Depending on how you look at it, the 2022-23 deer seasons were either a great success for hunters or part of a broader trend that has remained largely unchanged. The perspective matters among hunting camp owners still stewing over the opening day being moved to a Saturday.
The harvest estimate for the 2022-23 season, released Thursday by the state Game Commission, shows hunters took 422,960 white-tailed deer, nearly 164,200 bucks and 258,770 antlerless deer. That’s a 12% increase over the previous year’s total harvest.
As many camp owners see it, however, the stable three-year harvest average suggests a frustrating stability in the number of hunters despite assurances that the Saturday opener would sell more licenses.
“Longer-term … [the harvest was] very much in line with recent trends,” said a Game Commission statement, “with the buck harvest in particular only 2% higher than the most-recent three-year average.”
As usual, most of the 2022-23 harvest occurred during the two-week regular firearms season. Gun hunters took 251,520 whitetails including 87,190 bucks and 164,340 does. Archers with vertical bows and crossbows accounted for a little more than a third of the total deer harvest, taking 75,770 antlered and 69,870 antlerless deer for a total of 145,640. The estimated muzzleloader hunt accounted for 25,790 kills —1,230 males and 24,560 females.
A closer look at the antlerless harvest shows that 67% were adult females, 17% were button bucks and 16% were female fawns. The Game Commission reported that hunters filled roughly one of every four doe tags purchased.
Read More
In the southwestern Pennsylvania wildlife management units, the harvest was generally up.
WMU 2A parts of Beaver, Washington, Westmoreland, Greene, Fayette counties. Total 8,700 antlered (6,800 in 2021-22), and 11,000 antlerless (10,600 in 2021-22). Archery: 3,620 antlered, 2,060 antlerless. Muzzleloader: 80 antlered, 1,240 antlerless.
WMU 2B Allegheny County area. Total 6,600 antlered (5,200), and 15,000 antlerless (12,100). Archery: 4,830 antlered, 6,750 antlerless. Muzzleloader: 70 antlered, 850 antlerless.
WMU 2C parts of Westmoreland, Indiana, Cambria, Blair, Greene, Fayette, Somerset, Bedford counties. Total 10,000 antlered (9,300), and 16,600 antlerless (15,400). Archery: 4,410 antlered, 3,900 antlerless. Muzzleloader: 90 antlered, 1,700 antlerless.
Bryan Burhans, Game Commission executive director, said the new harvest figures illustrate the success of the deer management plan and ample hunting opportunities.
“We’ve been saying for a while now that this is a great time to be a Pennsylvania deer hunter,” Mr. Burhans said in a statement. “These harvest figures are the proof of that.”
In 2019, the Game Commission shifted the deer opener from the traditional Monday after Thanksgiving to the Saturday of the holiday weekend, with hunting allowed on the successive Sunday starting in the following year. The stated rationale was to increase hunting opportunities for students and workers who couldn’t take a day off on a weekday. The controversial move was seen by the agency as a way to help in countering a downward trend in hunting license sales ($20.90 since 1999), crucial because most wildlife management in Pennsylvania is funded by hunters through license sales, leases on Game Commission land and a federal tax on hunting gear.
Hunting camp participants grumble that the change disrupted their longtime camp traditions and caused rural stores to lose business. Opponents to the Saturday opener said a slight jump in hunting license sales in 2020 and 2021 didn’t reflect an increase in hunting opportunity, but was the result of people exploring outdoor recreation during the COVID-19 shop and business closures.
Members of the hunting advocacy group Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania, protested the Saturday opener at the January meeting of Game Commissioners. They have cited a relatively multi-year average in the deer harvest as a contributing indicator that the Saturday opener did not provide the expected boost in hunting participation.
“Is change a good thing or a bad thing? It’s not really a hard question,” said Wayne Haas, president of Unified Sportsmen of Pennsylvania in a group newsletter. “The real question would be if the change that was made did not result in the desired outcome, or actually turned out to be a negative unintended consequence.”
Every hunter gets a buck tag with a license purchase, and the limit is one antlered deer during the combined deer seasons. While there has been a steady decline in the number of hunters since the 1980s, the long-term statewide deer harvest has remained relatively steady. Some hunters say that suggests that the change in the opening day did not result in more license sales.
Travis Lau, Game Commission spokesman, said harvest reports may not be a reliable gauge for ascertaining hunting participation.
“Deer harvest and hunter success rates can certainly be influenced by hunter effort [as well as] number of hunters, time spent hunting, etc.,” he said. “For antlerless deer, harvest is controlled by the number of antlerless licenses allocated, and a single hunter can obtain multiple licenses and take multiple deer. So whether there are more or fewer hunters in a given year doesn’t really impact the harvest as much as the allocation does.”
For decades, Pennsylvania hunting license sales dropped at a fairly consistent rate of 3% annually, mirroring similar declines nationally. General license sales continued to plummet from 881,102 in 2017 to 855,486 in 2018, according to Game Commission data. In 2019, the first season of the Saturday deer opener, sales stopped dropping and showed a slight uptick to 860,743 licenses. Another incremental increase to 879,664 was recorded in 2020, and the sale of 857,964 general hunting licenses in 2021 was seen by the agency as relative stability. The Game Commission attributes the end of the freefall and consistent license sales since 2019 in part to satisfaction with the Saturday opening day by new hunters and returning lapsed hunters.
David Stainbrook, Game Commission deer and elk section supervisor, said the 2% increase in buck harvests over three years shows stable deer density.
“The long-term buck harvest trend indicates Pennsylvania’s deer population is in a pretty good place right now,” Mr. Stainbrook said. “We see generally stable population trends in most of the state, near goal levels, and we are seeing more older bucks available for harvest.”
In the past five years, he said, nearly one in every four Pennsylvania hunters has tagged a buck, with two-thirds of the bucks harvested being of reproductive age, at least 2½ years old.
In the 2023-24 license year, which begins June 26, hunters will be able to purchase antlerless permits ($6.70) online and wherever hunting licenses are sold, a new feature the agency believes will create more hunting opportunity and spur general license sales. Previously doe tags could be purchased only through postal mail or in person at county treasury offices.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.