Somewhere in Louisiana, National Aviary trail cams and drones are running. In an Arkansas swamp, a lone photographer quietly trolls his canoe with two cameras going.
All eyes are on the ivory-billed woodpecker in a quest for that picture-perfect photo.
That’s the one thing hanging up universal acceptance of the survival of what either was or is the largest woodpecker in the country.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is still evaluating submitted information and has not announced a date for a final ruling on the endangered species or extinction status of the bird, said Jennifer M. Koches, spokeswoman for U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Southeast Region Office.
This is at least the third time in the last century the ivory-billed woodpecker has been written off, only to be rediscovered again.
A new peer-reviewed research paper with new drone videos from the National Aviary’s Project Principalis has enough evidence to suggest that the bird still lives in Louisiana, according to authors of the 10-year research effort.
Read More
Although the Aviary’s work adds to two other peer-reviewed research projects in Arkansas and the Florida panhandle with findings of the woodpecker 20 years ago, the debate rages on.
What about those fuzzy images of the alleged bird? If there hasn’t been a clear photo for almost 80 years, surely it must be extinct?
The bird is hard to find and get close to, searchers say. Videos have been taken at a distance and are grainy when enlarged.
“Even if you suspected or knew where the bird was, you wouldn’t necessarily find them or know where to look for them in a day,” said Steven Latta, the Aviary’s director of conservation and field research and lead author of the paper, which was published last month in the peer-reviewed journal Ecology and Evolution.
Given the bird’s home range, researchers are looking in a 4- to 10-mile territory of a suspected nest site. “That’s a huge area,” Latta said.
The bird’s swampy bottomlands habitat makes it difficult to give chase to a fast-flying woodpecker that spends most of its time in the tree canopy, he said.
“Obviously, this is a rare, elusive and wary bird. They are not in locations where birdwatchers or photographers go with regularity.”
As the Aviary continues its research project with cameras running, fans and critics have been sounding off.
The Aviary’s paper drew 152 tweets ranging from “I hope this is true” to “Look, I’m just going to toss this landmine and step away from it.”
The photo problem
Critics, including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, want a clear photo, not distant videos where only some of the bird’s field marks are visible.
“As an agency that bases its decision on science, it is important to uphold our standard of proof through the scientific standard,” said Koches. “Using that as our standard, we ask that people provide evidence that, when analyzed by others, will reproduce the same conclusion.”
The Aviary’s drone videos show what the authors identify as two ivorybills in one video and a single bird flying in a second video. The birds in the videos display the prominent white saddle that only ivorybills have. Also, photo experts have been able to calculate the birds’ size. That and field marks rule out the similar-looking but smaller pileated woodpecker, the researchers said.
That doesn’t satisfy Brett Hartl, government affairs director for the Center for Biological Diversity, a nonprofit in Tucson, Arizona, dedicated to protecting wildlife.
“The purported drone footage, the audio recordings and the narrative description of the efforts of these people are beyond implausible in their extraordinary failure to actually document an ivory-billed woodpecker,” he said in an email from Japan.
“I was on a ferry today for eight hours and was able to spot three or four endangered short-tailed albatross out of several thousand more common seabirds (and even get pictures),” he continued.
Bobby Harrison, a retired associate professor of photography at Oakwood University in Alabama, said it’s not easy to snap a clear photo even with high tech cameras.
“People who say that with today’s technology there’s no reason you can’t get good photos of the ivorybill are not professional photographers,” he said from his home in Huntsville.
Harrison has worked as a professional photographer for 53 years, with photos of wildlife published in Audubon Magazine and other national publications. He is also known for following up on an ivorybill sighting in Arkansas in 2004 with a Cornell University journalist, which sparked the Cornell research project that they said documented the rediscovery of the bird.
“I can see a bird flying down the beach and will focus and get 20 frames a second and it is tack sharp,” Harrison said. “But take that camera into a swamp with cypress and tupelo trees, that camera doesn’t know what to focus on.”
Video cameras with autofocus technology focus on large objects like trees and things with the highest contrast, he said.
“That is why most of your videos are blurry in a swamp, which is cluttered with trees and branches.”
Harrison is still chasing the ivory-billed woodpecker, with two cameras running in his canoe as he stealthily trolls through swamps in Arkansas and elsewhere.
