining cookie dough onto the sheet of waxed paper or parchment paper. Spread the dough evenly. (Sprinkling the top with flour will make it spread to the edges easier.) Then place the cookie dough face down on the caramel-peanut butter layer and peel off the paper. Easy peasy!

Bake for 15-20 minutes or until golden brown and edges are set. Cool in the pan on a wire rack.

When completely cool, cut into small squares.

Advertise with us

— Cheryl Mascia, Connellsville

Winner: Family Favorite

(Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Burnt Butter Cookies

Julie Goetz discovered the recipe for this simple but elegant holiday cookie nearly three decades ago, as a military bride living in Panama. It has been a family favorite ever since. 

New to the Central American country, “I was grateful for the kindness of an Air Force family who invited us to share Christmas dinner,” she writes. The “Butter Riches” cookies their hostess, Gail, served for dessert were so memorable, she left with the recipe.

The next year the couple were in Miami, “and my husband’s holiday cookie request was for ‘you know, those burnt butter ones,’” she recalls. “That name, which still makes me chuckle, has stuck with us and our son and daughter.”

Advertise with us

“Calling them ‘burnt’ is part of its family lore and fun.”

The shortbread-style cookies are perfect either the day they’re made or frozen and shipped later in a cookie box. They pair beautifully with milk, coffee or tea and are so good, Goetz says, that her daughter has chosen them as her late-December birthday dessert.

The cookies, she likes to note, aren’t actually burnt — just made with browned butter. “But calling them ‘burnt’ is part of its family lore and fun.”

Suggested tools for making this cookie include a medium scoop that holds about 1 tablespoon (it’s optional but makes the work easier), and a small cup or measuring cup with a round bottom (one for 2 tablespoons or ¼ cup are ideal) for flattening and sugaring.

Goetz also suggests using the best quality vanilla extract possible and not imitation vanilla. (Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla is lovely.)

For dough

Advertise with us

¾ cup unsalted butter, softened

½ cup brown sugar, firmly packed

1 tablespoon sugar

1 egg yolk

1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract

Advertise with us

2 cups flour sifted with ½ teaspoon salt

Toasted walnut or pecan halves for decorating, optional

For sugaring cookies

⅓ cup white sugar

½ cup water

For frosting

½ cup butter

2½ cups confectioners’ sugar, sifted

1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract

3-4 tablespoons cream (whole milk may be substituted)

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Prepare 2 cookie sheets (rimless, not insulated) with parchment paper.

Make dough: Cream butter and sugar on medium speed. Add egg yolk and vanilla and beat well.

Blend in flour and salt mixture on lower speed, until just incorporated.

Scoop dough into balls with a medium scoop (about 1 tablespoon) or, using lightly floured hands, shape into balls with about 1 tablespoon of dough.

Place onto prepared cookie sheet and slightly flatten with the bottom of a small cup that has been just barely dipped first in water and then sugar.

Bake for about 9-10 minutes and remove when they’re a light golden brown. Cool and frost. Optional: top with a toasted pecan or walnut.

While the first batch of cookies is in the oven, make frosting.

Add butter to a stainless-steel saucepan and melt slightly in the saucepan over medium heat. (Using a stainless-steel saucepan helps to monitor the color change.)

As the butter melts, watch for foaming and solids sinking to the bottom of pan. Stir gently to keep solids from sticking.

When the color is a chestnut brown and the aroma is nutty, remove from the heat and cool slightly in a separate bowl, scraping all the bits into the bowl.

After the browned butter cools slightly, pour it over the sugar in a mixer. Add vanilla and blend the 3 ingredients over low speed.

Gradually add cream, mixing on medium speed, just until the frosting has a spreading consistency. (This can also be done by hand.)

When cookies are completely cool, spread with frosting.

Makes about 2½ dozen cookies.

— Julie Goetz, Highland Park

Winner: Filled

Snickerdoodle coquito cookie cups sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Snickerdoodle Coquito Cookie Cups

As a behavioral health first responder, Joanne Ezibe is out in the community dealing with a variety of crises, from domestic violence to homelessness. While each call may look different, one constant she finds comfort in is the chance to learn something new.

“The city of Pittsburgh is a melting pot of different cultures and peoples and experiences, and I am grateful to have a job that allows me to better understand both myself and the people around me,” she writes.

