Streams of American crows practically match the blue and black clouds a half-hour before sunset by Petersen Events Center in Oakland.
The black birds stream and swirl like smoke on the horizon as they make their way to a communal roost for safety and warmth.
This wintertime ritual has been recorded for more than two decades in Pittsburgh. Tens of thousands of crows start roosting together at night in Oakland before Christmas, later touching down in the Hill District, Downtown, North Shore and elsewhere. Recently they swarmed the tops of Downtown buildings, including the Old Allegheny County Jail on Ross Street. The flocks break up in February.
In winter, this member of the Corvid family hunches down, spaced a beak away from each other, sleeping high in tall treetops, on building roofs and elsewhere.
Local crows are joined by others who leave their breeding grounds in northern destinations such as New York and Canada.
“Pittsburgh for them is like us going to Florida for the winter,” said Kate St. John, of Oakland, a naturalist and author of the blog Outside My Window.
The relatively warmer temperatures of the city is one factor that makes Oakland attractive, said Kevin McGowan, an ornithologist at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology in Ithaca, N.Y. An educator as well as a researcher, he has been studying crows for more than 35 years.
The birds sleep together to avoid the winged tiger of the night, the great horned owl. “It is the boogie man who comes at night to eat you or your children,” Mr. McGowan said.
With silent flight and sharp eyesight, owls can easily pick off individual crows, which can’t see well in the dark. In fact, that might explain their preference for urban areas that offer “night lights” to illuminate and escape from predators.
In recent decades, huge flocks have moved from the country to cities for their winter roosts.
“At the winter roosts, some information is transferred about food the next day and there is some deep social aspect for the crows that we really don’t understand,” Mr. McGowan said.
“Their continued presence in urban roosts means it must work. They are getting something they like. They keep doing it.”
Counting crows
Ms. St. John and a few other volunteers had the difficult job of finding and counting the flocks for the Audubon Christmas Bird Count on Dec. 27.
During a practice run earlier in December, she closely watched where the crows came from to reach their night lodgings in Oakland.
“I know they come from the west and they cross the Ohio River, and from the North Side and the Allegheny River valley.
“If you are high up in Oakmont, you can see them heading here,” Ms. St. John said on Dec. 22 while perched on top of the OC parking lot overlooking Petersen Events Center, UPMC buildings and the Cathedral of Learning.

As a stream of dozens of crows moved over the University of Pittsburgh sports venue, Ms. St. John sighed and said, “That’s about 50.”
The previous night, she had counted 20,000 crows.
Her numbers are erratic because the highly intelligent birds can be unpredictable. Crows will change their flight direction and roost spots based on weather, food and other conditions, she said.
Garbage dumps and cornfields are favorite places to eat, but the sites can change quickly.
“Roosting in big numbers, if the food source a bird knows is gone and they go home hungry, they awake and follow the other birds,” Mr. McGowan said. “That is part of the way they transfer information.”
A crappy job
When Ms. St. John is doing fieldwork to prepare for the bird count, she often revisits the same areas where crows roosted last winter. Sometimes she comes up empty.
“I’m sitting there going ‘Jeez, where did they go?’”
This time, she found the crows roosting in Oakland throughout December.
”Look how high they are flying. Where are they going? I think they are going to Frick Fine Arts [Building], but I don’t know for sure. It’s frustrating,” she said during her Dec. 22 training count.
Only a minute later, “Look, here they come. Here’s the swirl.
“For me, the trees are perfect with an average of 250 in each tree, and then I count the trees.”
The crows settle into the tops of large trees lining Fifth Avenue and around the William Pitt Student Union, Cathedral of Learning, Heinz Chapel and Carnegie Library.
If Ms. St. John wants to check her math, she will return the next morning to inspect the sidewalks, looking for their considerable droppings.
“It’s super easy. You can tell when there were a lot of crows on a tree,” she said.
There are risks, though. As she was chasing a flock in her car during the Audubon Christmas Bird Count, she said a crow “pooted” through her open window.
”Ugh! We risked getting ugly-dirty,” she said. “If you want to count crows, it’s not worth it to be underneath them.”
Smart and social
She and a few other volunteers tallied 18,600 crows during the Audubon Christmas Bird Count.
“The best counting is when they are streaming. Pick a landmark – a building, a telephone pole — and count the birds flying past that point.”
