Predictably unpredictable, reliably finicky, regularly erratic, faithfully flighty, dependably uncertain.
You could call crappies — pronounced “craw-pees” by some, “crap-pees” by others — any of those things within the span of one season and not be off base. Yet, from one year to the next, they’re as certain a rite of spring as you can have.
That’s what makes catching them so much fun. That, and the fact they can get big — the state record is a 4-pound, 3-ounce fish caught in 2000 — and taste so good in a fish fry.
Want to see that for yourself? Get fishing, and do it now. While crappies can be and are caught year-round in lakes across Pennsylvania, this is the time of year when they’re “most exploitable,” said Tim Wilson, a Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission fisheries manager based in Crawford County.
The reason: They’re often in the shallows — only a foot or two deep sometimes — where anglers casting from the bank as well as from boats can reach them.
Wilson said crappies typically invade such skinny water each spring in two movements that often overlap (right about now). The first, starting in about mid-March and going through mid- to late April, is sparked by heat and hunger. The second, starting in April and going through much of May, is all about breeding.
To begin, as the days get longer and temperatures climb, lakes begin warming up. But, Wilson noted, they don’t warm to the same extent everywhere all at once. Some spots, especially those on a lake’s north shore, warm up faster. The difference in water temperature can be slight, but it’s significant to crappies.
“When the water in those back bays warms just a few degrees above ambient, crappies move,” Wilson said. “And that’s a movement shallow to eat. They’re in there to feed.”
Where did they go?
Here’s the kicker, though: While you can count on crappies to go shallow seeking minnows, shiners, small bluegills, yellow perch, insects and the like, you can never tell how long they’re going to stay.
A cold front can send them back into deeper water for anywhere from a few hours to a few days. Then, when the sun comes back and the water warms, they can return, seemingly almost “on a whim,” Wilson said.
This year has been no different.
Mike Milvet, owner of Cross Creek Bait in Avella, Washington County, said anglers on Cross Creek Lake have been getting crappies since the ice went off. But they’re here one day, gone the next.
“They can be spotty this time of year,” Milvet said. “You find fish one day, then they disappear. There will be a hit day, then there may be two off days.”
The fish become a little more predictable (relatively speaking) through May, when the second movement — the one driven by breeding — starts. As water temperatures reach the 55- to 60-degree range, crappies start laying eggs. They still feed then, but are more closely associated with shallow water structure, Wilson said.
Knowing that is a good thing for anglers.
“If you can find structure, most of the time there’s going to be crappies sitting on it,” said Don Kelly, owner of Tackle Shack in Wellsboro, Tioga County, and a Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission fishing skills instructor for about a decade.
“If you’ve got a nice rocky shoreline or some timber or some aquatic vegetation along the shoreline, you’re definitely going to see some crappies in there, coming in to lay some eggs. And before they lay eggs, they’ll be in there feeding, too,” he said.
Gearing up
Catching those fish doesn’t necessarily require a lot of special equipment, either.
Allan Schreffler, a Fish and Boat Commission education specialist who recently did a crappie fishing seminar with Kelly, said the same setup anglers use for trout — a light or ultralight 6- to 7-foot rod spooled with 4-pound test — is typically good. Anything too heavy, he noted, can rip a hook right through a crappie’s lip. That’s why they’re called “papermouths.”
“That light action rod is going to help you feel the bite, hook them and then fight them better overall,” Schreffler said.
That rig — paired with a fathead minnow on a size 6 to 8 octopus-style hook under a thin pencil- or cigar-shaped bobber — is as tried and true a crappie-catching technique as any. But it requires using monofilament line rather than fluorocarbon line. The latter sinks.
“If you’re running a full line of fluorocarbon, what’s going to happen is that your bobber is floating out there, and the line between the tip of your rod and the bobber is actually sinking beneath the water,” Kelly said. “So when you go to set your hook, you’ve got this big belly in your line.”
Fluoro does have a place, however. It’s stiffer and doesn’t have the same stretch as mono, Schreffler said, which makes tying knots more difficult. But it disappears under water, so fish notice it less. That makes it good for fishing jigheads weighing between 1/8 and 1/32 of an ounce and tipped with live baits or artificials.
Best of all in that situation, Kelly said, is often to fish light-yet-strong braided line with a fluorocarbon leader.
In addition to live bait, crappies also hit a variety of artificial lures. With those, color matters — at least until it doesn’t.
“Chartreuse and pink are the hotter colors,” Milvet said. “Some use just a jig with a chartreuse or pink tail.”
Chartreuse is Kelly’s go-to color as well, followed by white and then pink. But sometimes it pays to experiment, he said. The color that caught fish one day, or even an hour ago, might not be the one the fish want later. So he gives himself options.
“I like something that’s natural looking to mimic the forage base and something bright just to catch their attention,” he said.
Tipping a jig or lure with a dough-style paste bait or a scented bait is an option, too. Milvet said anglers had a lot of success on Cross Creek with those last year; there’s been less talk of them so far this year.
Kelly said he’s not sure they matter all the time. But he uses them occasionally, especially when the fish seem particularly choosy, believing they might convince them to hold onto a bait the extra split second it takes to set the hook.
Crappies also hit small spinnerbaits on occasion, tiny crank baits, topwater poppers and even flies. The ticket to getting them, Schreffler said, is paying attention to what the fish seem to be feeding on, and how, and doing that.
“The fish will let you know if you’re doing it right,” he said.
But however you go about it, get out and fish soon, Wilson said.
When lakes are uniformly warm throughout and the spawn is over, and all the shallow-water action comes to an end, crappies don’t disappear. They just move deeper, sometimes cruising more open water following baitfish. Anglers can catch them then, too, but it’s a little harder, especially for those bound to the shore.
So, while the opportunity is here, fish for crappies. Hit it right, he said, and the action can be fast and furious.
“You’re taking advantage of the nature of the fish,” Wilson said. “No matter how often catch them in same place, more keep on coming because that’s what their body is telling them to do.”
Up your crappie game
The first tool is the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission’s list of “best fishing waters.” It breaks down, by species, the places with the most robust populations of fish. They’re often places where you can expect to find bigger fish on average, too.
The list — see it at tinyurl.com/pabestfishingwaters — will point you to some of good places to try.
Just remember it’s not an exhaustive list. In Western Pennsylvania, good crappie waters not listed include Lake Arthur in Butler County, Shenango Lake and Lake Wilhelm in Mercer County, Keystone Lake in Armstrong County and Pymatuning Lake in Crawford County.
The second tool to use is the Fish and Boat Commission’s lake-specific habitat improvement maps. Those detail, for many waterways, the exact location of fish-holding porcupine cribs, rock rubble humps, stone deflectors and other habitat features. All draw baitfish, which in turns draw predators, including crappies.
To find the maps, broken down by water and county, go to tinyurl.com/paimprovementmaps.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.