It was through this profession that she was introduced to coquito, a coconut-based alcoholic beverage that is a traditional Christmas cocktail in Puerto Rico. After hearing about the creamy drink, which is quite similar to eggnog, she knew she had to incorporate it into a dessert for the holidays.

After collaborating with some friends from Puerto Rico “and anyone willing to listen,” she settled on making a soft, chewy snickerdoodle cookie cup filled with a creamy coquito cheesecake.

“This cookie combines the warm flavors of the holidays with the flavors of the Caribbean, paying homage to my mom and the people I have been blessed to encounter while working in the community,” Ezibe says.

For crust

2¼ cups all-purpose flour

½ teaspoon baking soda

1 teaspoon salt

1 tablespoon cinnamon

1 cup unsalted butter, softened

1¼ cups granulated sugar

2 large eggs, room temperature

2 teaspoons vanilla extract

For coquito cheesecake filling

1 cup heavy whipping cream

12 ounces cream cheese, softened

¼ cup granulated sugar

¼ cup powdered sugar

¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg

½ teaspoon ground cinnamon

⅛ teaspoon ground cloves

⅛ teaspoon ground allspice

½ cup homemade or store-bought coquito

For garnish

mon sticks

Star anise

Ground cinnamon

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Spray two regular-sized muffin tins with cooking spray.

Prepare cookie cups: In bowl, whisk together flour, baking soda, salt and cinnamon. Set aside.

Beat butter and sugar on medium-high until pale and fluffy. Reduce speed and add eggs, one at a time, and vanilla. Beat until combined.

Add flour mixture to butter mixture and mix until just combined.

Scoop 3 tablespoons of dough into muffin tins and press down to flatten slightly.

Bake for 10-12 minutes or until slightly browned and mostly set.

Remove from oven and immediately use a small jar or container to press firmly in the center to create a well. Cool in pans for about 10 minutes before transferring to wire rack to cool completely.

Prepare cheesecake filling: In large bowl, whip heavy cream until stiff peaks form.

In a separate bowl, beat cream cheese, powdered sugar and granulated sugar until smooth. Add spices and coquito and beat until incorporated.

Fold cream cheese mixture into whipped cream and pipe into cooled cookie cups.

Refrigerate until set, approximately two hours.

Serve cold, dusted with cinnamon powder and garnished with a cinnamon stick and star anise. (Be sure to discard both before eating the cookie!)

Eat within 2-3 days or freeze for up to 2 months. The cookies will soften a bit over time. Enjoy!

Makes 18 cups.

— Joanne Ezibe, East Liberty

Winner: Iced

Russian torte cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Russian Torte Cookie

Russian Torte is a beloved treat often served alongside coffee or tea, writes Teresa Kauffman of McMurray, and is cherished for both its nostalgic flavor and elegant presentation.

It features thin layers of tender, slightly crumbly dough, spread with apricot preserves and topped with a delicate walnut mix. Cut into delicate, flaky triangles, it was probably the prettiest cookie on a very pretty contest table.

Kauffman agrees.

“It's a perfect balance of sweetness and texture,” she writes. “Even those who say they don't like nuts or fruit in their cookies will be smitten with this delectable treat!”

For nut filling

4 cups ground walnuts

1 cup sugar

2 teaspoons cinnamon

For dough

1 package dry yeast

½ teaspoon sugar (to bloom yeast)

¼ cup warm water

4 cups flour

3 sticks butter (1½ cups) (not margarine!)

4 eggs yolks (reserve whites)

¼ cup milk

For apricot layer

2 24-ounce jars apricot preserves, thinned with up to 2 tablespoons orange juice

For meringue topping

4 egg whites

1 cup confectioners’ sugar

½ cup butter, softened

½ cup Crisco or oleo

½ cup scalded milk, cooled

1 teaspoon vanilla

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Make nut filling: Mix ground walnuts, sugar and cinnamon and set aside, reserving ⅓ cup of mixture for topping.

Prepare dough: In small bowl, dissolve sugar into warm (110-degree) water and stir in yeast. Set aside.

In separate bowl, mix flour and butter like you are making a pie crust.