He also has experience with technical reviews of bird videos, including the Cornell video that is still disputed. Analyzing videos is a science unto itself that requires the ability to distinguish “artifacts” — other objects — from the subject, he said.
On purported ivorybill videos, Harrison goes through frame by frame to figure out what is a bird and what is an artifact. He did such analysis for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service on his 9.8-second video of an ivorybill in October 2020 as well as Cornell researchers’ video of the bird in Arkansas.
For both, Harrison said skeptics chose single images within the video and were confused by artifacts in the images as well as lighting issues.
Ivory-billed woodpecker
Extinct or not?
Without a clear, definitive image, some do not believe the striking large woodpecker with a red or black crest still exists.
“The ivorybill is extinct. It’s time for these people to stop wasting everyone’s time,” Hartl said. There are other endangered species in need of greater attention and resources.
“If a breeding population of ivorybills still existed, there would be territorial mated pairs raising young. Those birds would be in the same spot time and time again. The notion that somehow these very large woodpeckers are that elusive even when breeding is simply impossible to reconcile,” he wrote in an email.
Latta, meanwhile, received much positive feedback from his paper along with criticism. He welcomes informed criticism and continues his work, using audio captures, trail cams, drones, environmental DNA sampling and more.
Aviary researchers base their drone searches on field sightings, audio recordings and signs of woodpecker foraging – bark stripped off trees and potential roosting and nesting cavities. They fly the drones above the tree canopy in these areas, then painstakingly review the footage looking for the bird.
Woody’s last laugh
One man has documented more than a century of searching for this woodpecker in a book.
“The ivorybill has been fooling us for more than 100 years that it is extinct. This is not new,” said J. Christopher Haney, author of “Woody’s Last Laugh: How the ‘Extinct’ Ivory-billed Woodpecker Fools Us into Making 53 Thinking Errors” (Changemakers Books, $29.95).
”It’s very common for birds to go missing for decades,” said Haney, who is president of Terra Mar Applied Sciences, a conservation research firm.
The longest interval between an assumed extinction and rediscovery is for more than 300 years, for the Bermuda petrel, he noted.
Haney said people generally have a tough time holding onto something that disappears for a long time. Then there is competitive birdwatching, where some birders can’t believe a bird is beyond their detection abilities.
“If you are an amateur and you report a rare bird, it doesn’t exist until one of the big boys or girls confirms it. That sighting usually has to be backed up by photography.”
Haney can’t say if the ivorybill still exists. However, considering current research results, he said the odds are that the bird is still out there.
“I can’t say with certainty that the one I see or you see or they see isn’t the last one. We’ve never been able to reliably count them in ways that, well, there are five or 10 over there. We have no idea.”
Not everyone is open to changing their minds, Haney said.
“If the bird is alive, you have to admit you are wrong. If you’re a top-notch, big-league birder, you were wrong.”
Top birders have to confirm sightings and get clear photos. ”Certainty is really important to birding and other sports pastimes,” he said.
But science isn’t sports. You collect data and look at statistics, probabilities, populations, etc.
“I would be more surprised to learn that it was extinct,” Haney said.
Before the Cornell study, he thought the probability of extinction was 90-95%. Cornell moved the needle and then the Auburn and Aviary researchers moved it further, he said.
Searching the swamps
On the decade-long research project by the National Aviary and independent searchers, Haney said, “These people go out year after year and might see the bird two to three times. It makes them credible to me.”
Some of the skeptics are people who watch birds in a wildlife refuge with a boardwalk, said Harrison, the professional wildlife photographer.
“They aren’t going to get into a swamp where they may get stuck for hours. They’re not going to walk in because of some snakes and alligators,” he said.
The only people frequenting such daunting environs are hunters and anglers.
“The best reports of the bird come especially from turkey hunters because they sit at the base of a tree for hours in total camouflage. They are the ultimate patient hunter,” Harrison said.
He credited renewed interest in the ivorybill to the Aviary’s paper and drone videos as well as discussion of Harrison’s ivorybill video in a recent article in Garden & Gun magazine.
”People are looking at it more closely,” he said.
“The public still needs the glossy photo so when they compare it to a picture of the bird, they can say, ‘Oh, that looks like an ivorybill.’
“However, the general public is not going to do an analysis,” Harrison said.
And they are not making the decision if the bird is extinct, he added.
“Fish and Wildlife have scientists and they should be able to look at the evidence.”
Mary Ann Thomas: mthomas@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.