Lake Wilma does not inspire much awe at first glance. It covers just 19 acres, making it more a pond than a lake.
It wouldn’t necessarily even be open to the public if not for the fact that Duke Lake, once the centerpiece of nearby Ryerson Station State Park in Greene County, had to be drained 20 years ago when its dam was found to be cracked and leaking.
But — and pick your cliché here: Looks can be deceiving, beauty is only skin deep, don’t judge a book by its cover — there’s more to Lake Wilma if you’re a bass fisherman.
“I’d love to fish that if I lived closer,” said Gary Smith, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission’s Area 8 fisheries manager, based out of Somerset.
It’s no wonder. He and his crew sampled the lake last year, using standard electroshocking techniques to monitor bass in particular. That involves floating in a boat along the shoreline and sending a mild electrical current into the water to temporarily stun fish without harming them. When they float to the surface, biologists collect them in nets, document them by length and sometimes weight, then return them to the water.
When they’re done, biologists calculate the total number of bass handled per hour of electroshocking, as well as the number of bass 12 and 15 inches and longer. That data allows for comparing a lake’s productivity over time, as well as relative densities from lake to lake.
‘It was amazing’
Wilma, by every measure, gave up tremendous amounts of largemouth bass. In 49 minutes of work, biologists got 247. That works out to about 300 per hour.
To put that into perspective, the Fish and Boat Commission considers a bass fishery to be good if it generates 35 fish per hour, with seven per hour exceeding 12 inches and two per hour exceeding 15.
“We filled up tubs with bass, then we’d have to stop the process and handle those because we couldn’t even finish one half of the lake,” Smith said. “Then, we’d start again.”
“What really stands out is that of the 247 bass we collected, 184 of them were 12 inches or greater. It was amazing.”
On a 12-inch fish per-hour basis, that ranks Lake Wilma’s bass population as the best in the 10-county Area 8, which stretches from the Ohio line east to Somerset and from the West Virginia line north into parts of Butler and Armstrong counties, Smith said.
“It may be the highest in the state,” he added. “It’s definitely in the top 1%. It was incredible. There were just legal bass everywhere.
“I don’t think I’ll say anything better than that in the rest of my career.”
For all that, Lake Wilma is a bit of a “you can’t get there from here” kind of fishery. You don’t happen there by accident. Owned by Core Natural Resources (formerly Consol Energy) but open to public fishing, it’s located about 18 miles south of Waynesburg. Lake Wilma is probably easiest reached by driving to Blacksville, W.Va., then turning north back into Pennsylvania.
But if you make the trip and are willing to fish from shore (no boats are permitted), the fishing can be worth the effort.
If that’s too much or too far, though, there are other options. One seldom-discussed secret is that some of the thickest populations of largemouth bass in Western Pennsylvania are found in smaller waters, many of them best known for being stocked with trout in spring.
Some allow small boats — canoes, kayaks and cartoppers, but no really big boats, which keeps tournament anglers away. Some don’t allow boats at all. Some offer lots of great shore access; some don’t. Some have facilities, from picnic tables to playgrounds, if you take the family along. Others are more spartan.
But all can be worthwhile.
Westmoreland County spots
In Westmoreland County, there’s Mammoth Lake near Mount Pleasant, Upper and Lower Twin Lakes near Greensburg and Acme Dam near Acme.
Of those, Mammoth really stands out. When the Fish and Boat Commission last surveyed it a handful of years ago, it produced 267 bass per hour, not far off Lake Wilma’s pace.
Of course, numbers alone don’t matter. Fish and Boat biologist Mike Depew said then that such numbers aren’t “great if the fish aren’t big.”
But Mammoth is home to lots of big bass, too. It churned out 85 fish per hour exceeding 12 inches and 30 per hour exceeding 15 when last examined. Some were far bigger: Crews saw numerous bass of 6 and 7 pounds, and even one 23-incher that topped 10 pounds. That wasn’t far off the state record of 11 pounds, 3 ounces.
Shore access at Mammoth is good and canoes and kayaks are allowed from May 1 to Oct. 31.
Upper and Lower Twin also both hold tremendous numbers of bass based on past surveys, though Lower Twin is the only one that consistently gives up many fish longer than 15 inches. There have been angler reports of bass topping 6 pounds and more there, too.
Shore access is good at both lakes, though no private boats are permitted. There is a boat concession at Lower Twin.
Acme Dam doesn’t rival either of those for sheer numbers, but its bass tend to be larger on average. The challenge there is the weeds. They grow thick in Acme this time of year, making it difficult to fish, especially from certain parts of the shore. Fishing from a kayak or canoe or other small boats really helps.
Beaver County bass
Bradys Run Lake in Beaver County, 2 miles north of Beaver, can get weedy, too. At 28 acres, it’s also small, and it’s more like Acme than Wilma in terms of bass numbers.
But its bass population seems to be doing very well, based on past survey work and angler catches. Really big bass are rare —most seem to top out in the mid-teens or a little larger — but there are lots of fish in all sizes and age classes. That’s indicative of a fishery that’s self-sustaining.
There are plenty of places to fish from shore here as well, along with an ADA-accessible fishing pier. Kayaks and canoes are allowed, but you first have to get a permit from the park. They’re available at the indoor recreation center.
There are likewise two lakes in Indiana County worth exploring for bass: Cummings Reservoir (also called Blue Spruce Lake) and Straight Run Lake (also called Hemlock Lake).
Cummings Reservoir is 13 acres and located about 6 miles north of Indiana in Blue Spruce County Park. It’s packed with bass; that’s the good news. The bad, if you want to call it that, is that they’re generally small. Though park officials report anglers getting the occasional lunker, you’re got to go through a lot of bass 12 inches and shorter to get them.
Look for the bigger ones in the lake’s coves, near shore on the northern and southern banks, where the weeds grow thickest.
Straight Run Lake is bigger at 60 acres, but like Cummings Reservoir, it’s relatively infertile. Unlike that lake, though, it’s more about quality than quantity. Bass aren’t as numerous here, but they tend to be bigger on average.
That’s not to say the lake is full of monsters. The majority fall between 11 and 14 inches, according to past surveys. But there are some in the upper teens and even the 20-inch class, too.
Anglers can put boats on Straight Run Lake, but not Cummings.
‘New’ North Park
One of the better largemouth bass waters in the region is close to Pittsburgh, North Park Lake. It’s been nearly 15 years since it was allowed to refill after being drawn down to repair the dam.
That process gave the lake a real boost called the “new lake effect.” When a lake is drawn down, vegetation grows on what was the lake bed. When water again covers it, the lake essentially gets a shot of adrenaline in the form of nutrients released by that now-inundated vegetation. All those grasses and weeds give young fish a place to hide, too. The lake gets a second boost of nutrients — basically liquid fertilizer — when that vegetation starts to die.
The peak of the “new lake effect” can last a decade or thereabouts, so North Park Lake is on the downside of that. But it is — and will — benefit for a while yet.
Its fish populations, of bass especially, demonstrate that. According to Fish and Boat surveys and angler reports, largemouth bass of 5 and 6 pounds aren’t unheard of and fish in the 12- to 15-inch range are common. Shore access is good, too, complete with an ADA pier. And anglers can put their own canoe or kayak on the lake or rent them from Venture Outdoors on site.
So with what’s left of summer, when looking for largemouth bass — lots of them and sometimes big ones — focus not on the book’s cover, but what’s on the pages inside. Or, in this case, not on the size of the lake, but on what’s swimming in it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.