Beat egg yolks and combine with flour mixture, then add milk. Once combined, add yeast mixture and use a dough hook to knead until the dough pulls away from the sides of the bowl. Once mixed, the dough should not stick to your hands.

Divide dough into 3 pieces. Roll 1 piece between waxed paper to measure 10 by 15 inches on a cookie sheet. Place the first layer in a jelly roll or rectangular half-sheet pan. Spread nut mixture over first layer of dough.

Roll, then place another layer of dough on top of nuts. Top that layer with apricot filling. Roll and place last layer of dough on top.

Bake in heated oven for 35-40 minutes. Remove from oven and cool slightly; the top should be slightly brown.

Make meringue by whipping egg whites until stiff. Add confectioners’ sugar, butter, Crisco or oleo, cooled scalded milk and vanilla until well combined. Spread over the baked pastry.

Sprinkle top of meringue with the reserved ⅓ cup nut mixture and bake for an additional 10 minutes.

Cut torte into diamonds or squares when partially cooled. Place in pasty cups for easy serving.

Makes 40-45 diamonds or 80-90 small squares.

— Teresa Kauffman, McMurray

Finalists: Family Favorite

Kahlua chews sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Kahlua Chews

Kathleen Englert found this recipe in the mid-1990s in a most unlikely place: a spiral-bound copy of the “Pfaltzgraff Collector's Cookbook.”

What struck her was the fact that the sweet treat included a favorite chewy fruit that doesn’t often find its way into cookies, dried apricots.

But it was her mother, Joanne, who insisted she make it.

Her drink of choice at the casino was Kahlua and cream, the New Kensington resident recalls. Since the recipe also included a good swig of the Mexican coffee liqueur, “she knew it had to be good.”

The original recipe called for using almonds, but Englert prefers pecans, so that’s what gives today’s cookie its nutty crunch. She also adds English toffee bits instead of chocolate chips “because the Heath Bar is my favorite candy bar,” she says. “Anything caramel-y like that I love.”

Englert’s mother passed away nearly three years ago, “but her memory lives on every time I make these,” Englert says. That includes picnic holidays like Memorial Day and Labor Day in addition to Christmas.

The crunchy-on the-outside, chewy-on the-inside cookie also made an appearance on the cookie table she prepared for her daughter Nicole’s baby shower before grandson Rory William arrived in 2023.

“It means family,” she says. “Everybody loves it.”

“Her memory lives on every time I make these.”

2 cups all-purpose flour

1 teaspoon baking soda

½ teaspoon salt

½ cup unsalted butter, softened

½ cup butter-flavored Crisco

1 3¾-ounce package instant vanilla pudding mix

½ cup white sugar

¾ cup firmly packed light brown sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

¼ cup Kahlua (coffee-flavored liqueur)

1 egg

1 8-ounce package Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee bits

½ cup chopped dried apricots

½ cup chopped pecans

Preheat oven to 375 degrees.

Combine flour, baking soda and salt in large bowl and set aside.

Cream butter, Crisco, pudding mix and white and brown sugars in second bowl until smooth. Then add vanilla, Kahlua and egg, beating well.

Add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture and combine well.

Stir in the toffee bits, apricots and pecans.

Drop by teaspoonful on ungreased baking sheet.

Bake for 12 minutes.

Yields 3 dozen.

— Kathleen Englert, New Kensington

Nana’s Jam Brownie Delights sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Nana's Jam Brownie Delight

“This recipe has been a family favorite since the mid ’80s,” notes Laurie Abel. “I grew up in a teetotaler household, but every Christmas, my mom would get out the ancient bottle of crème de menthe and pour a few drops of the bright green flavoring into a bowl of white icing. My sister, Michelle, and I were fascinated, and it became our favorite Christmas cookie.”

Fast-forward to when Abel’s mom, Claudia, became a grandmother, and Abel’s daughter, Bridget, who was a very picky eater as a toddler, refused to eat any fruits and vegetables except raspberries.

Nana decided to add the raspberry jam and fresh fruit to the recipe to make it “healthy” and just like that, the Marshall resident says, “a new and updated family favorite was born!”

As for the name, Bridget — who is now 22 — could not say raspberry or crème de menthe when she was little. So off the top of her head, Abel renamed the recipe “Nana’s Jam Brownie Delight” to make it easier for all involved.

