Lake Erie tributaries (Erie County) When stream temperatures drop in autumn, steelhead fishing is mostly about being at the right place at the right time. Unlike many gamefish species, the elusive lake-run rainbow trout return to their nursery waters as steelhead and migrate upstream only when the water temperature and flow are welcoming. If a pod doesn’t pass you or there are no fish in a pool, you missed them.
Cody Shuckhart and Kevin McNeil, both of the Pittsburgh area, arrived at Elk Creek on Oct. 6, the morning after the first significant rainfall following weeks of sporadic light showers. At Brandy Run, an Elk Creek feeder stream equipped with a U.S. Geological Survey water gauge, the water temperature had dipped into the low 60s and was dropping fast. The lightly tinted flow had spiked from a seasonal average of about 2 cubic feet per second to more than 16 cfs – the most welcoming conditions for steelhead so far this season.
“The fish were moving from the main lake into the creeks,” said Shuckhart. “We had a great day … getting bites throughout the entire day [and] landing quite a few.” Fresh silver bullets were caught on nymphs, he said.
By Thursday, Elk and Walnut creeks were low and mostly clear, but the water was holding at a cool 50 degrees and the lower sections of all the Erie County tributaries were full of fish, as well as anglers. A steady flow of fresh fish was trafficking into Walnut Creek, and steelhead were pulled from Elk Creek as far south as “the tubes” spilling from under the Conrail tracks between Route 5 and Route 20. Steelhead were entering Presque Isle Bay and good size crappies and yellow perch were caught.
More rain was expected to fall on Erie through the weekend. Real-time water conditions on Walnut, Elk and other streams and rivers can be found any time on digital USGS water charts. The automated gauges, placed to detect signs of of impending flooding, can be programmed to send email alerts to smartphones when conditions are optimal for steelhead fishing. That data and weather reports, Lake Erie tributary maps, angling instructions, user-posted fishing reports and more are available at no cost at www.FishErie.com.
Pymatuning Reservoir (Crawford County) Walleye took artificial and live baits off Tuttle Point on the Pennsylvania side, and were caught while trolling at night near the causeway in Ohio.
Lake Arthur (Butler County) Largemouth bass were pulled from deep nearshore hydrilla masses using weedless lures, including Texas rigged plastic worms. Crappies took tipped jigs at about 15 feet in Davis Hollow.
Harbar Acres Lake (Butler County) Following last week’s extended season trout stocking, rainbows were caught using live minnows under floats.
Buffalo Creek (Butler County) The Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only section was scheduled to get a state stocking of rainbow trout Monday.
Ohio River (Beaver County) Weekend rain increased flow and dropped the water temperature. Outstanding flathead fishing was reported at the Montgomery Lock and Dam tailrace.
Monongahela River (Allegheny County) Dave Grudowski of Monessen wrestled a fat flathead catfish onto the cement pier at Elizabeth Riverfront Park Sept. 30. Just after midnight, the big cat clamped its jaws on a scored bluegill.
Donegal Lake, Twin Lakes (Westmoreland County) Big deliveries of trout were expected to arrive Wednesday. Stocking was planned for upper and lower Twin Lakes.
Indian, Mammoth lakes (Westmoreland County) Trout were to be stocked Monday.
Canonsburg Lake (Washington County) The state was expected to stock trout Friday.
Dutch Fork Lake (Washington County) Fish and Boat executed an extended season trout stocking Thursday.
Dunlap Creek Lake (Fayette County) Trout were expected to be stocked Monday.
Virgin Run Lake (Fayette County) A trout stocking occurred Thursday.
Dunbar Creek (Fayette County) Rainbow trout were stocked in the Catch-and-Release Fly Fishing Only section Thursday.
Meadow Run (Fayette County) The Fish and Boat Commission was expected to deliver rainbows to the Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only stretch Monday.
Laurel Hill Lake, Laurel Hill Creek (Somerset County) The 63-acre impoundment and Delayed Harvest Artificial Lures Only sections above and below the lake were stocked Wednesday.
File your fishing report and high-resolution digital photos (1MB minimum) at fishingreport@post-gazette.com. Include name, age (for under 18 years), town, species, size, body of water and details of the catch.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.