PG tested

Mac­a­roni and cheese has been an Amer­i­can fa­vor­ite since at least 1802 when Pres­i­dent Tho­mas Jef­fer­son is said to have served “a pie called mac­a­roni” made from im­ported mac­a­roni and Parme­san cheese at a state din­ner at Mon­ti­cello. It’s easy to see why — You can mix and match so many of your fa­vor­ite cheeses, and the but­tered bread crumb crust is a good way to use up stale loaves.

This rec­ipe pairs ched­dar with creamy, smoked gouda and Spa­nish pa­prika for a rich, smoky fla­vor. Panko bread crumbs add crunch.

Left­overs (un­likely!) can be stored in the fridge; bring to room tem­per­a­ture be­fore re­heat­ing in a 300-de­gree oven with the dish cov­ered in foil. This dish would make a great Easter side. Steel City Salt Co. in the Strip Dis­trict of­fers sev­eral va­ri­et­ies of smoked salt.

Advertise with us

2 ta­ble­spoons un­salted but­ter

1 large shal­lot, diced

1 tea­spoon Di­jon mus­tard

Salt

2 tablespoons flour

Advertise with us

2 cups whole milk

1 large fresh thyme sprig

6 ounces sharp ched­dar, freshly grated

6 ounces smoked Gouda, finely chopped

1 tea­spoon Spa­nish smoked pa­prika

Advertise with us

Dash of Worces­ter­shire sauce

Dash of hot sauce or more to taste

Freshly ground black pep­per

Cook­ing spray

1½ cups el­bow mac­a­roni

Advertise with us

1 tablespoon salt

1 ta­ble­spoon ol­ive oil

1 cup panko bread crumbs

¼ cup grated Parme­san cheese

½ tea­spoon smoked salt

Advertise with us

1 tea­spoon fresh thyme leaves

Melt but­ter in a me­dium sauce­pan over me­dium heat. Add shal­lot and a pinch of salt and cook, stir­ring oc­ca­sion­ally for 5 min­utes. Add flour and cook, stir­ring con­stantly for 2 min­utes or un­til it browns slightly. Stir in mus­tard.

Add milk while stir­ring con­stantly. Cook, con­tin­u­ing to stir con­stantly for 2 to 3 min­utes or un­til sauce is smooth and bub­bling. Add thyme. Reduce heat to low and sim­mer for 10 min­utes.

While sauce is sim­mer­ing, bring a large pot of wa­ter over high heat to roll­ing boil. Add mac­a­roni and 1 ta­ble­spoon salt to wa­ter, re­duce heat to me­dium, and cook, stir­ring oc­ca­sion­ally, to a gen­tle boil for 10 min­utes or un­til al dente. Remove from heat and drain into a col­an­der. Pre­heat oven to 400 de­grees and spray a 1½-quart bak­ing dish with cook­ing spray and set aside.

Pour oil into large mix­ing bowl. While mac­a­roni is still hot, trans­fer to bowl and stir well un­til thor­oughly coated. Add half of ched­dar and Gouda cheeses to bowl and stir to com­bine.

Advertise with us

Remove and dis­card thyme sprig as sauce is sim­mer­ing on stove. Add re­main­ing ched­dar and Gouda cheeses and con­tinue cook­ing and stir­ring con­stantly un­til cheese has melted. Stir in Worces­ter­shire and hot sauces. Sea­son to taste with salt and pep­per.

Remove sauce­pan con­tain­ing the warm cheese sauce from heat. Fold the sauce into the bowl con­tain­ing the mac­a­roni and cheese mix­ture and then trans­fer the mix­ture to pre­pared dish.

Com­bine panko, Parme­san cheese, thyme and smoked salt in a small bowl and sprin­kle the mix­ture evenly over top of mac and cheese. Bake for 30-45 min­utes, or un­til lightly browned on top and bub­bling at edges. Remove from oven and serve hot.

Makes 6 side dish serv­ings or 3 en­tree serv­ings.

— Adapted from “Ap­pa­la­chian Cook­ing” by John Tul­lock (Coun­try­man Press, March 2018, $23)