While the family really only makes the cookie during the holidays because it’s so festive, it never fails to elicit so many wonderful shared memories. Michelle, who now lives in Florida, Zoomed with Abel while she was baking the cookies for the contest. “And it was, ‘Remember this!’ and ‘Remember that!’” Abel says with a laugh.

She adds that it’s a very simple switch to make the treats gluten-free for her nieces by substituting in 1-to-1 gluten-free flour for all-purpose.

“The brownies are still delicious.”

Nonstick cooking spray

½ cup all-purpose flour

⅓ cup unsweetened cocoa powder

¼ teaspoon kosher salt

½ cup unsalted butter, melted

¾ cup granulated sugar

2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract

2 large eggs

½ cup semisweet chocolate chips

Jar of raspberry jam

Handful of fresh raspberries

1 cup white cream cheese frosting

2 tablespoons crème de menthe

Preheat oven to 350. Spray an 8-by-8-inch baking dish with cooking spray.

Whisk together flour, cocoa powder and kosher salt in a large bowl.

In a separate bowl, mix melted butter, sugar, vanilla and eggs until smooth.

Mix butter mixture with flour mixture until just combined.

Fold in chocolate chips and a handful of raspberries.

Spread half the batter into the bottom of the pan, then spread on a layer of raspberry jam.

Spread the rest of the brownie batter on top.

Bake for 30 minutes.

While brownies are baking, make icing. Mix 1 cup of white icing with 2 tablespoons of crème de menthe (or more to taste).

When brownies are cool, spread icing on top. You can use as much icing or flavoring as you like, and spread the icing as thick as you prefer.

Garnish with a raspberry and mint.

Makes a dozen brownies.

— Laurie Abel, Marshall

Finalists: Chocolate

Double chocolate peppermint cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Double Chocolate Peppermint Cookie

“This is Christmas in a cookie!” Tiffany Bicek Rice writes about this recipe she sourced from the blog inbloombakery.com. The Bethel Park resident started making them a few years ago as she and her husband, Dylan, spent their first Christmas together married.

“And it’s been a big hit ever since,” she says.

Every year since then, Dylan has requested these cookies, “and I even make them in the summer for ‘Christmas in July’ to hold us over until winter!” she says.

“It is nothing short of Christmas for the taste buds!”

The chocolatey and minty dough base coupled with the ooey-gooey chocolate chips and crushed candy canes results in a cookie with crispy edges and a soft, chewy center that just melts in your mouth.

Bicek Rice says she worried the crushed peppermint extract and candy would be too strong when she first made the cookie but instead found it very refreshing.

“It was like, ‘Oh, this is very palatable,’” she says. “It is nothing short of Christmas for the taste buds!”

¾ cup unsalted butter, softened

¾ cup light brown sugar, packed

¼ cup granulated white sugar

2 egg yolks, at room temperature

1 teaspoon peppermint extract

1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste or extract

1¼ cups all-purpose flour, spooned and leveled

6 tablespoons cocoa powder, Dutch process

½ teaspoon baking powder

½ teaspoon baking soda

½ teaspoon salt

½ cup peppermint chips, Andes

¼ cup semisweet chocolate chips

2 tablespoons crushed candy canes for topping, optional

Preheat oven to 350 degrees and line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper.

Add softened unsalted butter, light brown sugar and granulated sugar to a large bowl. Cream the butter and sugars with an electric mixer for 2 minutes or until light and fluffy.

To the creamed butter and sugars add egg yolks, peppermint extract and vanilla. Mix on medium speed for 2 minutes or until the mixture is pale in color and fluffy.

Add in flour, cocoa powder, baking powder, baking soda and salt and mix until combined.

Add in peppermint chips and chocolate chips and mix just until incorporated.

Scoop the dough into 18 balls and arrange them 2 inches apart on the prepared baking sheets.

Bake for 10-12 minutes (10 for chewier centers, 12 for crispier edges).

After baking, let the cookies cool on the baking sheets for 2 minutes, then transfer to a cooling rack to cool for 10 minutes.

Sprinkle crushed candy canes over the cookies if you wish and then serve.

Store leftovers in an airtight container for up to 3 days.

