Like everything else in a capitalist economy, the price of fishing bait is dictated by supply and demand. In recent years, anglers had trouble finding or affording some live baits.

As Pennsylvania’s statewide trout season begins, regional bait shop owners say product is generally available 2024, with one notable exception, and angler demand is back following a devastating COVID-19 slump.

Butterworms, a pale moth larvae used to feed fish tank reptiles that wiggles when tossed in the water becomes a hot commodity at the start of trout season. The worms are difficult to breed in captivity and availability is subject to conditions in their native Chile.

Anglers can rely on the supply and price of red worms, like these at Reddi Bait in Bridgewater. (Reddi Bait)

In February, a rash of wildfires raged through the South American country stifling butterworm exports. American import restrictions require the worms to be irradiated to prevent reproduction. During the pandemic, shipments were stopped at the Mexican and Canadian borders, and even now the butterworm wholesale business is controlled by select American distributors.

Advertise with us

This year, normally volatile butterworm retail prices have gone up only slightly. At most Pittsburgh-area shops they sell for about $7 a dozen. Mike Stabile of Tri-State Bait — recognized by the little refrigerators inside convenience stores — drives to a Michigan distributor to keep up with demand. Mike Milvet of Cross Creek Bait Shop near Avella said he maintains connections with several Northeastern distributors to keep butterworm customers happy.

Mealworms, another pet food, are generally packaged for anglers at about $2 for 20, $3.50 for 36 worms. Maggots, another beetle larva, can be picked up for about 50 for $3.25.

Trout see the ubiquitous red worm and nightcrawler only when they are washed into the water during a hard rain. But because they’re stinky and move a lot, they’re generally considered a good live bait. During the pandemic, crawlers couldn’t get into the United States because many truckers carrying product from Canadian worm farms refused to cross the border.

Retail prices have stabilized since 2022. At Pittsburgh shops, redworms generally go for $2 to $2,50 a dozen. Crawlers cost about $4.50 a dozen, but they’re too big for trout and are usually pinched in half before rigged onto a hook. Do the math.

To slow the spread of invasive aquatic species, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission has gotten more serious about limiting the sale of Great Lakes minnows. Fatheads seined from Lake Erie go for about $3 to $3.25 a dozen. Pink fathead minnows, or ruby reds, cost a little more, and at most bait shops shiners won’t be available until bass season arrives in mid-June.

Advertise with us

Two other considerations impact live bait prices.

Bait is relatively cheap, but there’s often movement in the price of the little plastic cups it’s sold in. Mr. Stabile said his prices for most items went up 20 cents this year when his cost for cups rose 5% to 8%.

Rick Mason, owner of Bucks and Bows outfitter in Gibsonia, said he understands the pressures bait shops are under. Some have permanently closed.

“It’s tough. We didn’t have an ice fishing season in the last couple of years, which means a lot of places weren’t bringing in money for six months,” he said.

The number of retail outlets can affect local prices. Bait shops in the Pittsburgh region that have closed include Lock 3 Bait and Tackle near Lock and Dam No. 3 on the Allegheny River in Harmar; North Park Sports Shop near North Park in Allison Park; Joe’s Tackle Unlimited just off the Youghiogheny River in Westmoreland County; and O’Donnell’s Sports Supplies off Lake Arthur in Butler County.

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.