Researchers from Pennsylvania State University and the National Aviary in Pittsburgh used emerging technology to prove that a bird discovered in Lawrence County is the unique hybrid offspring of two avian species that have been distinctly separate for at least 10 million years.

The bird was discovered in June 2020. Research recently published in the journal Ecology and Evolution identified it as never-before-seen cross of rose-breasted grosbeak and a scarlet tanager.

It’s not quite “Jurassic Park” because in this case, it is nature, not humans, that fiddled with the genetic code.

Stephen Gosser, an experienced birder from McCandless, was snapping photos in a wooded area when he heard a distinctive chirping, like a robin with a scratchy throat. He immediately recognized it as the song of the scarlet tanager, a species that birders like to add to their life lists because of its rarity and beauty.

Advertise with us

Expecting to see bright red and black plumage through his camera lens, Gosser was surprised to find that the bird making all that racket had an off-white belly, orange throat and gray feathers from head to tail. It looked like a male rose-breasted grosbeak but sounded like a scarlet tanager. He took some photos and reported his find to the National Aviary.

The next day Steve Latta, the Aviary’s director of conservation and field research, and ornithologist Robert Mulvihill traveled to the site with netting gear, blood sampling equipment and capture-and-release permits. Mulvihill said they located the bird in 45 minutes and played a recording of a scarlet tanager song to lure the bird into a fine mesh mist net.

“We quickly took a variety of measurements of wing length, tail length, bill length and bill depth and width,” he said. “We took several documentary photos of the bird’s plumage, and Steve collected a small blood sample. … When that was finished we gave the discoverer, Steve Gosser, the honor of releasing it.”

The data was taken to a Penn State laboratory for the analysis of photos, field observations, DNA and digital sound recordings made by professional birder Tom Johnson of New Jersey.

It was determined that the strange little bird was the healthy, 1-year-old male offspring of a female rose-breasted grosbeak and a male scarlet tanager, the first documented hybrid of its kind.

Advertise with us

“This is a fun story because there’s a little mystery in it and it shows that what we do requires a lot of luck,” said David Toews, lead author of the study and assistant professor of biology at Penn State.

The story began long ago when an avian species related to the cardinal and having a powerful beak gradually split into a variety of species including the rose-breasted grosbeak and scarlet tanager. The birds still co-occupy Eastern North America but have very different nesting preferences. Today, the birds’ ranges overlap in Western Pennsylvania. The environment and habitat are changing, conditions believed to contribute to genetic change.

Toews said it is unknown why the hybrid’s parents mated and how the offspring survived to adulthood.

“The more closely related species are to each other, the more often these kinds of mistakes happen,” he said. “But it’s genetically complicated and very rare for that type of hybridization to result in a new species. In this case it’s probably more of a dead end than it is a new beginning.”

Nevertheless, said Toews, “dead end” hybridization may have an important genetic function.

Advertise with us

“We think this kind of interbreeding is actually important for evolution,” he said. “The stuff of evolution is genetic variation, which can arise through mutation in genes or through hybridization.”

Interspecies sexual coupling is not uncommon in the animal world. Actual mating can occur among genetically related species when a suitable mate can’t be found. Successful cross-species pregnancy is less common and often results in sterile offspring or hybrids with physical anomalies leading to their death. Mulvihill said this type of hybridization is “extremely rare” and not likely to lead to the evolution of a new species.

“I feel confident saying that there is no possibility of that happening,” he said. “Hybrids typically have very poor fertility, and they are extremely rare between such distantly related species as these.”

Jim Bonner, executive director of the Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania, did not participate in the study. He referred to the Penn State determination as “an interesting documentation, but not something I would try to read too much into.”

He said current science holds that 16% of bird species may mate successfully with other species in the wild. It is more common in captivity.

Advertise with us

“Interbreeding often happens where the ranges of related species overlap,” he said. “It usually occurs between closely related species … but it can also occur between more distantly related species.

Probably the biggest takeaway is that we still don’t know as much as we could about the lives of birds.”

John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.