— Tiffany Bicek Rice, Bethel Park

(The Best) Chocolate Chip Cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

(The Best) Chocolate Chip Cookies

A few years ago, Noah Welter tasked himself with figuring out how to make the best chocolate chip cookie possible. It's taken years of trial and error to get it right, but the Churchill resident says he finally managed to do it with this recipe.

“They are a labor of love but one that is worth every little second of time,” he says.

The most important thing, he adds, is how they’re served. When Welter takes these cookies somewhere, he brings them as a frozen log of cookie dough so he can bake them fresh for people on site because “warm fresh cookies are absolutely a game changer!”

Weight is very important to the recipe, he advises. “Grab yourself a scale and get to work!”

“They are a labor of love but one that is worth every little second of time.”

142 grams unsalted butter (about 10 tablespoons)

241 grams flour (slightly over 1 cup)

¾ teaspoon baking soda

¾ teaspoon baking powder

¾ teaspoon coarse salt

1 bar of good quality milk chocolate (Lindt works well)

½-¾ bar 70% dark chocolate

142 grams light brown sugar (about ⅔ cup)

113 grams dark brown sugar (about ½ cup)

1 large egg

1 egg yolk

1 teaspoon natural vanilla extract

Chunky salt, for sprinkling

In a pan over medium heat, add butter and continually stir until browned.

Separately, add ice and water into a large bowl and set a smaller bowl into the ice bath.

Once the butter has been browned, add it to the smaller bowl in the ice bath and whisk until room temperature. Set aside.

Sift flour, baking soda, baking powder and salt into a separate bowl. Set aside.

Loosely chop chocolate bars into various sizes and shapes. You will want big chunks as well as small slivers to add textural variation. Put in separate bowl and set aside.

In the mixing bowl of a stand mixer outfitted with paddle attachment, cream together browned butter and sugars until lightened.

Once it’s light, add egg, egg yolk and vanilla extract. Mix again until aerated and light, about 5 minutes.

Once fully mixed, reduce speed on the mixer to low and slowly begin adding the dry ingredients until just incorporated. A few dry clumps are fine at this stage.

Remove the bowl from the mixer and use a rubber spatula to finish bringing the cookie dough together. This will prevent over-mixing (which can lead to a gluten network that will toughen your cookies).

Add chopped chocolate and mix until incorporated.

At this point, some of your dough may look a bit dry. This is OK! It needs to rest and hydrate. Separate your dough into 2 clumps, put each clump onto a large piece of plastic wrap and twist into a log that can later be cut.

Rest in the refrigerator for a minimum of 24 hours.

When ready to bake, preheat oven to 365 degrees.

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper (not aluminum foil, as we don’t want to conduct too much heat and burn the bottoms).

Cut cookie dough log into large cylinders (larger than you think — about 2 inches tall by 2½ inches wide). Place on the parchment-lined baking sheet.

Bake for exactly 14 minutes, sprinkle a tiny bit of chunky salt on top of the cookies and transfer to a wire rack to cool.

Make sure to leave the remaining cookie dough in the fridge while you continue cooking. Cold dough is the name of the game!

Best served warm!

Makes 1 dozen cookies.

— Noah Welter, Churchill

Finalists: Iced

Coconut Th”rum” print cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Coconut Th‘rum’ prints

North Side caterer Linda Iannotta won the Social Media-Worthy category in the 2024 cookie challenge with a cutout pistachio cookie. This recipe is based on a butterscotch pudding mix cookie recipe she saw in the PG a few years ago, married with last year's pistachio cookie.

“I thought there'd be an ‘Adults Only’ category, ergo the rum,” she says.

Coconut pudding mix always seems hard to find, so Iannotta grabs it whenever she sees it on the shelf, and you should, too.

“I thought there'd be an ‘Adults Only’ category, ergo the rum.” 

For cookies

10 tablespoons butter, softened

½ cup sugar

2 3¾-ounce boxes coconut pudding mix

1 egg

1 teaspoon each coconut and rum extract

2 tablespoons dark rum

½ cup coconut flakes, plus more for rolling

1 cup flour

½ teaspoon baking powder

Dash of salt

For icing

¾ cup confectioners’ sugar

3 tablespoons dark rum

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

In bowl, cream butter, sugar and dry pudding mix.