During the day, crows can fly 30 miles to find food. Ms. St. John believes some of Oakland’s crows feed at landfills in East Pittsburgh. Some head elsewhere.
“They do go to Imperial. You see them coming from the west.”
Around 2:30 p.m., the birds head back to their winter roost. They travel in stages, gathering, shouting in cornfields and other places.
“I call it the bar scene for crows,” she said.
Young crows sometimes meet mates in the large flocks made up of local birds and northern visitors.
“Crows are very social,” Ms. St. John said. “The young ones are getting to know another bird they could spend the rest of their lives with.”

Researchers aren’t sure about all of the social aspects of a crow roost, but they assume that crows, like other animals, are on the lookout for prospective mates, Mr. McGowan said.
“They might not necessarily find a mate, but they are checking to see how they rank in society. Are you a big studly male picking up a chick at the crow bar? Or maybe you wait a year or two before you make your first move,” he said.
“Stunt flying, chasing and calling seem to be important to these birds, and we have no clue how that works. But it matters to the crows.”
Flocks of crows settling in urban places became a phenomenon in the late 1990s and early 2000s. That’s when Mr. McGowan began receiving calls from municipal officials throughout the Northeast.
Nowadays, he doesn’t get many calls from concerned city residents. “It seems there’s more acceptance. It’s not such a weird thing anymore.”
It’s not because crows have changed their urban ways.
In 2025, the U.S. Department of Agriculture Wildlife Services conducted non-lethal crow dispersals in 44 states, said Tanya Espinosa, a spokeswoman for the USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, headquartered in Riverdale, Md.
Crows have excellent memories and can apply past experiences to new situations, Mr. McGowan said. Research has also revealed that crows can recognize individual human faces.
They are extremely social, especially in the winter, and family members can stay together for years.
“Crows have adapted well to the urban environment and take advantage of the resources,” Mr. McGowan said.
They will rip open garbage bags to get food.
“They learned how to do that. They are very observant, adaptable and learn how to exploit new resources,” he said.
Over the last two centuries, vast forests east of the Mississippi River have been cleared. That didn’t faze crows.
“They followed settlers to the Great Plains. They’ve always been adaptable. Now we don’t shoot them like we used to. They can get close to people and have adapted to urban environments,” Mr. McGowan said.
Breaking up the party
More than a decade ago, flocks of crows moved from the Hill District and Polish Hill to Oakland; they seemed to like the Pitt campus.
Over the years, groundskeepers have tried to distract the birds and divert them to less populated areas of the campus. The university consulted experts and deployed decoy owls, strobe lights and a loudspeaker emitting predator noises, said William Mitchell, director of facilities services.
“Crows are very smart birds that get used to our tactics and we have to change them up,” said Andy Moran, who has been Pitt’s senior manager of grounds for 11 years.
Ms. St. John has watched the university's efforts and the birds’ reaction.
“Crows are flexible and they learned. Although a new loud noise can scatter the birds, they often return again. “It’s like, ‘Just ignore the noise, ladies and gentlemen.’”
Mr. Moran said the distraction devices are intended to stop the crows from staying in certain trees overnight, “which causes the heavy accumulation of droppings.”
When temperatures are above freezing, power washers and a riding deck scrubber are used to clean the droppings on the sidewalks.
Mr. Moran said the high-tech devices used to scatter crows never worked for very long. “They get used to them and they are worthless.”
Loud noises like gun blasts and fireworks will disturb the flock, but they are not legal or practical in most urban areas.
Then a couple of years ago, they had a breakthrough, Mr. Mitchell said.
Clap on!
Pitt found that smacking pieces of wood together created enough noise to move the birds. Pitt carpenters came up with a “clapper” — hinged two-by-fours that seemed to do the job.
“We try to stay ahead of them and certainly stay behind them. We shift as the birds shift,” Mr. Mitchell said.
The clapper worked last year, but Mr. Moran noticed the crows were getting used to the noise.
“You have to change up the sound because they will just laugh at you,” he said.
So, they now use metal dust pans and air horns in some areas and strobe flashlights near student housing.
“I think we’ve had some success over the years. But a success one year could turn into an influx of crows the next year,” Mr. Mitchell said.
”We’re at a point where we understand that it’s a part of the ecosystem that is going to occur. Acceptance and preparation are the keys to how we manage the crow population.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.