When it comes to your favorite dipping sauce, time to go on record:  Do you always reach for that trusted bottle of Heinz ketchup, or do you dunk you chicken tenders and fries in ranch dressing?

That can be a tough one for Pittsburghers. When you grow up in the Steel City, there’s a certain built-in pride in knowing that the King of Ketchups (in our opinion, anyway) has homegrown roots. Spot a bottle of Hunt’s or some other brand on the table and just wait for the outrage!

So you actually like ranch dressing better? That’s kind of bold — or so I thought.

Last week, I caught the tail end of a conversation on the “Bubba Show” on 100.7 Star (WBZZ-FM) in which Mark “Bubba” Snider and co-host Melanie Taylor were taking passionate calls from listeners on whether ketchup or ranch was better. I was surprised to hear that the creamy white dressing made with buttermilk, dill and chives was the overwhelming favorite.

Advertise with us

Especially beloved by callers-in was the homemade ranch spooned up at local restaurants as varied as Eat’n Park, The Pizza Company in Munhall and (not surprisingly) Bubba’s Kitchen + Bar in Belle Vernon.

Turns out, the ketchup vs. ranch debate comes up all the time on the station, Snider told me later on the phone, because Pittsburgh is the “ranch capital of the world.”

“In my mind, it’s just gigantic,” he said. “Everyone loves Heinz, but they’re more passionate about their ranch,” in large part because you can make it at home and play with the ingredients.

It got me thinking. “Homemade,” I believe, is a pretty broad term. Does adding a packet or two of dry Hidden Valley Original Ranch seasoning mix to some mayonnaise and sour cream make it homemade? Or do you have to actually measure out the various spices, add dill and give the mixture a generous squeeze of lemon to have it considered scratch?

I guess it depends on how busy you are, what you’ve got on hand and what you’ve grown up with and are used to drizzling on your pizza and salads.

Advertise with us

At any rate, it appears Snider and crew are on to something. While a Giant Eagle spokesperson confirmed ketchup slightly outpaces ranch dressing in sales, nationally, ranch kicked ketchup’s butt in 2024 — $1.3 billion in sales compared to ketchup's $833 million. Ouch.

All my grandkids are crazy about “dip dip,” their name for ketchup. And I love it, too, especially on burgers and fries. But when it comes to crispy, crunchy chicken strips,  ranch wins hands down as the preferred condiment.

For this (truly) homemade recipe, I took the advice Bubba offered his radio audience, and used whole buttermilk to add that signature tangy flavor — specifically, Charlie’s Old Time Buttermilk from Penn Hills-based Turner’s Dairy (it contains butter flakes), as recommended.

Anything less than that, Snider said, “and nope!”

I used another favorite, Duke’s Mayonnaise, and Greek yogurt for the marinade.

Advertise with us

For chicken

1 cup whole buttermilk

1½ teaspoons salt

Pinch of cayenne pepper

Pinch of garlic powder

Advertise with us

Pinch of paprika

1 pound boneless chicken breast, cut into strips

Vegetable oil, for frying

For breading

1 cup all-purpose flour

Advertise with us

1½ teaspoons baking powder

1 heaping teaspoon salt

½ teaspoon black pepper

½ teaspoon garlic powder

½ teaspoon paprika

Advertise with us

For ranch dressing

½ cup sour cream or whole milk Greek yogurt

¼ cup mayonnaise

4 tablespoons buttermilk

1 teaspoon dried dill

Advertise with us

1 teaspoon fresh lemon juice

1 teaspoon distilled white vinegar

½ teaspoon garlic powder

¼ teaspoon onion powder

Salt and pepper, to taste

Advertise with us

1 tablespoon chopped fresh chives, optional

1 tablespoon chopped fresh dill, optional

Marinate chicken: In a large sealable plastic bag, combine buttermilk, salt, cayenne pepper, garlic powder and paprika. (You can also mix in a bowl and add to the sealable bag.) Add chicken, seal the bag tightly and massage the chicken until it is evenly coated with buttermilk mixture. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours and up to 24 hours.

Prepare dressing: In a large bowl, stir together sour cream or yogurt, mayonnaise and buttermilk. Add dill, lemon juice, vinegar and garlic and onion powder, and whisk until well combined. Season to taste with salt and pepper, and if desired, add chopped chives and dill. Refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before using to allow the flavors to meld.

Prepare breading: In a large bowl, combine flour, baking powder, salt, pepper, garlic powder and paprika. Whisk until well blended.

Advertise with us

When ready to cook, line a baking sheet with parchment. Remove the chicken strips from the marinade a few at a time and toss in the breading mixture. Use your fingers to gently press the breading firmly to the chicken. Set breaded tenders on the prepared baking sheet.

Line a plate with paper towels and set next to the stove. Add enough oil to a large, high-sided pot to reach about ¾ of an inch. Heat over medium-high heat until oil is shimmering.

Using tongs, place several chicken strips in the hot oil, being careful not to crowd the pan. Cook until golden brown on the bottom side, 3-4  minutes, then flip and cook until the second side is also golden, a few minutes more.

Remove cooked tenders to the paper towel-lined baking sheet to drain. Fry remaining chicken in batches, adding more oil and adjusting the heat as necessary.

Serve hot or warm, with ranch dressing for dipping.

— Gretchen McKay, Post-Gazette