Add egg, extracts, rum, coconut flakes, flour, baking powder and salt. Mix until well combined.

Roll dough into pingpong-sized balls and dip in additional coconut. Flatten slightly onto a baking sheet.

Bake for 15 minutes. Remove from oven and press a thumbprint into each cookie with the end of a wooden spoon.

While cookies are baking, make icing by mixing together confectioners’ sugar and dark rum.

When cookies are cool, drizzle and fill thumbprint with icing.

Makes about 3 dozen.

— Linda Iannotta, Deutschtown

Italian anise cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Italian Anise Cookies

Whether you love it or don’t care for it, you can’t miss the strong licorice-like flavor in this delightful, colorful cookie.

Deborah Tony of South Fayette fell into the lover category more than 40 years ago.

Her mother, Josephine Pekular, was a clinical secretary at Ohio Valley General Hospital in the 1970s when a nurse gifted her a plate of the cake-like traditional Italian treats topped with a sweet glaze.

Tony, who was in nursing school at the time, liked the distinctive flavor so much that she asked for the recipe. “And I’ve been making these ever since,” she says.

Never mind that the cookies, known as anisette or anginetti in Italy, don’t exactly track with her family’s culinary heritage (her mother had Lithuanian roots, and her father was Greek). “I just like anything with that flavor,” she says, as well as cookies that tend to be drier.

They’re a year-round snack, in fact, enjoyed not just by family but also Tony’s friends.

While her mother sometimes made a fried ribbon-like Lithuanian cookie called zagarėliai (angel wings), “I’m not good at frying,” she admits.

But these nonpareils-covered treats? “They’re easy, and I can make them very quickly,” she says.  You can, too!

½ cup shortening

1 cup sugar

4 eggs

½ teaspoon anise oil

4 cups flour

½ teaspoon salt

2½ teaspoons baking powder

⅓ cup milk

Icing made from confectioners’ sugar and milk

Colored nonpareils, for garnish

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Cream shortening and sugar in a bowl, then add eggs and anise oil.

Add dry ingredients alternating with milk. If the dough seems too sticky, you can add a little more flour.

Roll into small balls and place on ungreased cookie sheet. Bake at 350 degrees about 8-9 minutes. They are not to turn brown; you want only lightly browned bottoms.

Make a thick glaze of confectioners’ sugar and milk. When the cookies are cool, dip the tops into glaze and add some colored nonpareils.

Makes 6 dozen.

Deborah Tony, South Fayette

Finalists: Filled

(Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Almond Croissant Cookies

Khristine Winter only recently went professional with her home-based bakery, The Kookie Shop. She’s such a great baker that her husband, Justin, pushed her to start her own business. But the Cecil resident has been baking since she was a little girl, when she cooked alongside her mother, Mary Toth.

“She’d say, ‘Grab a spoon and get in my kitchen, or get out of the kitchen,’” she remembers with a smile.

This buttery, flaky cookie packed with a homemade almond-flavored cream called frangipane is one of her favorites to make.

“I love the contrast of combining the flaky croissant with my giant signature soft cookie,” she says.

For some, this treat may be a “goal” cookie because of fancy ingredients like feuilletine, a French pastry ingredient made from thin crispy layers of caramelized crepes and the sweet homemade filling. But it’s actually fairly easy to make, so long as you have a kitchen scale (most of the ingredients are measured in grams).

The great thing about these cookies, notes Winter, is that once you’ve made the dough, you don’t need to bake them all at the same time. The balls will keep well in the freezer for up to 3 months.

For frangipane center

175 grams ground almonds

150 grams caster (superfine) sugar

1 egg

35 grams melted butter

1 teaspoon vanilla

½ teaspoon almond extract

Pinch of salt

For cookie dough

230 grams browned butter, chilled

160 grams light brown sugar

160 grams caster (superfine) sugar

100 grams flaked almonds

200 grams feuilletine or dried croissant

550 grams plain flour

100 grams ground almonds

2 teaspoons baking powder

1 teaspoon salt

5 eggs

2 teaspoons almond extract

Confectioners’ sugar, for dusting

Flaked almonds and feuilletine, for rolling

Start by making the frangipane filling. In a bowl, stir together ground almonds, caster sugar, salt, melted butter, egg and vanilla and almond extracts. (This can be done with a spatula.) Mix everything until you form a thick paste.

Pop the mixture into a lined container, then smooth out and pop into the freezer to completely set.

To make the cookies, add cold butter and sugars into the bowl of a stand mixer and get this going on a low speed until it begins to form clumpy nuggets. You’re not looking to cream anything.

Once your butter and sugar has formed small nuggets, turn the mixer down and add almonds and feuilletine, keeping it on a low speed to fully combine.

In a separate bowl, combine flour, ground almonds, baking powder and salt and give it a little whisk.

Add this to the stand mixer and again, on a low speed, mix until it has a breadcrumb-like consistency. Lastly, add in eggs and almond extract and mix to fully combine.

Take frozen frangipane from the freezer and cut into cubes. You’ll need 12 for this recipe and may have a little left over. (Or put HUGE cubes into each cookie if you prefer!)

Grab a scale and weigh 160 grams of the cookie dough. Pop a cube of frangipane into the center of each and gently squeeze to bring it together.

Roll the cookie balls in a mix of flaked almonds and feuilletine. Place into an airtight container or ziplock bag and into the freezer for 4 hours minimum, preferably overnight.

Once the cookies are completely frozen, preheat oven to 375 degrees and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Spread the cookies a few inches apart and bake for 16 minutes. Let cool and dust with powered sugar.

Makes 12 (very large) cookies.

— Khristine Winter, Cecil

Raspberry almond shortbread thumbprint cookies sit on a table prior to the Post-Gazette’s Holiday Cookie Challenge, held at Robinson Market District on Monday, Dec. 1, 2025. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Raspberry Almond Shortbread Thumbprints

This recipe was handed down to Eva Philips’ family by her Aunt Mel, an exceptional baker whose annual bake-off competitions with her mother, Kathleen, at family reunions were always the highlight of the weekend.

Our youngest competitor, Philips started making these cookies in middle school as holiday gifts for her teachers. Now 24 and an archives and special collections assistant at the University of Pittsburgh’s Hillman Library, she continues to bake for friends, family and colleagues “who support my baking habit.”

The Baden resident credits her mom for passing down her knowledge and love of cooking. It’s a valuable skill set she’s even been able to use in her work, she says. She baked a cookie recipe from “The Suffrage Cookbook” — compiled in 1915 by L.O. Kleber — for an exhibit of cookbooks from Pitt’s rare book and archival collections that she helped curate. (It’s on display in Hillman Library until February.)

“They’ve become my signature cookie. I share them at work and with friends, and of course they have a permanent place of honor on my Christmas cookie tray,” she writes. She also makes sure to save some for her former high school teachers at Quigley Catholic, who remain close family friends.

For cookies

⅔ cup sugar

1 cup salted butter, softened

½ teaspoon almond extract

2 cup plus 1 tablespoon all-purpose flour

¾ cup good quality raspberry jam (seedless recommended)

For glaze

1 cup confectioners’ sugar

1½ teaspoons almond extract

2 or 3 teaspoons water

Heat oven to 350 degrees. (If your oven runs cold, set it to 365 degrees.) Prepare baking sheets by lining with parchment paper; do not grease the sheets or paper.

In bowl of stand mixer, combine sugar, butter and almond extract. Beat at medium speed, scraping the bowl often, until creamy (no more than 1 minute, or cookies will spread in oven).

Reduce speed to low and add flour. Continue beating on low speed until well mixed (1-2 minutes). There will be dry, floury bits at the bottom of the bowl; make sure this gets incorporated, mixing by hand if needed.

Shape dough into 1-inch balls and place 2 inches apart on lined baking sheets. Using thumb, make an indent in the center of each cookie and fill with ¼-½ teaspoon jam. You may have jam left over after filling all the cookies; that’s OK.

Bake for 14-18 minutes or until bottoms and edges of cookies are golden brown.

Let stand on trays 1 minute, then remove to wire cooling rack.

Mix confectioners’ sugar, almond extract and enough water to make a glaze. Once cookies are fully cool, use a spoon or miniature whisk to drizzle glaze over cookies in zigzag pattern (or enticing style of your choice).

Let glaze harden, then store cookies in airtight container. These freeze well!

Yields 3½ dozen cookies.

— Eva Philips, Baden